Does Albinism Fit Within the Legal Definition of Disability in the Employment Context? A Comparative Analysis of the Judicial Interpretation of Disability under the SA and the US Non-Discrimination Laws

  • Mphoeng Maureen Mswela University of South Africa
Keywords: Albinism, disability, employment, the right to equality, Employment Equity Act, Americans with Disability Amendment Act

Abstract

South Africans with albinism are among the most marginalised and vulnerable citizens yet very little attention is paid to protecting them from human rights violations. There have been several calls by people with albinism in South Africa to be classified as disabled. The question of whether albinism is classified as a disability or not is a controversial legal one, which does not always have a straightforward answer. A literature search indicates that in South Africa no comprehensive and analytical study has been carried out on the subject of albinism and disability, whereas this has already been addressed in court cases in the United States of America. This paper anticipates addressing this gap within a legal perspective. The objective of such an analysis is to understand the construction of disability under the Employment Equity Act in order to shed light on whether people with albinism qualify for the protection, which is afforded to people with disabilities in the work place. Foreign case law and international human rights law could shed new light on this longstanding grey area or stimulate the development of novel legal analytical strategies. This paper reviews the nature of disability claims in the workplace on grounds of albinism in the United States context, including factors contributing to disability claims; assessing the degree of impairment and the guidelines in assessing albinism related disability. Prior to this discussion, the paper explores the current working definition of disability in South Africa, which stems from the IMATU case, which relied significantly on a foreign precedent; the Sutton v United Airlines case as there was no indigenous precedent in South Africa to fall back on. It will be argued that the Sutton v United Airlines decision, referred to in the IMATU case is based on an insufficiently inclusive definition of disability. Specific cases that relied on the Sutton v United Airlines decision as a persuasive authority in determining whether albinism is a disability or not, will also be examined. While the United States of America has struck down the decision in the Sutton v United Airlines and amended its legislation to include a broader and less restrictive definition of disability, which includes present as well as past conditions and a subjective component of perceived disability, the South African definition of disability still remains narrow and less inclusive. The United States of America's amended legislation does not contain an exhaustive definition of disability; rather, an equality-based framework was chosen which considers changing biomedical, social and technological developments. This new definition highlights the fact that the emphasis must be on whether discrimination occurred rather than adherence to a strict definition of disability. Such a framework of disability includes a socio-political aspect, which places emphasis on human dignity, respect and the right to equality. Against this background, the comparative analysis raises specific issues that deserve attention, in particular that the unique disadvantages and negative stereotyping suffered by people with albinism should be recognised as unlawful conduct against people with disabilities as defined by legislation. Put differently, the discussion calls for a broader approach to viewing disability, which includes both a social and a human rights perspective. In taking the position that albinism related discrimination is socially constructed, the article also explores the mandate of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in as far as it relates to the social construction of disability. The paper argues that the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities affords a direction for an analysis of the discrimination faced by persons with albinism.

Author Biography

Mphoeng Maureen Mswela, University of South Africa
Department of Jurisprudence, Senior Lecturer in Law

References

Bibliography

Literature

Areheart 2008 Ind LJ
Areheart BA "When Disability isn't Just Right: The Entrenchment of the Medical Model of Disability and the Goldilocks Dilemma" 2008 Ind LJ 181-232

Benfer ADA Amendments Act
Benfer EA The ADA Amendments Act: An Overview of Recent Changes to the Americans with Disabilities Act (American Constitution Society for Law and Policy Washington DC 2009)

Braathhen Albinism in Malawi
Braathhen SH Albinism in Malawi: A Qualitative Study on Attitudes and Beliefs (Master of Philosophy Thesis University of Oslo 2005)

Brodsky Paediatric Ophthalmology
Brodsky MC Paediatric Ophthalmology (Springer New York 2010)

Bryan Socio-Political Aspects of Disabilities
Bryan WV Socio-Political Aspects of Disabilities (Charles Thomas Springfield 2010)

Charles and Scott 2010 JAAPL
Charles L and Scott MD "The Americans with Disabilities Act Amendments Act of 2008: Implications for the Forensic Psychiatrist" 2010 JAAPL 95-99

Cruz-Inigo et al 2011 Dermatologic Clinics
Cruz-Inigo AE et al "Albinism in Africa; Stigma, Slaughter and Awareness Campaigns" 2011 Dermatologic Clinics 79-87

