The Remedial Action of the "State of Capture" Report in Perspective

Loammi Wolf

Abstract


In the State of Capture report the public protector instructed the president to appoint a commission of inquiry to investigate the capture of state institutions by the Gupta family. The president and his family are personally implicated and due to a conflict of interests, the public protector limited both his choice of a commissioner to conduct the inquiry and the power to specify certain terms of reference. In the Economic Freedom Fighters, the Constitutional Court ruled that the public protector's remedial action is legally binding and must be executed by the state organs concerned. President Zuma challenges the remedial action on the basis that it is the sole prerogative of the head of state under section 84(2)(f) of the Constitution to appoint commissions of inquiry and that it is an unfettered discretionary power, which may not be limited. It is not only doubtful whether the responsibility to appoint commissions of inquiry is invariably a discretionary power; it is also doubtful whether the president has an unfettered discretion. In the case of a conflict of interest the president would in any event be barred from taking a decision in terms of the nemo iudex maxim if the decision could be tainted by bias. The difficulty is that section 90 of the Constitution does not regulate the ad hoc exercise of section-84(2) powers by another state organ when the president should recuse himself from taking a decision. The limitations imposed by the public protector in regard to the commission of inquiry appear to be the best solution under the circumstances.


Keywords


Public protector; commission of inquiry; remedial action; public protector; nemo iudex maxim.

Full Text:

PDF XML

References


BIBLIOGRAPHY

Literature

Basson and Viljoen Constitutional Law

Basson D and Viljoen H South African Constitutional Law (Juta Cape Town 1988)

Baxter Administrative Law

Baxter L Administrative Law (Juta Cape Town 1984)

Booysen and Van Wyk '83 Grondwet

Booysen H and van Wyk D Die '83 Grondwet (Juta Cape Town 1984)

Bradley and Ewing Constitutional and Administrative Law

Bradley AW and Ewing KD Constitutional and Administrative Law 15th ed (Pearson Education Harlow 2010)

Carpenter 1989 CILSA

Carpenter G "Prerogative Powers – An Anachronism?" 1989 CILSA 190-205

Carpenter Constitutional Law

Carpenter G South African Constitutional Law (Butterworths Durban 1987)

De Vos "Role of Chapter 9 Institutions"

De Vos P "Balancing Independence and Accountability: The Role of Chapter 9 Institutions in South Africa's Constitutional Democracy" in: Chirwa DM and Nijzick L (eds) Accountable Government in Africa (United Nations University Press Tokyo 2011) 160-177

De Vos and Freedman South African Constitutional Law

De Vos P and W Freedman South African Constitutional Law in Context (Oxford University Press Cape Town 2014)

Finer Governments

Finer H Governments of Greater European Powers: A Comparative Study of the Governments and Political Culture of Great Britain, France, Germany, and the Soviet Union vol 1 (Holt New York 1956)

Freedman "Commissions"

Freedman DW "Commissions" in Joubert WA (ed) The Law of South Africa 2nd ed vol 2 part 2 (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2003) 143-193

Gossnell 1934 Polit Sci Q

Gossnell HF "British Royal Commissions of Inquiry" 1934 Polit Sci Q 84-118

Hoffman Confronting the Corrupt

Hoffman P Confronting the Corrupt – Accountability Now's Battle against Graft in SA (Tafelberg Cape Town 2016)

Hoexter Administrative Law

Hoexter C Administrative Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2007)

Marumoagae 2014 De Rebus

Marumoagae C "Condemning the Leaking of Public Protector's Provisional Reports" 2014 (May) De Rebus 32-34

Rautenbach and Malherbe Constitutional Law

Rautenbach IM and Malherbe EFJ Constitutional Law 5th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2009)

Rabkin Business Day

Rabkin F "Judges on Arms Deal Commission likely to be Focus of Intense Scrutiny" Business Day (25 October 2011) 5

Van der Vyver Grondwet

Van der Vyver JD Die Grondwet van die Republiek van Suid-Afrika (Lex Patria Johannesburg 1984)

Wiechers Staatsreg

Wiechers M Verloren van Themaat Staatsreg 3rd ed (Butterworth Durban 1981)

Wolf 2015 Administratio Publica

Wolf L "The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) in a Nimbus between the Executive and the Judicature" 2015 Administratio Publica 30-53

Wolf 2011 PELJ

Wolf L "Pre- and Post-Trial Equality in Criminal Justice in Context of the Separation of Powers" 2011 PELJ 58-203

