Protection of the African Lion: A Critical Analysis of the Current International Legal Regime

Authors

  • Samantha Watts University of Cape Town

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2016/v19i0a1158

Keywords:

African lion, international environmental law, conservation, hunting, trade, habitat loss, endangered, conventions, agreements

Abstract

This article looks at the current international regime that pertains to the African lion, a species that needs adequate protection across its range (a range that does not adhere to state boundaries). This analysis comes at a time when threats such as habitat and prey loss, retaliatory killing, trophy hunting and trade, are all impacting the remaining populations of African lions. The species is in danger of rapid population decline and possible extinction in the near future. Two decades ago there was an abundance of African lions, roughly 100 000, on the continent. But at present there are less than 32 000, while some believe there to be as little as 15 000 left. This decline is mainly due to the threats noted above. African lions are currently listed as "vulnerable" on the International Union for Conservation of Nature Red List of Threatened Species. This listing is being contested by commentators who believe that the species now requires an "endangered" status. African lion populations, and the threats to the species, extend across state boundaries. Therefore, international law is of particular importance in providing conservation and protection measures to the species. Creating conservation obligations at a global level allows for more uniform action, implementation and enforcement of legislation at regional and local levels. Therefore this article looks at each threat to African lion populations in detail and then assesses the international legal regime pertaining to each of these threats, and whether that regime is adequate. The Convention on Biological Diversity, Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species, Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora and the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance are but some of the international instruments that are analysed. This article outlines the arguments that the international legal framework is not acceptable for the protection of the species, and addresses both the positive and negative aspects of this regime. It is found that the international legal regime for the African lion is in fact not effective in achieving the protection and survival of the species. Some changes are recommended, and the best way forward through an international legal lens is outlined. The security and viability of the African lion is uncertain, and legal protection of the species needs to be clear to start ensuring their survival in the future. With the increase in threats to the species and African lions already regionally endangered in some parts of Africa, it is obvious that some legal changes need to be made to ensure greater protection of the African lion at an international level.

 

Google_Scholar_12018.png    ScienceOpen_Log034312.png

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Bibliography

Literature

Bauer and Van Der Merwe 2004 OIJC

Bauer H and Van Der Merwe S "Inventory of Free-ranging Lions Panthera

Leo in Africa" 2004 OIJC 26-31

CBD Secretariat, UNCCD and Oslo ConsortiumValuing the Biodiversity

Convention on Biological Diversity Secretariat, Global Mechanism of the UN

Convention to Combat Desertification and OSLO Consortium Valuing the

Biodiversity of Dry and Sub-humid Lands (Secretariat of the Convention on

Biological Diversity Montreal 2013)

CITES Secretariat "CITES and Bushmeat"

CITES Secretariat "CITES and Bushmeat" Presentation at the Joint Meeting

of the CBD Liaison Group on Bushmeat and the CITES Central Africa

Bushmeat Working Group (7-10 June 2011 Nairobi)

Creel et al 2013 EL

Creel S et al"Conserving Large Populations of Lions: The Argument for

Fences has Holes" 2013 (16) EL1-4

Croes et al 2011 BioCon

Croes BM et al "The Impact of Trophy Hunting on Lion (Panthera Leo) and

Other Large Carnivores in the Benou Complex, Northern Cameroon" 2011

BioCon3064-3072

Ervin et al Making Protected Areas Relevant

Ervin J et al Making Protected Areas Relevant: A Guide to Integrating

Protected Areas into Wider Landscapes, Seascapes and Sectoral Plans

and Strategies (Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity

Montreal 2010) 7-64

Estes, Atwood and Estes 2006 BioCon

Estes RD, Atwood JL and Estes AB "Downward Trends in Ngorongoro

Crater Ungulate Populations 1986-2005: Conservation Concerns and the

Need for Ecological Research" 2006 BioCon 106-120

Fitzherbert et al 2014 BioCon

Fitzherbert E et al "From Avengers to Hunters: Leveraging Collective Action

for the Conservation of Endangered Lions" 2014 BioCon 84-92

Funston "Conservation and Management of Lion"

Funston P "Conservation and Management of Lion in Southern Africa:

