Attacks on the Judiciary: Undercurrents of a Political versus Legal Constitutionalism Dilemma?

  • Herbert Kawadza
Keywords: Political constitutionalism, legal constitutionalism, judiciary, constitution, government, constitutionalism

Abstract

A number of landmark judicial review decisions and the resultant political backlash are arguably to supportive of the claim that political and legal constitutionalism are entrenched in South Africa. The common thread in the legislature and executive's reaction to judicial review decisions is that government supremacy is under threat from legal constitutionalism. More specifically, there is a perception that courts are meddling in the political space through judgments that are aimed at weakening the government's authority and power. Nonetheless, such decisions have had an effect of reinforcing the judiciary's legal constitutional role of reviewing the lawfulness of the other branches' activities. There is need for strategies to minimize this tension as the continued antagonism can have unintended consequences such as the delegitimisation of the judiciary

References

Bibliography

Literature

Arato 2012 ICON
Arato J "Constitutionality and Constitutionalism beyond the State: Two Perspectives on the Material Constitution of the United Nations" 2012 ICON 627-659

Albertyn 2006 SAJHR
Albertyn C "Judicial Independence and the Constitution Fourteenth Amendment Bill" 2006 SAJHR 126-143

Bellamy Political Constitutionalism
Bellamy R Political Constitutionalism: A Republican Defence of the Constitutionality of Democracy (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2007)

Carbonell Theory of New Constitutionalism
Carbonell M The Theory of New Constitutionalism (Iberoamericana Vervuert Madrid 2007)

Ciencia "From Judicialization to Politicization of the Judiciary"
Ciencia AN "From Judicialization to Politicization of the Judiciary: The Philippine Case" in Dressel B (ed) The Judicialization of Politics in Asia (Routledge London 2012) 117-138

Cohen "Sovereignty in the Context of Globalization"
Cohen J "Sovereignty in the Context of Globalization: A Constitutional Pluralist Perspective" in Besson S and Tasioulas J (eds) The Philosophy of International Law (Oxford University Press Oxford 2010) 261-280

Craig "Political Constitutionalism and Judicial Review"
Craig P "Political Constitutionalism and Judicial Review" in Forsyth C et al (eds) Effective Judicial Review: A Cornerstone of Good Governance (Oxford University Press Oxford 2010) 19-42

Craig 2011 ICON
Craig P "Political Constitutionalism and the Judicial Role: A Response" 2011 ICON 112-131

Dawson, Enderlein and Joerges Beyond the Crisis
Dawson M, Enderlein H and Joerges C Beyond the Crisis: The Governance of Europe's Economic, Political and Legal Transformation (Oxford University Press Oxford 2016)

Dodek 2009 JPPL
Dodek A "State v Zuma: The Future of Constitutional Democracy in South Africa" 2009 JPPL 121-128

Epstein Economics of Judicial Behaviour
Epstein L (ed) The Economics of Judicial Behaviour Volume I (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2013)

European Commission for Democracy through Law Definition and Development of Human Rights
European Commission for Democracy through Law Definition and Development of Human Rights and Popular Sovereignty in Europe (Council of Europe Strasbourg 2011)

Feiyue 2006 Front Law China
Feiyue S "Economic Constitutionalism: Path for State to Intervene in the Economy" 2006 Front Law China 372-392

Gee and Webber 2010 OJLS
Gee G and Webber GCN "What is a Political Constitution?" 2010 OJLS 273-299

Gerber 2001 JITE
Gerber DJ "Economic Constitutionalism and the Challenge of Globalization: The Enemy is Gone? Long Live the Enemy: Comment" 2001 JITE 14-22

Gibson and Caldeira 2003 Journal of Politics
Gibson JL and Caldeira GA "Defenders of Democracy? Legitimacy, Popular Acceptance and the South African Constitutional Court" 2003 Journal of Politics 1-30

Goldoni 2012 ICON
Goldoni M "Two Internal Critiques of Political Constitutionalism" 2012 ICON 926-949

Griffith 1979 MLR
Griffith JAG "The Political Constitution" 1979 MLR 1-21

Gumede Restless Nation
Gumede WM Restless Nation: Making Sense of Troubled Times (Tafelberg Cape Town 2012)

Hickman 2005 U Toronto LJ
Hickman T "In Defence of the Legal Constitution" 2005 U Toronto LJ 981-1022

