Unlawful Occupation of Inner-City Buildings: A Constitutional Analysis of the Rights and Obligations involved

Keywords: constitutional property, deprivation, expropriation, housing, land law, redistribution, comparative law.

Abstract

The unlawful occupation of inner-city buildings in South Africa has led to a number of legal disputes between vulnerable occupiers and individual landowners that highlight the conflict between individuals' constitutional right not to be evicted in an arbitrary manner and property owners' constitutional right not to be deprived of property arbitrarily. The cause of this tension is a shortage of affordable housing options for low-income households in the inner cities, a fact which shows that the state is evidently struggling to give effect to its housing obligation embodied in section 26(1) and (2) of the Constitution. In the majority of cases the courts assume that any interference with private landowners' rights beyond a temporary nature would be unjustifiable, but they do this without undertaking a proper constitutional analysis to determine whether a further limitation of the individual landowner's property rights might be justifiable and non-arbitrary in the circumstances of each case.

In general the courts can allow, suspend or refuse the eviction of unlawful occupiers, provided that the order does not amount to an arbitrary deprivation of property. Nevertheless, in some instances the arbitrary deprivation of property is unavoidable, despite the court's best efforts to protect property entitlements. These eviction cases show the limits of the courts' powers both to provide adequate solutions to protect owners' property rights and to give effect to the constitutional housing provision.

In the light of three eviction cases, namely Blue Moonlight, Modderklip and Olivia Road, this article explains the role of the court and the local authority, together with the entitlements and social obligations of inner-city landowners within the framework of the property clause, in order to analyse the constitutionality of the courts' decisions and to suggest ways in which the inner-city housing shortage may be addressed more effectively. This article also considers how two foreign jurisdictions, namely England and the Netherlands, have managed the precarious relationship between urban landowners – who often allow buildings to decay and stand vacant – and the homeless. These jurisdictions provide innovative alternatives to the expropriation of the ownership of private inner-city properties for housing purposes. Similar measures, tailored to accommodate the South African constitutional, economic and socio-economic landscape, may be a welcome addition to the existing statutory powers of the local authorities tasked with combatting homelessness in urban areas.

  

References

Bibliography

Literature

Alexander Global Debate

Alexander GS The Global Debate Over Constitutional Property: Lessons for American Takings Jurisprudence (University of Chicago Press Chicago 2006)

Alexander 2009 Cornell L Rev

Alexander GS "The Social Obligation Norm in American Property Law" 2009 Cornell L Rev 745-820

Badenhorst 1998 De Jure

Badenhorst PJ "Compensation for Purposes of the Property Clause in the New South African Constitution" 1998 De Jure 251-270

Baker 2012 Journal of Housing Law

Baker C "Empty Homes: Strategy or Sticking Plaster?" 2012 Journal of Housing Law 45-47

Besemer "Uitvoering"

Besemer JWJ "Uitvoering van Leegstandwet" in Kleyn WM (ed) Leegstandbestrijding (Tjeenk Willink Deventer 1982) 26-38

Budlender "Constitutional Protection"

Budlender G "The Constitutional Protection of Property Rights" in Budlender G, Latsky J and Roux T Juta's New Land Law (Juta Cape Town 1998) Chapter 1

Calabresi and Melamed 1972 Harv L Rev

Calabresi G and Melamed AD "Property Rules, Liability Rules and Inalienability: One View of the Cathedral" 1972 Harv L Rev 1089-1128

De Vries, Schutte and Vranken Eigendom

De Vries JJM, Schutte RM and Vranken JBM Eigendom en Woonrecht (Kluwer Deventer 1981)

Hofman "Eigentumsgarantie"

Hofman H "Eigentumsgarantie, Erbrecht und Enteignung" in Schmidt-Bleibtreu B and Klein F et al (eds) Schmidt-Bleibtreu,

Hofman, Hopfauf Grundgesetz: Kommentar 11th ed (Heymanns Verlag Munich 2008) 471-522

Hoogenboom "Rechtsbeskerming"

Hoogenboom T "Rechtsbeskerming Onder de Leegstandwet" in Kleyn WM (ed) Leegstandbestrijding (Tjeenk Willink Deventer 1982) 50-59

Kleyn "Opening"

Kleyn WM "Opening met Inleiding" in Kleyn WM (ed) Leegstandbestrijding (Tjeenk Willink Deventer 1982) 9-19

Legwaila 2001Stell LR

Legwaila T "An Introduction to the Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999" 2001 Stell LR 277-282