Status, Threats, Utilisation and Restoration Option" in Croes B et al (eds)

Management and Conservation of Large Carnivores in West and Central

Africa (Institute of Environmental Sciences Leiden 2008) 109-132

Gardener and Davidson "Ramsar Convention"

Gardener RC and Davidson NC "The Ramsar Convention" in LePage BA

(ed) Wetlands: Integrating Multidisciplinary Concepts (Springer New York

189-204

Geldmann et al 2013 BioCon

Geldmann J et al"Effectiveness of Terrestrial Protected Areas in Reducing

Habitat Loss and Population Decline" 2013 BioCon 230-238

Hall 2010 SAJELP

Hall J "Building the Ethical Dimension of the Environmental Right" 2010

SAJELP 1-21

Hargreaves 2010 JWCLAS

Hargreaves R "Countering the Moral and Ethical Argument for Canned

Hunting of Captive Bred Lions in South Africa" 2010 (3) JWCLAS 7-26

Hazzah et al 2014 CB

Hazzah L et al "Efficacy of Two Lion Conservation Programs in Maasailand,

Kenya" 2014 CB 851-860

Hazzah, Mulder and Frank 2009 BioCon

Hazzah L, Mulder M and Frank L "Lions and Warriors: Social Factors

Underlying Declining African Lion Populations and the Effect of Incentive-

based Management in Kenya" 2009(142) BioCon 2428-2437

Kabii "Overview of African Wetlands"

Kabii T "An Overview of African Wetlands" in Hails A (ed) Wetlands,

Biodiversity, and the Ramsar Convention (Ramsar Convention Bureau

Gland 1997) 29-42

Kasiki and Hamunyela "Panthera Leo -Report"

Kasiki S and Hamunyela E "CITES: Panthera Leo -Report of Kenya and

Namibia" Presented at the Twenty-seventh Meeting of the Animals

Committee (28 April -3 May 2014 Veracruz) 1-53

Kiffner 2008 ESU

Kiffner C "African Lions and the Trophy Hunting Dilema" 2008 (25) ESU 1-

Kissui, Mosser and Packer 2010 PE

Kissui BM, Mosser A and Packer C "Persistence and Local Extinction of

Lion Prides in the Ngorongoro Crater, Tanzania" 2010 PE 103-111

Lindsey et al 2012 SAJWR

Lindsey PA et al "Possible Relationships between the South African

Captive-bred Lion Hunting Industry and the Hunting and Conservation of

Lions Elsewhere in Africa" 2012 SAJWR 11-22

Lindsey et al 2013 PLoS ONE

Lindsey PA et al"The Trophy Hunting of African Lions: Scale, Current

Management Practices and Factors Undermining Sustainability" 2013 (8)

PLoS ONE 1-12

Lindsey et al Illegal Hunting

Lindsey PA et al Illegal Hunting and the Bush-meat Trade in Savanna Africa:

Drivers, Impacts and Solutions to Address the Problem (FAO New York

4-56

Loveridge, Packer and Dutton "Recreational Hunting of Lions"

Loveridge AJ, Packer C and Dutton A "Science and the Recreational

Hunting of Lions" in Dickson B, Hutton J and Adams WM (eds) Recreational

Hunting, Conservation and Rural Livelihoods (Blackwell London 2009) 108-

Matz 2005 HJIL

Matz N "Chaos or Coherence? Implementing and Enforcing the

Conservation of Migratory Species through Various Legal Instruments"

HJIL 197-215

Mrema "Lusaka Agreement"

Mrema EM "Lusaka Agreement as a Mechanism for Enforcement of CITES"

in Seventh International Conference on Environmental Compliance and

Enforcement (9-15 April 2005 Marrakech) 227-238

Nowell and Bauer Regional Lion Conservation Strategy

Nowell K and Bauer H Regional Lion Conservation Strategy for Eastern and

Southern Africa (IUCN SSC Cat SG Gland 2006) 1-32

Nowell and Jackson Status Survey

Nowell K and Jackson P Status Survey and Conservation Action Plan: Wild

Cats (IUCN SSC Cat SG Gland 1996) 1-280

Ogada 2014 ANYAS

Ogada DL "The Powerof Poison: Pesticide Poisoning of Africa's Wildlife"