Degener "Disability as a Subject of International Human Rights Law"
Degener T "Disability as a Subject of International Human Rights Law and Comparative Discrimination Law" in Herr SS et al (eds) The Human Rights of Persons with Intellectual Disabilities: Different but Equal (Oxford University Press Oxford 2003) 151-184

Department of Provincial and Local Government Disability Framework
Department of Provincial and Local Government Disability Framework for Local Government, 2009-2014 (Department of Provincial and Local Government Pretoria 2009)

Dominguez et al Building Blocks
Dominguez B et al Building Blocks: Foundation for Learning for Young Blind and Visually Impaired Children (AFB Press New York 1991)

DPSA Pocket Guide
Disabled People South Africa Pocket Guide on Disability Equity (Disabled People South Africa Cape Town 2000)

Du Plessis Access to Work for Disabled Persons
Du Plessis MC Access to Work for Disabled Persons in South Africa: The Intersections of Social Understandings of Disability, Substantive Equality and Access to Social Security (PhD-thesis University of Cape Town 2015)

Dupper and Garbers Equality in the Workplace
Dupper O and Garbers C Equality in the Workplace: Reflections from South Africa and Beyond (Juta Cape Town 2009)
EEOC Technical Assistance Manual

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission Technical Assistance Manual on the Employment Provisions (Title I) of the Americans with Disabilities Act (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission Washington DC 1992)

Ekurhuleni Policy Guidelines for People with Disabilities
Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality Policy Guidelines for People with Disabilities (Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality
Ekurhuleni 2005)

Ekurhuleni Declaration on the Rights of Persons with Albinism
Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality Declaration on the Rights of Persons with Albinism (Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality Ekurhuleni 2013)

Elliott 2012 Gonz L Rev
Elliott TL "The Path to the Americans with Disabilities Act Amendments Act: US Supreme Court Cases, Congressional Intent, and Substantial Change" 2012 Gonz L Rev 395-420

Feldblum et al 2008 TJCLCR
Feldblum CR et al "The ADA Amendments Act of 2008" 2008 TJCLCR 187-240

Gutto Equality and Non-discrimination in South Africa
Gutto S Equality and Non-discrimination in South Africa: The Political Economy of Law and Law Making (Zebra Cape Town 2001)

Horobin Diseases and Disorders
Horobin W (ed) Diseases and Disorders (Marshal Cavendish New York 2008)

Hurpur 2012 Disability and Society
Hurpur P "Embracing the New Disability Rights Paradigm: The Importance of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities" 2012 Disability and Society 1-14

Lawrence and Gostin 2015 JAMA
Lawrence O and Gostin LO "The Americans with Disabilities Act at 25: The Highest Expression of American Values" 2015 JAMA 2231-2235

Lund 2001 Health Educ Res
Lund PM "Health and Education of Children with Albinism in Zimbabwe" 2001 Health Educ Res 1-7

Marks et al Clinical Signs and Procedures
Marks R et al Clinical Signs and Procedures in Dermatology (Martin Dunitz London 1993)

Mcgarry and Tong 5-Minute Consult
Mcgarry KA and Tong IL The 5-Minute Consult Clinical Companion to Women's Health (Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Philadelphia 2013)

Mswela Selection of Legal Issues
Mswela M A Selection of Legal Issues Relating to Persons Living with Albinism (LLD University of South Africa 2016)

Ngwena 2006 SAJHR
Ngwena CG "Deconstructing the Definition of 'Disability' under the Employment Equity Act: Social Deconstruction" 2006 SAJHR 613-646

Ngwena 2007 SAJHR
Ngwena CG "Deconstructing the Definition of 'Disability' under the Employment Equity Act: Legal Deconstruction" 2007 SAJHR 116-156

Ngwena 'Disabled People' and the Search for Equality
Ngwena CG 'Disabled People' and the Search for Equality in the Workplace: An Appraisal of Equality Models from a Comparative Perspective (LLD-thesis University of the Free State 2010)

Ngwena and Pretorius 2007 ILJ
Ngwena CG and Pretorius JL "Conceiving Disability, and Applying the Constitutional Test for Fairness and Justifiability: A Commentary on IMATU v City of Cape Town" 2007 ILJ 747-768

Renteln Cross-cultural Perceptions on Disability
Renteln AD Cross-cultural Perceptions on Disability: Policy Implications of Divergent Views (Oxford University Press Oxford 2003)

Richards and Hawley Human Genome
Richards JE and Hawley RS The Human Genome: A User's Guide (Elsevier Science Amsterdam 2010)