Hirschl 2006 Fordham L Rev
Hirschl R "The New Constitutionalism and the Judicialization of Politics Worldwide" 2006 Fordham L Rev 721-754

Hoexter 2000 SALJ
Hoexter C "The Future of Judicial Review in South African Administrative Law" 2000 SALJ 484-519

Hoexter Administrative Law
Hoexter C Administrative Law in South Africa 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2012)

Honohan "Republicans, Rights, and Constitutions"
Honohan I "Republicans, Rights, and Constitutions: Is Judicial Review Compatible with Republican Self-government?" in Besson S and Martí JL (eds) Legal Republicanism: National and International Perspectives (Oxford University Press Oxford 2009) 83-101

Horowitz "Constitutional Design"
Horowitz DL "Constitutional Design: Proposals versus Processes" in Reynolds A (ed) The Architecture of Democracy (Oxford University Press New York 2002) 15-36

Klug 2010 CCR
Klug H "Finding the Constitutional Court's Place in South Africa's Democracy: The Interaction of Principle and Institutional Pragmatism in the Court's Decision Making" 2010 CCR 1-32

Kurland 1959 Utah L Rev
Kurland PB "The Supreme Court and Its Judicial Critics" 1959 Utah L Rev 457-466

Malila 2011 Zambia LJ
Malila M "The Zambian Judiciary on Trial: Politicisation of the Judiciary or Judicialisation of Politics?" 2011 Zambia LJ 63-152

Mendes 2010 CCR
Mendes CH "Fighting for their Place: Constitutional Courts as Political Actors - A Reply to Heinz Klug" 2010 CCR 33-43
Mollers Three Branches
Mollers C The Three Branches: A Comparative Model of Separation of Powers (Oxford University Press Oxford 2013)

Moseneke 2012 SALJ
Moseneke D "Striking a Balance between the Will of the People and the Supremacy of the Constitution" 2012 SALJ 9-22

Okpaluba 2003 SAPR/PL
Okpaluba C "Justiciability, Constitutional Adjudication and the Political Question in a Nascent Democracy: South Africa (Part 1)" 2003 SAPR/PL 331-348

Pearce 1991 PLR
Pearce D "Executive Versus Judiciary" 1991 PLR 179-193

Pieterse 2004 SAJHR
Pieterse M "Coming to Terms with the Judicial Enforcement of Socio-Economic Rights" 2004 SAJHR 383-417

Rawls Theory of Justice
Rawls J A Theory of Justice (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1971)

Sciulli Theory of Societal Constitutionalism
Sciulli D Theory of Societal Constitutionalism: Foundations of a Non-Marxist Critical Theory (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1992)

Shinar Accidental Constitutionalism
Shinar A Accidental Constitutionalism: The Political Foundations and Implications of Constitution-Making in Israel (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2013)

Siyo et al 2015 PELJ
Siyo L and Mubangizi JC "The Independence of South African Judges: A Constitutional and Legislative Perspective" 2015 PELJ 816-846

Tate 1994 Int'l Pol Sci Rev
Tate C. Neal "The Judicialization of Politics in the Philippines and Southeast Asia" 1994 Int'l Pol Sci Rev 187-197

Tomkins 2010 U Toronto LJ
Tomkins A "The Role of the Courts in the Political Constitution" 2010 U Toronto LJ 1-22

Tushnet 2006 Chi-Kent L Rev
Tushnet MV "Popular Constitutionalism as Political Law" 2006 Chi-Kent L Rev 991-1007

Vinx 2010 Political Theory
Vinx L "Constitutional Indifferentism and Republican Freedom" 2010 Political Theory 809-837

Waldron 2006 Yale LJ
Waldron J "The Core of the Case against Judicial Review" 2006 Yale LJ 1346-1360

Walen 2009 ICON
Walen A "Judicial Review in Review: A Four-Part Defense of Legal Constitutionalism" 2009 ICON 329-354

Van Zyl 2009 PELJ
Van Zyl D "The Judiciary as a Bastion of the Legal Order in Challenging Times" 2009 PELJ 1-13

Vibert New Regulatory Space
Vibert F The New Regulatory Space: Reframing Democratic Governance (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2014)

Vinx 2010 Political Theory
Vinx L "Constitutional Indifferentism and Republican Freedom" 2010 Political Theory 809-837