ANYAS1-20

Packer and Kissui 2007 TNAWNRC

Packer C and Kissui BM "Managing Human-Lion Conflicts" 2007

TNAWNRC 1-15

Packer et al "Impacts of Trophy Hunting"

Packer C et al"Impacts of Trophy Hunting on Lions in East and Southern

Africa: Recent Offtake and Future Recommendations" Background Paper

for the Eastern and Southern African Lion Conservation Workshop (11-13

January 2006 Johannesburg) 2-22

Riggio et al 2013 BioCon

Riggio J et al"The Size of Savannah Africa: A Lion's (Panthera Leo) View"

BioCon18-34

Rose "Gaps in the Implementation of Environmental Law"

Rose G "Gaps in the Implementation of Environmental Law at the National,

Regional and Global Level" Paper delivered at the First Preparatory Meeting

of the World Congress on Justice, Governance and Law for Environmental

Sustainability (12-13 October 2011 Kuala Lumpur) 1-29

Sands and Peel Principles

Sands P and Peel J Principles of International Environmental Law

(Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2012) 1-897

Tende et al 2014 PLoS ONE

Tende T et al"Individual Identification and Genetic Variation of Lions from

Two Protected Areas in Nigeria" 2014 (9) PLoS One 1-11

Valeix et al2012 JAE

Valeix M et al"Behavioural Adjustments of a Large Carnivore to Access

Secondary Prey in a Human-dominated Landscape" 2012 JAE 73-81

Wiersema 2015 MJIL

Wiersema A "Uncertainty, Precaution, and Adaptive Management in Wildlife

Trade" 2015 MJIL 375-424

Whitman et al 2007 CB

Whitman KL et al"Modelling the Effects of Trophy Selection and

Environmental Disturbance on a Simulated Population of African Lions"

CB 591-601

Winterbach et al 2012 MR

Winterbach HEK et al "Key Factors and Related Principles in the

Conservation of Large African Carnivores" 2012 MR 89-110

Case law

South African Predator Breeders Association v Minister of Environmental

Affairs and Tourism 2011 2 SA 529 (SCA)

International instruments

African Convention on the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources

(1968) 101 UNTS 3

CITES Decision: Interpretation and Implementation of the Convention

(2010) CoP15/Doc. 20

CITES Resolution: Criteria for Amendment of Appendices I and II(2010)

Conf. 9.24/Rev.CoP15

CITES Resolution: National Laws for Implementation of the Convention

(1992) Conf. 8.4/Rev.CoP8

CITES Resolution: Review of Significant Trade in Specimens of Appendix

II Species (2004) Conf.12.8/Rev.CoP13

CMS Draft Resolution: Conservation and Management of the African Lion,

Panthera Leo (2014) UNEP/CMS/COP11/CRP4

CMS Proposal: Proposal for the Inclusion of the Lion (Panthera Leo) in CMS

Appendix II (2014) UNEP/CMS/COP11/Doc.24.1.2/Rev.1

Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural

Heritage (1972) 11 ILM 1358

Convention on Biological Diversity (1992) 31 ILM 818

Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna

and Flora (1973) 12 ILM 1085

Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals

(1980) 19 ILM 15

Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain

Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade (1999) 38 ILM

Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as

Waterfowl Habitat (1972) 11 ILM 963

Lusaka Agreement on Co-operative Enforcement Operations Directed at

Illegal Trade in Wild Fauna and Flora(1994) 1950 UNTS 35

Southern African Development Community Protocol on Wildlife

Conservation and Law Enforcement(2003)

