A complex systems view of climate and development issues in South African coal power expansion
Keywords:complexity studies; climate mitigation; social justice; coal-fired power; electricity sector
The implementation of climate change policy in South Africa inevitably requires decision-makers to navigate issues of development. This paper explores some of the implications of this requirement by examining the case of a proposed new independent coal-fired power producing plant, Khanyisa, in the province of Mpumalanga from the perspective of complexity studies, an emerging transdisciplinary field. Complexity thinking re-casts the Khanyisa project in a whole-system view, encouraging an active consideration of scale, perspectives, different knowledges, and cumulative impacts. In so doing, tensions both between and within dimensions of climate mitigation and development are quickly revealed, a complexity which is theorised in complexity studies as the raw material for systemic transformation. This whole-system conceptualisation also undermines incremental and relative arguments that Khanyisa mitigates greenhouse gas emissions. Further, the complex systemic property of non-linearity suggests that the Khanyisa decision is more significant than its power generation capacity indicates. Attention to the conceptual simplification inherent in ‘development’ highlights what is lost through such simplification, as well as what is gained, and by whom. Finally, complexity thinking foregrounds the multiple scales at which the systemic climate mitigation and development implications of Khanyisa play out. Currently there is very little policy-making capacity nationally, regionally or in eMalahleni to look at alternatives, or ‘spaces of possibility’ through the complexity lens for both development and climate mitigation. This case argues that new policy processes are needed, which go far beyond policy and regulatory processes steeped in path dependencies and incrementalism.
• The case reveals the complex entanglement of climate and development issues as raw material for systemic transformation.
• A whole system and scalar conceptualisation, paying attention to non-linearities, and the exercise of power through simplifications suggest productive areas of focus for policymakers
• New policy processes are needed, which go far beyond policy and regulatory processes steeped in path dependencies and incrementalism.
CWA. Undated. Khanyisa flyer.
ACWA. 2017. Khanyisa IPP phase one, 306 MW Greenfield project. Project overview.
NERSA Application form: ACWA Power Khanyisa Thermal Power Station (RF) (Pty.) Ltd. (Undated). Electricity generation licence application form.
Aurecon. 2015). Environmental Authorisation Amendment Report, Khanyisa Power Station, eMalahleni, Mpumalanga Province. Reference 111415, Revision 1.
Aurecon (2012). Environmental and social impact assessment report: Khanyisa coal fired power station, eMalahleni, Mpumalanga. Volume 1 of 4.
Bian, Z., Inyang, H. I., Daniels, J. L., Otto, F. and Struthers, S. 2010). Environmental issues from coal mining and their solutions. Mining Science and Technology, 20(2): 215–223. http://doi.org/10.1016/S1674-5264(09)60187-3
Bischof-Niemz, T. and Creamer, T. 2018. South Africa’s energy transition: A roadmap to a decarbonised, low-cost and job-rich future. Routledge, Oxford, United Kingdom.
Boulton, J., Allen, P. and Bowman, C. 2015. Embracing complexity: Strategic perspectives for an age of turbulence. Oxford University Press. Oxford, United Kingdom.
Burton, J. 2011. The role of industrial policy in pursuing climate change mitigation objectives in South Africa. Energy Research Centre, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
Cairney, P. and Geyer, R. 2015. Introduction. In R. Geyer & P. Cairney (Eds.), Handbook on complexity and public policy: 1–19. Cheltenham, United Kingdom: Edward Elgar.
Chettiparamb, A. 2014. Complexity theory and planning: Examining ‘fractals’ for organising policy domains in planning practice. Planning Theory, 13(1): 5–25. http://doi.org/10.1177/1473095212469868
Chu, D., Strand, R. and Fjelland, R. 2003. Theories of complexity. Complexity, 8(3): 19–30. http://doi.org/10.1002/cplx.10059
Cook, A. P. and Lloyd, P. J. D. 2012. The estimation of greenhouse gas emissions from South African surface and abandoned coal mines. Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, 112(12): 1087–1090.
Department of Energy. 2016. Coal procurement programme: Bid window 1 fact sheet. www.energy.gov.za/files/media/pr/2016/Coal-IPP-factsheet.pdf.
Department of Environmental Affairs of South Africa. 2017. Amendment of the environmental authorisation issued on 31 October 2013 for the proposed construction of 450MW Khanyisa coal fired power station in
Emalahlni, Mpumalanga Province.
Department of Environmental Affairs of South Africa. 2015. Amendment of the environmental authorisation issued on 31 October 2013 for the proposed construction of 450MW Khanyisa coal fired power station in Emalahlni, Mpumalanga Province.
Department of Environmental Affairs of South Africa. 2012. Integrated Environmental Authorisation, construction of 450MW Khanyisa coal fired power station and associated infrastructure in Emalahleni, Mpumalanga Province.
Department of Minerals and Energy. Undated. Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme. Accessed 22 October 2020. https://www.ipp-renewables.co.za/.
Fine, B. and Rustomjee, Z. 1996. The political economy of South Africa: From minerals-energy complex to industrialisation. London: Hurst and Company.
Fourie, D., Kritzinger-van Niekerk, L. and Nel, M. 2015. An overview of the renewable energy independent power producers procurement programme (REIPPPP. Energize RE: Renewable Energy Supplement, 15: 9-12
Global Energy Monitor Wiki. Accessed 22 September 2020. https://www.gem.wiki/Khanyisa_power_station.