Rioux 2011 Sport in Society
Rioux M H "Disability Rights and Change in a Global Perspective" 2011 Sport in Society 1094-1098

Rioux et al Critical Perspectives
Rioux M et al Critical Perspectives on Human Rights and Disability Law (Nijhoff Boston 2011)

Scott 1999 JGRJ
Scott SA "New Category of Colour: Analyzing Albinism under Title VII of the Americans with Disabilities Act" 1999 JGRJ 493-522

Shakespeare Disability Rights and Wrongs Revisited
Shakespeare T Disability Rights and Wrongs Revisited (Routledge New York 2014)

Walter Legal Interpretation of Disability
Walter RK The Legal Interpretation of Disability Under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 and Changes in this Standard Set Forth in the Americans with Disabilities Act Amendments Act of 2008 (PhD-dissertation University of Connecticut 2014)

Case law

Albertsons, Inc v Kirkingburg 527 US 555, 566, 119 S Ct 2162, 144 L Ed 2d 518 (1999)
Barta v Sears, Roebuck and Co 307 F Supp 2d 773 (ED Va 2004)
Chenoweth v Hillsborough County 250 F 3d 1328 (11th Cir 2001)
Colwell v Suffolk County Police Dept 158 F 3d 635 (2d Cir1998)
Hoffmann v South African Airways 2001 1 SA 1 (CC)
IMATU v City of Cape Town 2005 11 BLLR 1084 (LC)
Manz v Gaffney 200 F Supp 2d 207 (EDNY 2002)
Standard Bank of South Africa v Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration 2008 4 BLLR 356 (LC)
Sutton v United Airlines Inc 527 US 471 (1999)
Toyota Motor Manufacturing Kentucky v Williams 534 US 184, 198-99, 122 S Ct 681, 151 L Ed 2d 615 (2002)

Legislation
Americans with Disabilities Amendment Act of 2008
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Employment Equity Act 55 of 1998
Income Tax Act 58 of 1962
Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995
Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000
Social Assistance Act 13 of 2004
Government publications
GN 1345 in GG 23702 of 19 August 2002 (Code of Good Practice: Key Aspects on the Employment of People with Disabilities)

International instruments
United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (2007)

Internet sources
Bick 2011 http://www.mondaq.com/x/147254/Arbitration+Dispute+
Resolution/Definitions+Of+Disability+And+The+2011+Census
Bick L 2011 South Africa: Definitions of Disability and the 2011 Census http://www.mondaq.com/x/147254/Arbitration+Dispute+Resolution/Definitions+Of+Disability+ And+The+2011+Census accessed 10 February 2016

Guerin 2018 https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/what-is-the-eeoc.html
Guerin L 2018 What Is the EEOC? https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/what-is-the-eeoc.html accessed 23 April 2018

Hlongwane 2011 http://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/kwazulu-natal/fear-as-albino-boy-vanishes-1.1092451#.VYkfCvmqqko
Hlongwane A 2011 Fear as Albino Boy Vanishes http://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/kwazulu-natal/fear-as-albino-boyvanishes1.1092451#.VYkfCvmqqko accessed 10 July 2016

Kaplan date unknown http://www.accessiblesociety.org/topics/
demographics-identity/dkaplanpaper.htm
Kaplan D date unknown The Definition of a Disability http://www.accessible society.org/topics/demographics-identity/dkaplanpaper.htm accessed 10 July 2016

Ntiwane 2015 http://www.observer.org.sz/news/69308-albinism-classification-is-discriminatory.html
Ntiwane Q 2015 Albinism Classification is Discriminatory http://www.observer.org.sz/news/69308-albinism-classification-is-discriminatory.html accessed 19 June 2016

SAHRC 2015 http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/HRBodies/HRCouncil/
AdvisoryCom/Albinism/SouthAfricanHumanRightsCommission.doc

South African Human Rights Commission 2015 Report on the Situation of Human Rights of Persons with Albinism in South Africa
http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/HRBodies/HRCouncil/AdvisoryCom/Albinism/SouthAfricanHumanRightsCommission.doc accessed 10 March 2016

Western Cape Government 2014 https://www.westerncape.gov.za/general-publication/disability-definitions-models-and-terminology
Western Cape Government 2014 Disability definitions, models and terminology https://www.westerncape.gov.za/general-publication/disability-definitions-models-and-terminology accessed 23 April 2018
Views
  • Abstract 0
  • pdf 0
  • XML 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2018-06-29
Section
Articles