UN Convention to Combat Desertification in Those Countries Experiencing

Serious Drought and/or Desertification, Particularly in Africa (1994) 33 ILM

Internet sources

Anon 2005 http://www.huntingreport.com/images2/pdf/Final_Draft_Panel_

of_ Expert_Report_to_DEAT.pdf

Anon 2005 Report to the Minister of Environmental Affairs and Tourism

http://www.huntingreport.com/images2/pdf/Final_Draft_Panel_of_Expert_

Report_to_DEAT.pdf accessed 6 September 2014

Bauer 2003 http://www.carnivoreconservation.org/files/thesis/bauer_2003_

phd.pdf

Bauer H 2003 Lion Conservation in West and Central http://www.ca

rnivoreconservation.org/files/thesis/bauer_2003_phd.pdf accessed 7

September 2014

Bauer, Nowell and Packer 2014 http://www.iucnredlist.org/details/15951/0

Bauer H, Nowell K and Packer C 2014 Panthera Leo IUCN Red List of

Threatened Specieshttp://www.iucnredlist.org/details/15951/0 accessed

August 2014

Braun 2012 http://newswatch.nationalgeographic.com/2012/12/06/lion-

numbers-plunge-as-african-wilderness-succumbs-to-human-pressure/

Braun D 2012 Lion Numbers Plunge as African Wilderness Succumbs to

Human Pressurehttp://newswatch.nationalgeographic.com/2012/12/06/

lion-numbers-plunge-as-african-wilderness-succumbs-to-human-pressure/

accessed 8 August 2014

CBD 2014http://www.cbd.int/information/parties.shtml

CBD 2014 List of Parties http://www.cbd.int/information/parties.shtml

accessed 6 August 2014

CITES 2004 http://www.cites.org/common/cop/13/raw_props/KE-Lion.pdf

CITES 2004 Consideration of Proposals for Amendment of Appendices I

and IIhttp://www.cites.org/common/cop/13/raw_props/KE-Lion.pdf

accessed 7 October 2014

CITES 2012 http://bit.ly/1RXSRL5

CITES 2012 Trade Database: Comparative Tabulation Report

http://bit.ly/1RXSRL5 accessed 7 September 2014

CITES 2012 http://cites.org/sites/default/files/eng/notif/2012/E036.pdf

CITES 2012 National Law for Implementation of the Convention

http://cites.org/sites/default/files/eng/notif/2012/E036.pdf accessed 7

October 2014

CITES 2014 http://www.cites.org/eng/disc/ac_pc.php

CITES 2014 Animal Committee http://www.cites.org/eng/disc/ac_pc. php

accessed 6 August 2014

CMS 2014 http://www.cms.int/en/meetings/standing-committee

CMS 2014 Standing Committeehttp://www.cms.int/en/meetings/standing-

committee accessed 26 November 2014

CMS 2014 http://www.cms.int/en/parties-range-states

CMS 2014 Parties and Range States http://www.cms.int/en/parties-range-

states accessed 7 October 2014

Director: Wildlife Trade Regulation 2014 http://www.environment.gov.au/

biodiversity/wildlife-trade/comment/stricter-measures-import-export-

african-lion

Australian Government: Department of Environment,Director: Wildlife

Trade Regulation 2014 Proposal to Take Stricter Domestic Measures to

Regulate the Import and Export of Specimens of African Lion

http://www.environment.gov.au/biodiversity/wildlife-trade/comment/stricter-

measures-import-export-african-lion accessed 25 November 2014

IUCN 2014 http://www.iucnredlist.org/static/categories_criteria_2_3

IUCN 2014 1994 Categories and Criteria Version 2.3

http://www.iucnredlist.org/static/categories_criteria_2_3 accessed 10

August 2014

IUCN 2014 http://maps.iucnredlist.org/map.html?id=15951

IUCN 2014 Species Rangehttp://maps.iucnredlist.org/map.html?id=15951

accessed 6 October 2014

IUCN SSC Cat SG 2006 http://www.conservationforce.org/pdf/C_W_Lion_

Strategy_UK.pdf

IUCN SSC CatSG 2006 Conservation Strategy for the Lion in West and

Central Africa

http://www.conservationforce.org/pdf/C_W_Lion_Strategy_UK.pdf

accessed 7 October 2014

KWS 2014 http://www.kws.org/about/index.html

KWS 2014 Overview: About Us http://www. kws.org/about/index.html

accessed 7 October 2014

Lenarz 2014 http://www.cms.int/en/news/global-protection-proposed-

sharks-rays-sawfish-polar-bear-and-lions