Wolf 2011 TSAR

Wolf L "The Prosecuting Discretion: An Administrative-Law or Criminal-Law Power?" 2011 TSAR 703-729

Case law

Crawford-Browne v President of the Republic of South Africa (WC)

(unreported) case number 1135/09 (unreported, only costs judgment)

Crawford-Browne v The President of South Africa (CC)

(unreported) case number CCT 103/10; directions of the Chief

Justice issued on 7 February 2011 (settled out of court)

De Lange v Smuts 1998 3 SA 785 (CC)

Democratic Alliance v President of South Africa 2013 1 SA 248 (CC)

Economic Freedom Fighters v Speaker of the National Assembly; Democratic Alliance v Speaker of the National Assembly 2016 3 SA 580 (CC)

Independent Electoral Commission v Langeberg Municipality 2001 9 BCLR 883 (CC)

Matatiele Municipality v President of the RSA 2007 6 SA 477 (CC)

President of the Republic of South Africa v South African Rugby Football Union (SARFU) 2001 1 SA 1 (CC)

South African Association of Personal Injury Lawyers v Heath 2001 1 SA 883 (CC)

Legislation

Commissions Act 8 of 1947

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 200 of 1993

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Executive Members' Ethics Act 82 of 1998

Inquiries Act of 2005 (United Kingdom)

National Prosecuting Authority Act 32 of 1998

Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004

Public Finances Act 44 of 1998

Public Protector Act 23 of 1994

Republic of South Africa Constitution Act 32 of 1961

Tribunals of Inquiry (Evidence) Act of 1921 (United Kingdom)

Internet sources (government publications)

Corder, Jagwanth and Soltau 1999 http://www.casac.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Report-on-Parliamentary-Oversight-and-Accountability.pdf

Corder H, Jagwanth S and Soltau F 1999 Report on Parliamentary Oversight and Accountability http://www.casac.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Report-on-Parliamentary-Oversight-and-Accountability.pdf accessed 19 June 2017

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development 2011 http://www.justice.gov.za/m_statements/2011/20111027_armscomms.html

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development 2011 Announcement of the Details of the Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of Fraud, Corruption, Impropriety or Irregularity in the Strategic Defence Procurement Packages

http://www.justice.gov.za/m_statements

/2011/20111027_armscomms.html accessed 19 June 2017

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development 2013 http://www.justice.gov.za/m_statements/2013/20130822-comms-funding.html

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development 2013 Media Statement on the Funding of Commissions of Inquiry http://www.justice.gov.za/m_statements/2013/20130822-comms-funding.html accessed 19 June 2017

Ginwala 2008 http://www.justice.gov.za/commissions/2008_ginwala.pdf (Ginwala Report)

Ginwala FN 2008 Report of the Enquiry into the Fitness of Advocate VP Pikoli to hold the Office of National Director of Public Prosecutions http://www.justice.gov.za/commissions/2008_ginwala.pdf accessed 19 June 2017

House of Commons Public Administration Select Committee 2004 http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200304/cmselect/cmpubadm/422/422.pdf (House of Commons Taming the Prerogative)

House of Commons Public Administration Select Committee 2004 Taming the Prerogative: Strengthening Ministerial Accountability to Parliament. Fourth Report of Session 2003-04

http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200304/cmselect/cmpubadm/422/422.pdf accessed 19 June 2017

House of Commons Public Administration Select Committee 2005 http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200405/cmselect/cmpubadm/51/51i.pdf (House of Commons Government by Inquiry)

House of Commons Public Administration Select Committee 2005 Government by Inquiry. First Report of Session 2004-05, vol 1 http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200405/cmselect/cmpubadm/51/51i.pdf accessed 19 June 2017

Presidency 2017 http://www.psppd.org.za/press-statements/president-zuma-not-opposed-establishing-commission-inquiry-%E2%80%9Cstate-capture%E2%80%9D

Presidency 2017 President Zuma is not Opposed to Establishing a Commission of Inquiry on 'State Capture' http://www.psppd.org.za/press-statements/president-zuma-not-opposed-establishing-commission-inquiry-%E2%80%9Cstate-capture%E2%80%9D accessed 19 June 2017

Public Protector 2005 http://www.gov.za/sites/www.gov.za/files/public_protector_0405.pdf (Mushwana Report)

Public Protector 2005 Annual Report: 1 April 2004 – 31 March 2005 http://www.gov.za/sites/www.gov.za/files/public_protector_0405.pdf accessed 19 June 2017