Lewis 1985 Acta Juridica

Lewis C "The Modern Concept of Ownership of Land" 1985 Acta Juridica 241-266

Liebenberg 2008 TSAR

Liebenberg S "The Application of Socio-economic Rights to Private Law" 2008 TSAR 464-480

Liebenberg Socio-Economic Rights

Liebenberg S Socio-Economic Rights: Adjudication under a Transformative Constitution (Juta Cape Town 2010)

Mukheibir 2000 Obiter

Mukheibir A "The Effect of the Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999 on the Common Law of Landlord and Tenant" 2000 Obiter 325-350

Pascoe 2012 Conveyancer and Property Lawyer

Pascoe S "Social Obligation Norm and the Erosion of Land Ownership" 2012 The Conveyancer and Property Lawyer 484-497

Priemus 2011 Enhr Conference Paper

Priemus H "Squatters and Municipal Policies to Reduce Vacancy – Evidence from the Netherlands" 2011 Enhr Conference Paper 1-6

Pruijt 2003 Int J Urban Reg Res

Pruijt H "Is the Institutionalization of Urban Movements Inevitable? A Comparison of the Opportunities for Sustained Squatting in New York City and Amsterdam" 2003 Int J Urban Reg Res 133-157

Pruijt 2013 Urban Studies

Pruijt H "Culture Wars, Revanchism, Moral Panics and the Creative City. A Reconstruction of the Decline of Tolerant Public Policy: The Case of Dutch Anti-squatting Legislation" 2013 Urban Studies 1114-1129

Radin 1981 Stan L Rev

Radin MJ "Property and Personhood" 1981 Stan L Rev 957-1015

Roux "Property"

Roux T "Property" in Woolman S, Roux T and Bishop M (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa Volume 3 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2003) Chapter 46

Russell "Minimum State Obligations"

Russell S "Introduction – Minimum State Obligations: International Dimensions" in Brand D and Russell S (eds) Exploring the Core Content of Socio-economic Rights: South Africa and International Perspectives (Protea Book House Pretoria 2002) 11-21

Schnably 1993 Stan L Rev

Schnably SJ "Property and Pragmatism: Critique of Radin's Theory of Property and Personhood" 1993 Stan L Rev 347-407

Sonnekus 2004 TSAR

Sonnekus JC "Abandonnering van die Eiendomsreg op Grond en Aanspreeklikheid vir Grondbelasting" 2004 TSAR 747-757

Strydom Demolition Orders

Strydom J A Hundred Years of Demolition Orders: A Constitutional Analysis (LLD-dissertation University of Stellenbosch 2012)

Van der Walt 1987 SALJ

Van der Walt AJ "The Effect of Environmental Measures on the Concept of Landownership" 1987 SALJ 469-479

Van der Walt 1991 Recht en Kritiek

Van der Walt AJ "De Onrechmatige Besetting van Leegstaande Woningen en het Eigendomsbegrip" 1991 Recht en Kritiek 329-359

Van der Walt 1992 TSAR

Van der Walt AJ "Squatting and the Right to Shelter" 1992 TSAR 40-55

Van der Walt 1999 SAPL

Van der Walt AJ "Compensation for Excessive or Unfair Regulation: A Comparative Overview of Constitutional Practice Relating to Regulatory Takings" 1999 SAPL 273-331

Van der Walt 2004 SALJ

Van der Walt AJ "Striving for the Better Interpretation - A Critical Reflection on the Constitutional Court's Harkson and FNB decisions on the Property Clause" 2004 SALJ 854-878

Van der Walt 2005 SALJ

Van der Walt AJ "Retreating from the FNB Arbitrariness Test Already? Mkontwana v Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality and another; Bisset and others v Buffalo City Municipality and others; Transfer Rights Action Campaign v MEC, Local Government and Housing, Gauteng (CC)" 2005 SALJ 75-89

Van der Walt Constitutional Property

Van der Walt AJ Constitutional Property Law 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 2011)

Visser 1985 Acta Juridica

Visser DP "The Absoluteness of Ownership: The South African Common Law Perspective" 1985 Acta Juridica 39-52

Wemes "De Leegstand"

Wemes JP "De Leegstand in die Praktijk" in Kleyn WM (ed) Leegstandbestrijding (Tjeenk Willink Deventer 1982) 39-49