Ismail, Z. and Khembo, P. 2015. Determinants of energy poverty in South Africa, Journal of Energy in Southern Africa, 26(3): 66-78. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/2413-3051/2015/v26i3a2140
Kurtz, C. F. and Snowden, D. J. 2003. The new dynamics of strategy: Sense-making in a complex and complicated world. IEEE Engineering Management Review, 31(3): 110–130. http://doi.org/10.1109/EMR.2003.24944
Laisani, J. and Jegede, A. O. 2019. Impacts of coal mining in Witbank, Mpumalanga province of South Africa: An eco-legal perspective. Journal of Reviews on Global Economics, 8: 1586-1597.
McCall, B., Burton, J., Marquard, A., Hartley, F., Ahjum, F., Ireland, G., and Merven, B. 2019. Least-cost integrated resource planning and cost- optimal climate change mitigation policy: Alternatives for the South African electricity system. Energy Research Centre, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa. Retrieved from http://www.erc.uct.ac.za/sites/default/files/image_tool/ images/119/Papers-2019/Alt IRP final 07022019_2.pdf.
Mitleton-Kelly, E. 2015. Effective policy making: addressing apparently intractable problems. In P. Cairney and R. Geyer (Eds.), Handbook on complexity and public policy: 111–130. Cheltenham, United Kingdom: Edward Elgar.
Morin, E. 2006. Restricted complexity, general complexity. In Intelligence de la complexite: epitemologie et pragmatique: 1–25. Centre dEtudes Transdisciplinaires, Sociologie, Anthropologie, Histoire; Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales.
National Planning Commission. 2011. South African National Development Plan 2030: Our future – make it work. Pretoria, South Africa. Retrieved from http://www.npconline.co.za/MediaLib/Downloads/Downloads/NDP 2030 - Our future - make it work.pdf.
Patel, L. and Graham, L. 2012. How broad-based is broad-based black economic empowerment? Development Southern Africa 29(2): 193-207. DOI: 10.1080/0376835X.2012.675692
Price, J., Haynes, P., Darking, M., Stroud, J., Warren-Adamson, C. and Ricaurte, C. 2015. The policymaker’s complexity toolkit. In R. Geyer and P. Cairney (Eds.), Handbook on complexity and public policy: 92–110. Cheltenham, United Kingdom: Edward Elgar.
Ptsera Environmental Management Consultants. 2011. Proposed independent coal fired power station with associated infrastructure in the eMalahleni area. Social impact assessment.
Republic of South Africa. 2011. National Climate Change Response White Paper. Pretoria, South Africa.
Republic of South Africa. 2004. Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment Act, 2003. Government Gazette 463 (25899).
Richardson, K.A., Cilliers, P. and Lissack, M. 2001. Complexity science: A ‘gray’ science for the ‘stuff in between’. Emergence, 3 (2): 6-18.
Savannah Environmental. 2017. Thabametsi power station near Lephalale, Limpopo Province: Climate change study and palaeontological impact assessment.
Shine, C. T. 2015. Policymaking as complex cartography? Mapping and achieving probable futures using complex concepts and tools. In P. Cairney & R. Geyer (Eds.), Handbook on complexity and public policy: 171–189. Cheltenham, United Kingdom: Edward Elgar.
Stern, P. C., Sovacool, B. K. and Dietz, T. 2016. Towards a science of climate and energy choices. Nature Climate Change, 6(6): 547–555. http://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate3027
Steyn, G., Burton, J. and Steenkamp, M. 2017. Eskom’s financial crisis and the viability of coal-fired power in South Africa. Retrieved from http://meridianeconomics.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/CoalGen-Report_FinalDoc_ForUpload-1.pdf.
Tyler, E. 2020. What might a Paris-aligned emissions profile look like for the South African power sector? Meridian Economics Policy Brief, July 2020/03.
Tyler, E and Steyn, G. 2018. Studying the employment implications of the South African power sector transition. Meridian Economics, Cape Town.
Voigt, C. and Ferreira, F. 2016. ‘Dynamic differentiation’: The principles of CBDR-RC, progression and highest possible ambition in the Paris Agreement. Transnational Environmental Law, 5(2): 285–303. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2047102516000212
Walby, S. 2007. Complexity theory, systems theory and multiple intersecting social inequalities in Philosophy of the Social Sciences 37 (4): 449-470. http://doi.org/10.1177/0048393107307663
Wells, J. 2013. Complexity and sustainability. Oxford: Routledge.
Wright, J., Bischof-Niemz, T., Calitz, J., Crescent, M., Robbie van, H. and Mamahloko, S. 2017. Council for Scientific and Industrial Research formal comments on the Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) Update Assumptions, Base Case and Observations 2016.
Yuen, K. 2014. REIPPPP - A new dawn for South African renewables? An analysis of renewable energy prices in the South AFrican Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Programme. Masters Thesis Sciences Po, Paris School of International Affairs.
Burton, J. Researcher, Energy Research Centre, University of Cape Town, Cape Town. South Africa. 29 August 2018.
Govender, P. Executive Director of Business Development Phase of Khanyisa project. 26 February 2018.
Hallowes, D. Groundwork. 12 March 2018.
Loser, N. and Koyama, M. Centre for Environmental Rights. 19 February 2018.
Netch, A. Industrial Development Corporation. 27 February 2018.
How to Cite
Copyright (c) 2021 Emily Tyler, Brett Cohen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright remains with the author(s).
Publishing rights remain with the author(s)
All articles published in JESA can be re-used under the following CC license: CC BY-SA Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.