Public Protector 2014

http://www.pprotect.org/library/investigation_report/2013-14/Final%20Report%2019%20March%202014%20.pdf (Secure in Comfort Report)

Public Protector 2014 Secure in Comfort. Report No 25 of 2013/2014.

http://www.pprotect.org/library/investigation_report/2013-14/Final%20Report%2019%20March%202014%20.pdf

Public Protector 2016

http://www.pprotect.org/library/investigation_report/2016-17/State_Capture_14October2016.pdf (State of Capture Report)

Public Protector 2016 State of Capture. Report on an Investigation into Alleged Improper and Unethical Conduct by the President and other State Functionaries Relating to Alleged Improper Relationships and Involvement of the Gupta Family in the Removal and Appointment of Ministers and Directors of State-Owned Enterprises Resulting in Improper and Possibly Corrupt Award of State Contracts and Benefits to the Gupta Family's Businesses - Report No 6 of 2016/17 http://www.pprotect.org/library/investigation_report/2016-17/State_Capture_14October2016.pdf accessed 19 June 2017

Public Protector 2017 http://www.pprotect.org/library/investigation_report/2016-17/Report%208%20of%202017&2018%20Public%20Protector%20South%20Africa.pdf (Bankorp Report)

Public Protector 2017 Alleged Failure to Recover Misappropriated Funds - Report Nr 8 of 2017/2018 http://www.pprotect.org/library/investigation_report/2016-17

/Report%208%20of%202017&2018%20Public%20Protector%20South%20Africa.pdf accessed 19 June 2017

Seriti 2015 http://www.gov.za/documents/arms-procurement-commission-report-21-apr-2016-0000 (Seriti Report)

Seriti LW 2015 Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of Fraud, Corruption, Impropriety or Irregularity in the Strategic Defence Procurement Package http://www.gov.za/documents/arms-procurement-commission-report-21-apr-2016-0000 accessed 19 June 2017

Spies 2007 http://www.armsdeal-vpo.co.za/special_items/statements/not_recall.html

Spies W 2007 Minister 'does not Recall' whether she Travelled with Ginwala - Press Release Issued by Willie Spies, FF Plus MP, National Assembly http://www.armsdeal-vpo.co.za/special_items/statements/not_recall.html accessed 19 June 2017

Internet sources (news reports and articles)

amaBhungane Reporter 2016 http://amabhungane.co.za/article/2016-09-23-two-to-tango-the-story-of-zuma-and-the-guptas

amaBhungane Reporter "#GuptaLeaks: All the Latest on the Gupta-Zuma Scandal" amaBhungane (23 September 2016) http://amabhungane.co.za/article/2016-09-23-two-to-tango-the-story-of-zuma-and-the-guptas accessed 19 June 2017

ANA Reporter 2017 http://www.iol.co.za/news/politics/ramaphosa-renews-call-for-state-capture-inquiry-9257815

ANA Reporter "Ramaphosa Renews Call for State Capture Inquiry" IOL (21 May 2017) http://www.iol.co.za/news/politics/ramaphosa-renews-call-for-state-capture-inquiry-9257815 accessed 19 June 2017

Bendile 2017 https://mg.co.za/article/2017-05-29-anc-calls-for-judicial-commission-of-inquiry-into-state-capture

Bendile D "ANC Calls for Judicial Commission of Inquiry into State Capture" Mail & Guardian (29 May 2017) https://mg.co.za/article/2017-05-29-anc-calls-for-judicial-commission-of-inquiry-into-state-capture accessed 19 June 2017

De Vos 2016 https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2016-11-03-can-zuma-use-the-law-to-avoid-the-consequences-of-madonselas-report/#.WVHwPOlpzyQ

De Vos P "Can Zuma Use the Law to Avoid the Consequences of Madonsela's Report?" Daily Maverick (3 November 2016)

https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/opinionista/2016-11-03-can-zuma-use-the-law-to-avoid-the-consequences-of-madonselas-report/#.WVHwPOlpzyQ accessed 19 June 2017

Dube 2016 http://www.politicsweb.co.za/news-and-analysis/did-the-state-of-capture-report-usurp-the-presiden

Dube P "Did the State of Capture Report Usurp the President's Powers?" Politicsweb (4 November 2016)

http://www.politicsweb.co.za/news-and-analysis/did-the-state-of-capture-report-usurp-the-presiden accessed 19 June 2017

Evans 2016 http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/zuma-withdrawal-catches-public-protectors-office-by-surprise-20161102

