Managing the Trade-Public Health Linkage in Defence of Trade Liberalisation and National Sovereignty: An Appraisal of United States-Measures affecting the Production and Sale of Clove Cigarettes

Keywords: World Trade Organisation, trade - public health linkage, trade liberalisation, trade and environment linkage, national sovereignty and trade regulation

Abstract

Under the legal framework of the World Trade Organisation (WTO), countries have great flexibility to unilaterally adopt environmental regulations that have effect within their territories only. However, the same discretion does not apply to measures that adversely affect imports or exports. An absence of clear guidelines on how to address some of the attendant issues poses challenges to the effectiveness of a trade-environment linkage. Not surprisingly, attempts to link the environment and trade have resulted in a number of jurisprudentially significant cases in which the WTO's Panel and Appellate Body have tried to address critical questions about the Organisation's capacity to address or manage legal or quasi-legal subjects falling outside the scope of its legal framework. In this regard the Panel and Appellate Body reports in the case of United States - Measures Affecting the Production and Sale of Clove Cigarettes  (US-Clove Cigarettes) have re-ignited the debate on the Organisation's existential challenge of balancing the rights of the sovereign to freely regulate matters pertaining to health or the environment within its domestic domain with the need to maintain the sanctity of the multilateral trade order. This article demonstrates that in the US-Clove Cigarettes case the WTO Panel and Appellate Body, whilst managing to successfully defend the integrity of WTO Member States' treaty commitments and the overarching importance of trade liberalisation within the organisation's policy foundations even in the context of public health-related regulations, failed to provide any substantive affirmation of the development-related challenges facing developing countries that are part of the WTO family.

 

Google_Scholar_120219.png    ScienceOpen_Log0343238.png

References

Bibliography

Literature

Cosby Trade and Climate Change

Cosbey A Trade and Climate Change: Issues in Perspective (Winnipeg: International Institute for Sustainable Development Winnipeg 2008)

Houser et al Levelling the Carbon Playing Field

Houser T et al Levelling the Carbon Playing Field (Peterson Institute for International Economics and World Resources Institute Washington 2008)

Hufbauer et al Global Warming

Hufbauer GC et al Global Warming and the World Trading System (Peterson Institute for International Economics Washington 2009)

Kulovesi WTO Dispute Settlement System

Kulovesi K The WTO Dispute Settlement System: Challenges of the Environment, Legitimacy and Fragmentation (Kluwer Law International Alphen aan den Rijn 2011)

Lester 2012 Free Trade Bulletin

Lester S "Free Trade and Tobacco: Thank You for not Smoking (Foreign) Cigarettes" 2012 (49) Free Trade Bulletin 1-5

Lester, Mercurio and Davies World Trade Law

Lester S, Mercurio B and Davies A World Trade Law: Text, Materials and Commentary 2nd ed (Hart Oxford 2012)

Sinha 2012 Trade, Law and Development

Sinha S "A Review of Kati Kulovesi, the WTO Dispute Settlement System: Challenges of the Environment, Legitimacy and Fragmentation (Kluwer International 2011)" 2012 Trade, Law and Development 268-282

Sunstein 2007 Tulsa Law Review

Sunstein CR "Beyond Judicial Minimalism" 2007 Tulsa Law Review 825-842

Voon 2012 ASIL Insights

Voon T "The WTO Appellate Body Outlaws Discrimination in US Flavoured Cigarette Ban" 2012 ASIL Insights Vol. 16 Issue 15

Reports

Appellate Body Report Brazil - Measures Affecting Imports of Retreaded Tyres WT/DS332/AB/R (December17, 2007) DSR 2007: IV, 1527

Appellate Body Report European Communities - Measures Affecting Asbestos and Asbestos Containing Products 99, WT/DS135/AB/R (April 5, 2001) DSR 2001: VII, 3243

Appellate Body Report European Communities - Regime for the Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas WT/DS27/AB/R (September 9, 1997) DSR 1997: II, 591

Appellate Body Report Korea - Measures Affecting Imports of Fresh, Chilled and Frozen Beef WT/DS161, 169/AB/R (January 10, 2001) DSR 2001: I, 5

Appellate Body Report, United States - Measures Affecting the Production and Sale of Clove Cigarettes, WT/DS406/AB/R (April 4, 2012)

Appellate Body Report United States - Measures Concerning the Importation, Marketing and Sale of Tuna and Tuna Products WT/DS381/AB/R (May 16, 2012)

GATT Panel Report Thailand - Restrictions on Importation of and Internal Taxes on Cigarettes DS10/R (November 7, 1990) BISD 37S/200

GATT Panel Report US Measures Affecting the Importation, Internal Sale and Use of Tobacco DS44/R 131

Request for Consultations by Indonesia US-Clove Cigarettes 5, WT/DS406/1 (April 4, 2010)

US House Report to the WTO Panel Exhibit 67, 37, 2011

WTO Panel Report European Communities - Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products WT/DS291/R, WT/DS292/R, WT/DS293/R (November 21, 2006) DSR 2006: III-VIII, 847

WTO Panel Report United States - Measures Affecting the Production and Sale of Clove Cigarettes WT/DS406/R (September2, 2011)

Case law

FDA v Brown and Williamson Tobacco Corporation 529 US 120 161 (2000)

Legislation

Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, Public Law No. 111-131, 2009

Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, United States Code, Title 21, Chapter 9

International instruments

Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (1995)

Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade (1995)

Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (2005)

Marrakech Agreement Establishing the WTO (1994)

Published
2017-04-11
How to Cite
Warikandwa, T. V., & Osode, P. C. (2017). Managing the Trade-Public Health Linkage in Defence of Trade Liberalisation and National Sovereignty: An Appraisal of United States-Measures affecting the Production and Sale of Clove Cigarettes. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 17(4), 1262-1285. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i4a2164
Section
Articles