Case law

Doctors for Life International v Speaker of the National Assembly 2006 6 SA 416 (CC)
Economic Freedom Fighters v Speaker of the National Assembly 2018 2 SA 571 (CC)
Freedom under Law v Acting Chairperson: Judicial Service Commission 2011 3 SA 549 (SCA)
Glenister v President of the Republic of South Africa 2011 3 SA 347 (CC)
Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)
Hlophe v Constitutional Court of South Africa 2008 ZAGPHC 289 (25 September 2008)
Primedia Broadcasting, A Division of Primedia (Pty) Ltd v Speaker of the National Assembly 2015 4 SA 525 (WCC)
Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign 2002 5 SA 721 (CC)
Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development v The Southern African Litigation Centre 2016 ZASCA 17 (15 March 2016)
Oba Lamidi Adeyemi (Alafin of Oyo) & Ors v Attorney General of Oyo State & Ors 1984 1 SCNLR 525
S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)
S v Zuma 2006 2 SACR 191 (W)

Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Internet sources
Bellamy 2007 https://www.ucl.ac.uk/spp/research/publications/
downloads/SPP-WP-26-Inaugural-Lecture.pdf
Bellamy R 2007 Inaugural Lecture: Political Constitutionalism https://www.ucl.ac.uk/spp/research/publications/downloads/SPP-WP-26-Inaugural-Lecture.pdf accessed 11 September 2016

Britton 2015 http://702.co.za/articles/3355/gwede-mantashe-the-judiciary-has-anti-government-tendencies
Britton N 2015 Gwede Mantashe: The Judiciary has Anti-government Tendencies http://702.co.za/articles/3355/gwede-mantashe-the-judiciary-has-anti-government-tendencies accessed 7 November 2016

Budlender 2011 http://www.polity.org.za/article/sa-budlender-address-by-human-rights-lawyer-at-the-bram-fischermemorial-lecture-johannesburg-11112011-2011-11-11
Budlender G 2011 Bram Fischer Memorial Lecture, 11 November 2011 http://www.polity.org.za/article/sa-budlender-address-by-human-rights-lawyer-at-the-bram-fischermemorial-lecture-johannesburg-11112011-2011-11-11 accessed 10 October 2016

Comrie 2015 https://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Gwede-Mantashe-singles-out-problematic-courts-20150622
Comrie S 2015 Gwede Mantashe Singles out 'Problematic Courts' https://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Gwede-Mantashe-singles-out-problematic-courts-20150622 accessed 17 April 2018

Corder, Jagwanth and Soltau 1999 http://www.casac.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Report-on-Parliamentary-Oversight-and-Accountability.pdf
Corder H, Jagwanth S and Soltau F 1999 Report on Parliamentary Oversight and Accountability http://www.casac.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Report-on-Parliamentary-Oversight-and-Accountability.pdf accessed 21 October 2016

Dani 2009 http://www.lse.ac.uk/european-institute/Assets/Documents/
LEQS-Discussion-Papers/LEQSPaper13b.pdf
Dani M 2009 Economic and Social Conflicts, Integration and Constitutionalism in Contemporary Europe http://www.lse.ac.uk/european-institute/Assets/Documents/LEQS-Discussion-Papers/LEQSPaper13b.pdf accessed 30 November 2016

Daniels date unknown http://law.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6279&context=expresso
Daniels R date unknown The Counter-Majoritarian Difficulty and the South African Constitutional Court http://law.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6279&context=expresso accessed 30 October 2016

Democratic Governance and Rights Unit 2014 http://www.dgru.uct.ac.za/sites/default/files/image_tool/images/103/Separation%20of%20Powers%20Draft%20August%202014.pdf
Democratic Governance and Rights Unit 2014 Has the South African Constitutional Court Over-Reached? A Study of the Court's Application of the Separation of Powers Doctrine between 2009 and 2013 http://www.dgru.uct.ac.za/sites/default/files/image_tool/images/103/Separation%20of%20Powers%20Draft%20August%202014.pdf accessed 7 November 2016

eNCA 2015 https://www.enca.com/south-africa/gwede-mantashe-criticises-judiciary-being-problematic
eNCA 2015 Gwede Mantashe Criticises Judiciary as Being Problematic https://www.enca.com/south-africa/gwede-mantashe-criticises-judiciary-being-problematic accessed 17 November 2016