Evans J "Zuma Withdrawal Catches Public Protector's Office by Surprise" News24 (2 November 2016) http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/zuma-withdrawal-catches-public-protectors-office-by-surprise-20161102 accessed 19 June 2017

Gallens 2016 http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/madonsela-weighs-her-options-over-state-capture-report-interdict-20161013

Gallens M "Madonsela Weighs her Options over 'State Capture' Report Interdict" News24 (13 October 2016)

http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/madonsela-weighs-her-options-over-state-capture-report-interdict-20161013 accessed 19 June 2017

Goba 2017 https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2017-05-30-state-capture-is-busy-eating-the-anc-away-ramaphosa

Goba N "Ramaphosa Calls for State Capture Judicial Commission" Times Live (24 April 2017) https://www.timeslive.co.za/politics/2017-05-30-state-capture-is-busy-eating-the-anc-away-ramaphosa/ accessed 19 June 2017

Grootes 2017 http://ewn.co.za/2017/05/02/arms-deal-critics-welcome-ajay-sooklal-affidavit-into-zuma-s-concealed-role

Grootes S "Arms Deal Critics Welcome Affidavit into Zuma Revelations" Eyewitness News (2 May 2017) http://ewn.co.za/2017/05/02/arms-deal-critics-welcome-ajay-sooklal-affidavit-into-zuma-s-concealed-role accessed 19 June 2017

Heard 2016 http://city-press.news24.com/News/the-r137m-price-tag-for-whitewash-arms-deal-report-20160524

Heard J "The R137m Price Tag for 'Whitewash' Arms Deal Report" City Press (24 May 2016) http://city-press.news24.com/News/the-r137m-price-tag-for-whitewash-arms-deal-report-20160524 accessed 19 June 2017

Jamal 2016 https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2016-04-22-seriti-commission-of-inquiry-whitewash---findings-are-a-joke-critics/

Jamal S "Seriti Commission of Inquiry Whitewash - Findings are a 'Joke': Critics" Times Live (22 April 2016)

https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2016-04-22-seriti-commission-of-inquiry-whitewash---findings-are-a-joke-critics/ accessed 19 June 2017

Lowman 2016 http://www.biznews.com/leadership/2016/10/13/zumas-last-ditch-effort-to-silence-madonsela-on-state-capture

Lowman S "Zumas Last Ditch Effort to Silence Madonsela on State Capture" BizNews (13 October 2016) http://www.biznews.com/leadership/2016/10/13/zumas-last-ditch-effort-to-silence-madonsela-on-state-capture accessed 19 June 2017

Madia 2016 http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/chief-justice-will-wait-to-hear-from-zuma-on-state-capture-inquiry-20161117

Madia T "Chief Justice will Wait to hear from Zuma on 'State Capture' Inquiry" News24 (17 November 2016)

http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/chief-justice-will-wait-to-hear-from-zuma-on-state-capture-inquiry-20161117 accessed 19 June 2017

Monare 2006 http://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/npa-questions-mushwanas-ambit-on-zuma-report-291587

Monare M "NPA Questions Mushwana's Ambit on Zuma Report" IOL (30 August 2006) http://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/npa-questions-mushwanas-ambit-on-zuma-report-291587 accessed 19 June 2017

Nicolaides and Bateman 2016 http://ewn.co.za/2016/11/02/public-protector-ordered-to-release-state-capture-report-by-5pm-today

Nicolaides G and Bateman B "Public Protector Ordered to Release State Capture Report by 5pm Today" Eyewitness News (2 November 2016) http://ewn.co.za/2016/11/02/public-protector-ordered-to-release-state-capture-report-by-5pm-today accessed 19 June 2017

Nicholson 2016 https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2016-11-10-no-confidence-anc-wins-the-vote-but-zuma-suffers-in-battle/#.WVUhVulpzyQ

Nicholson G "No Confidence: ANC Wins the Vote, but Zuma Suffers in Battle" The Daily Maverick (10 November 2016) https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2016-11-10-no-confidence-anc-wins-the-vote-but-zuma-suffers-in-battle/#.WVUhVulpzyQ accessed 19 June 2017

Quintal 2016 https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2016-11-25-zuma-to-take-madonselas-state-capture-report-to-court

Quintal G "Jacob Zuma to take Thuli Madonsela's Remedial Action Ruling on Review" Business Day (25 November 2016) https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2016-11-25-zuma-to-take-madonselas-state-capture-report-to-court accessed 19 June 2017