Case law

Netherlands

Arr Rb Middelburg 1 October 1980 and 24 December 1980, NJ 1981, 374

HR 2 februari 1971, 1971 NJ 1971, 385

South Africa

Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd v Occupiers of Saratoga Avenue 2009 1 SA 470 (W)

Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd v Occupiers of Saratoga Avenue [2010] JOL 25031 (GSJ)

City of Cape Town v Helderberg Park Development (Pty) Ltd 2007 1 SA 1 (SCA)

City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Blue Moonlight 2011 4 SA 337 (SCA)

City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd 2012 2 SA 104 (CC)

City of Johannesburg v Changing Tides 74 (Pty) Ltd 2012 6 SA 294 (SCA)

City of Johannesburg v Rand Properties (Pty) Ltd 2007 1 SA 78 (W)

City of Johannesburg v Rand Properties (Pty) Ltd 2007 6 SA 417 (SCA)

Eagle Valley Properties 250 CC v Unidentified Occupants of Erf 952, Johannesburg Situated at 124 Kerk Street, Johannesburg In re: Unidentified Occupants of Erf 952, Johannesburg Situated at 124 Kerk Street, Johannesburg v City of Johannesburg [2011] ZAGPJHC 3

First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Commissioner, South African Revenue Service; First National Bank of SA Ltd t/a Wesbank v Minister of Finance 2002 4 SA 768 (CC)

Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)

Jaftha v Scoeman; Van Rooyen v Stoltz 2005 2 SA 140 (CC)

Maphango v Aengus Lifestyle Properties (Pty) Ltd 2012 3 SA 531 (CC)

Mkontwana v Nelson Mandela Metropolitan Municipality; Bisset v Buffalo City Municipality; Transfer Rights Action Campaign v MEC, Local Government and Housing, Gauteng 2005 1 SA 530 (CC)

Modderfontein Squatters, Greater Benoni City Council v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd; President of the Republic of South Africa v

Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd 2004 6 SA 40 (SCA)

Occupiers of 51 Olivia Road, Berea Township, and 197 Main Street, Johannesburg v City of Johannesburg 2008 3 SA 208 (CC)

Port Elizabeth Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)

President of the Republic of South Africa v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd 2005 5 SA 3 (CC)

Sailing Queen Investments v The Occupants La Colleen Court 2008 6 BCLR 666 (W)

The Occupiers, Shulana Court, 11 Hendon Road, Yeoville, Johannesburg v Steele 2010 9 BCLR 911 (SCA)

United Kingdom

Joyce v Secretary of State for Transport, Local Government and the Regions [2002] EWHC 2213 (Admin)

Legislation

Netherlands

Leegstandwet 21 of May 1981

Wetboek van Strafrecht

Woonruimtewet 1947

South Africa

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Expropriation Act 63 of 1975

Housing Act 107 of 1997

Local Government: Municipal Systems Act 32 of 2000

National Building Regulations and Building Standards Act 103 of 1977

Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998

Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999

Social Housing Act 16 of 2008

United Kingdom

Housing Act 1985

Housing Act 2004

International law instruments

European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (1950)

Government publications

Housing (Empty Dwelling Management Orders). (Prescribed

Exceptions and Requirements) (England) Order 2006, SI. 2006/367

Property Valuation Bill GN 1085 in GG 36993 of 1 November 2013

Internet sources

Department of Rural Development and Land Reform 2012 http://www.ruraldevelopment.gov.za/legislation-and-policies/file/1368

Department of Rural Development and Land Reform 2012 Policy

Framework for Land Acquisition and Land Valuation in a Land Reform Context and for the Establishment of the Office of the Valuer-General as 18 October 2012

http://www.ruraldevelopment.gov.za/legislation-and-policies/file/1368 accessed 10 April 2014

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister 2003 http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20120919132719/www.communities.gov.uk/documents/housing/pdf/138826.pdf

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister 2003 Empty Homes: Temporary Management, Lasting Solutions - A Consultation Paper http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20120919132719/www.communities.gov.uk/documents/housing/pdf/138826.pdf accessed 10 April 2014

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister 2004 https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/7691/191888

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister 2004 Compulsory Purchase and the Crichel Down Rules - Circular 06/2004 https://www.gov.uk/government/

uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/7691/1918885.pdf accessed 10 April 2014

Published
2017-04-11
How to Cite
Strydom, J., & Viljoen, S. (2017). Unlawful Occupation of Inner-City Buildings: A Constitutional Analysis of the Rights and Obligations involved. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 17(4), 1206-1261. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i4a2163
Section
Articles