Fin24 2016 https://www.fin24.com/Economy/sa-not-out-of-the-woods-on-ratings-downgrade-20160509
Fin24 2016 SA not out of the Woods on Ratings Downgrade https://www.fin24.com/Economy/sa-not-out-of-the-woods-on-ratings-downgrade-20160509 accessed 17 April 2018

Hartley 2011 https://www.pressreader.com/south-africa/business-day/20111102/282480000577522
Hartley W 2011 "Executive Superior to Courts, Says Zuma" Business Day (2 November 2011) https://www.pressreader.com/south-africa/business-day/20111102/282480000577522 accessed 17 April 2018

House of Lords 2007 https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200607/ldselect/ldconst/151/151.pdf
House of Lords 2007 Relations between the Executive, the Judiciary and Parliament: Report with Evidence. 6th Report of Session 2006-07 https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200607/ldselect/ldconst/151/151.pdf accessed 17 April 2018

Joffe 2016 https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/opinion/2016-12-07-institutional-strength-staved-off-junk-status-downgrade-by-ratings-agencies/
Joffe H 2016 Institutional Strength Staved off Junk Status Downgrade by Ratings Agencies https://www.businesslive.co.za/bd/opinion/2016-12-07-institutional-strength-staved-off-junk-status-downgrade-by-ratings-agencies/ accessed 17 April 2018

Klaaren 2009 http://wiredspace.wits.ac.za/jspui/bitstream/10539/
8749/1/Hlophe%20and%20the%20Politics%20of%20the%20Judiciary.pdf
Klaaren J 2009 Hlophe JP and the Current Politics of the South African Judiciary http://wiredspace.wits.ac.za/jspui/bitstream/10539/8749/1/Hlophe%20and%20the%20Politics%20of%20the%20Judiciary.pdf accessed 27 November 2016

Legalbrief Today 2011 http://legalbrief.co.za/diary/legalbrief-today/story/zuma-lays-down-law-on-separation-of-powers/print/
Legalbrief Today 2011 Zuma Lays Down Law on Separation of Powers http://legalbrief.co.za/diary/legalbrief-today/story/zuma-lays-down-law-on-separation-of-powers/print/ accessed 29 August 2016

Letsoalo, Rossouw and Alcock 2008 https://mg.co.za/article/2008-07-04-anc-boss-accuses-judges-of-conspiracy-against-zuma
Letsoalo M, Rossouw M and Alcock SS 2008 "ANC boss accuses judges of conspiracy against Zuma" Mail and Guardian (4 July 2008) https://mg.co.za/article/2008-07-04-anc-boss-accuses-judges-of-conspiracy-against-zuma accessed 17 April 2018

Mattes et al 2003 http://www.afrobarometer.org/publications/wp24-democratic-governance-south-africa-peoples-view
Mattes R et al 2003 Democratic Governance in South Africa: The People's View (Afrobarometer Paper No 24) http://www.afrobarometer.org/publications/wp24-democratic-governance-south-africa-peoples-view accessed 15 April 2018

McHugh 2002 http://www.hcourt.gov.au/assets/publications/speeches/former-justices/mchughj/mchughj_paris.htm
McHugh AC 2002 Tensions between the Executive and the Judiciary http://www.hcourt.gov.au/assets/publications/speeches/former-justices/mchughj/mchughj_paris.htm accessed 2 December 2016

News24 2011 http://m.news24.com/news24/SouthAfrica/Politics/Nzimande-slams-judicial-dictatorship-20111217-2
News24 2011 Nzimande Slams 'Judicial Dictatorship' http://m.news24.com/news24/SouthAfrica/Politics/Nzimande-slams-judicial-dictatorship-20111217-2 accessed 2 December 2016

South African Judiciary 2015 http://www.judiciary.org.za/index.php/news/
press-statements/statements-2015?start=20
South African Judiciary 2015 Statement on the Meeting of the National Executive and the Judiciary, Union Buildings - Pretoria, 27 August 2015 http://www.judiciary.org.za/index.php/news/press-statements/statements-2015?start=20 accessed 19 April 2018

World Bank date unknown http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTLAWJUSTINST/Resources/JudicialIndependence.pdf
World Bank date unknown Judicial Independence: What It Is, How It Can Be Measured, Why It Occurs http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTLAWJUSTINST/Resources/JudicialIndependence.pdf accessed 12 December 2016
Views
  • Abstract 0
  • pdf 0
  • XML 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2018-07-02
Section
Notes