Rabkin 2016 https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2016-10-26-state-capture-report-done-fairly

Rabkin F "State Capture Report 'done Fairly'" Business Day (26 October 2016) https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/national/2016-10-26-state-capture-report-done-fairly accessed 19 June 2017

Swilling et al 2017 http://markswilling.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/25052017-Betrayal-of-the-Promise.pdf

Swilling M et al 2017 Betrayal of the Promise: How South Africa is being Stolen http://markswilling.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/25052017-Betrayal-of-the-Promise.pdf accessed 19 June 2017

Thamm 2016 https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2016-04-21-seriti-commission-findings-on-arms-deal-it-aint-over-till-concourt-sings/#.WVUAyOlpzyQ

Thamm M "Seriti Commission Findings on Arms Deal: It ain't over till ConCourt Sings" Daily Maverick (21 April 2016)

https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2016-04-21-seriti-commission-findings-on-arms-deal-it-aint-over-till-concourt-sings/#.WVUAyOlpzyQ accessed 19 June 2017

Thamm 2017 https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2017-06-11-state-capture-lobby-groups-approach-concourt-to-ask-ramaphosa-to-set-up-commission-of-inquiry/#.WVUaUelpzyQ

Thamm M "State Capture: Lobby Groups Approach ConCourt to Ask Ramaphosa to set up Commission of Inquiry" The Daily Maverick (11 June 2017) https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2017-06-11-state-capture-lobby-groups-approach-concourt-to-ask-ramaphosa-to-set-up-commission-of-inquiry/#.WVUaUelpzyQ accessed 19 June 2017

Tmg Digital 2016 http://www.heraldlive.co.za/news/2016/10/06/new-public-protector-reveal-thulis-state-capture-probe-cant-priority

Tmg Digital "New Public Protector to Reveal why Thuli's State Capture Probe 'can't be a Priority'" Herald Live (6 October 2016) http://www.heraldlive.co.za/news/2016/10/06/new-public-protector-reveal-thulis-state-capture-probe-cant-priority accessed 19 June 2017

Trengove, Bruinders and Makola 2008 http://www.politicsweb.co.za/replies/the-real-reason-for-pikolis-suspension

Trengove W, Bruinders T and Makola B "The Real Reason for Pikoli's Suspension" Politicsweb (9 May 2008) http://www.politicsweb.co.za/replies/the-real-reason-for-pikolis-suspension accessed 19 June 2017

Umraw 2017 http://www.huffingtonpost.co.za/2017/05/29/heres-how-zuma-will-ensure-a-judicial-inquiry-into-state-captur_a_22115149/

Umraw A "Zuma's Judicial Inquiry into State Capture could be a Whitewash Like the Arms Deal" Huffington Post (29 May 2017) http://www.huffingtonpost.co.za/2017/05/29/heres-how-zuma-will-ensure-a-judicial-inquiry-into-state-captur_a_22115149/ accessed 19 June 2017

Underhill 2012 https://mg.co.za/article/2012-10-19-00-arms-deal-twist-raises-alarm

Underhill G "Arms Deal: Conflict of Interest Twist Raises Alarm" Mail & Guardian (19 October 2012) https://mg.co.za/article/2012-10-19-00-arms-deal-twist-raises-alarm accessed 19 June 2017

Underhill 2013 https://mg.co.za/article/2013-08-02-arms-deal-commission-lawyer-resigned-over-second-agenda

Underhill G "Another Arms Deal Commission Resignation over 'Second Agenda'" Mail & Guardian (2 August 2013)

https://mg.co.za/article/2013-08-02-arms-deal-commission-lawyer-resigned-over-second-agenda accessed 19 June 2017

Underhill 2014 https://mg.co.za/article/2014-08-11-resignations-take-arms-deal-probe-from-mess-to-farce

Underhill G "Resignations take Arms Deal Probe from Mess to 'Farce'" Mail & Guardian (11 August 2014) https://mg.co.za/article/2014-08-11-resignations-take-arms-deal-probe-from-mess-to-farce accessed 19 June 2017

Vollgraaff et al 2016 http://www.fin24.com/Economy/madonselas-regret-i-shouldve-been-harder-on-zuma-20161102-2

Vollgraaff R et al "Madonsela's Regret: I should have been Harder on Zuma" Fin24 (2 November 2016) http://www.fin24.com/Economy/madonselas-regret-i-shouldve-been-harder-on-zuma-20161102-2 accessed 19 June 2017




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2017/v20i0a1687

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2017 Loammi Wolf

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.