Lenarz V 2014 Global Protection Proposed for Sharks, Rays, Sawfish, Polar

Bear and Lions http://www.cms.int/en/news/global-protection-proposed-

sharks-rays-sawfish-polar-bear-and-lions accessed 7 October 2014

Lion Guardians 2014 http://lionguardians.org/our-tools

Lion Guardians 2014 Our Tools http://lionguardians.org/our-tools accessed

October 2014

Lusaka Agreement 2014 http://www.lusakaagreement.org

Lusaka Agreement 2014 Task Force http://www.lusakaagreement.org

accessed 16 November 2014

Macleod 2012 http://mg.co.za/article/2012-07-12-officials-turn-a-blind-eye-

to-the-smuggling-of-wild-lions

Macleod F 2012 Officials Turn a Blind Eye to the Smuggling of Wild Lions

http://mg.co.za/article/2012-07-12-officials-turn-a-blind-eye-to-the-

smuggling-of-wild-lions accessed 26 November 2014

Macsween 2014 http://www.lionaid.org/news/2014/04/the-cites-draft-

periodic-review-on-lions-is-a-disgrace-and-could-do-great-damage-to-

lions.htm

Macsween C 2014 The CITES Draft Periodic Review on Lions is Disgrace

and Could Do Great Damage to Lionshttp://www.lionaid.org/

news/2014/04/the-cites-draft-periodic-review-on-lions-is-a-disgrace-and-

could-do-great-damage-to-lions.htm accessed 7 October 2014

Parker 2012 http://mg.co.za/article/2012-07-04-sa-breeders-embrace-

growing-asian-demand-for-lion-bones

Parker F 2012SA Breeders Embrace Growing Asian Demand for Lion

Bones http://mg.co.za/article/2012-07-04-sa-breeders-embrace-growing-

asian-demand-for-lion-bones accessed 12 November 2014

Parry 2015 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3190750/One-Cecil-

lion-s-cubs-killed-rival-male-sparking-fears-remaining-seven-just-days-left-

live-beast-slaughtered-dentist.html

Parry H 2015 One of Cecil's Cubs is Killed by Rival Male

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3190750/One-Cecil-lion-s-cubs-

killed-rival-male-sparking-fears-remaining-seven-just-days-left-live-beast-

slaughtered-dentist.html accessed 15 August 2015

Place et al2011 http://www.ifaw.org/united-states/resource-centre/petition-

list-african-lion-panthera-leo-leo-endangered-pursuant-us-endangered-

specie

Place J etal 2011 Petition to List the African Lion (Panthera Leo) as

Endangered Pursuant to the US Endangered Species Act

http://www.ifaw.org/united-states/resource-centre/petition-list-african-lion-

panthera-leo-leo-endangered-pursuant-us-endangered-specie accessed

August 2014

Ramsar Convention 2014 http://www.ramsar.org/country-profiles

Ramsar Convention 2014 Country Profileshttp://www.ramsar.org/country-

profiles accessed 7 October 2014

Roberts 2004 https://awionline.org/content/will-cites-ignore-its-responsi

bilitycon tribute-african-lion-conservation

Roberts A 2004 Will CITES Ignore Its Responsibility to Contribute to African

Lion Conservation?https://awionline.org/content/will-cites-ignore-its-

responsibility-contribute-african-lion-conservation accessed 7 October

UNCCD 2012 http://www.unccd.int/en/about-the-convention/Pages/About-

the-Convention.aspx

UNCCD 2012 About the Convention http://www.unccd.int/en/about-the-

convention/Pages/About-the-Convention.aspx accessed 7 October 2014

WHC 2014 http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/156/

WHC 2014 Serengeti National Park http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/156/

accessed 6 October 2014

World Bank Group 2014 http://data.worldbank.org/region/sub-saharan-

africa

World Bank Group 2014 Data http://data.worldbank.org/ region/sub-

saharan-africa accessed 6 September 2014

Published

17-05-2017

How to Cite

Watts, S. (2017). Protection of the African Lion: A Critical Analysis of the Current International Legal Regime. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 19, 1–41. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2016/v19i0a1158

Issue

Section

Articles