The Potential of Capstone Learning Experiences in addressing perceived Shortcomings in LLB Training in South Africa

Keywords: Legal education, LLB, capstone course, capstone learning experience, curriculum, curriculum design, comparative education, content analysis.

Abstract

Current debates about legal education in South Africa have revealed the perception that the LLB curriculum does not adequately integrate various outcomes, in particular outcomes relating to the development of skills in communication, problem solving, ethics, and in general a holistic view of the law in practice. One mechanism that has been mooted as a potential remedy to this situation is capstone courses, which will consolidate and integrate the four years of study in the final year and build a bridge to the world of practice. A literature review on capstone courses and learning experiences (collectively referred to as capstones) indicates that these curriculum devices as modes of instruction offer particular pedagogical advantages. These include inculcating a strong perception of coherence across the curriculum and hence discipline in students, providing the opportunity for students to reflect on their learning during the course of the entire programme, creating an opportunity to engage with the complexity of law and legal practice, and guiding students through the transition from university to professional identity. An empirical analysis of the modes of instruction used in LLB curricula at 13 South African law faculties/schools indicates that there are six categories of existing modules or learning experiences that already exhibit elements of capstone-course design. These are clinics, internships, moots, research projects, topical capstones and capstone assessment. A further comparative study into foreign law curricula in especially Australia and the United States of America reveals four further noteworthy approaches to capstone-course design, namely problem-based learning, the virtual office, conferences and remedies courses. The empirical study suggests that capstones indeed hold the potential as learning experiences to address some of the challenges facing legal education in South Africa but that further development of this curriculum-design element is required.

    

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Literature

ABA Standards and Rules

American Bar Association ABA Standards and Rules of Procedure for Approval of Law Schools 2013-2014 (ABA Publishing Chicago 2013)

Adams et al 2003 ACM SIGCSE Bulletin

Adams L et al "Challenges in Teaching Capstone Courses" 2003 35(3) ACM SIGCSE Bulletin 219-220

Altbach and Kelly "Introduction"

Altbach PG and Kelly GP "Introduction: Perspectives on Comparative Education" in New Approaches to Comparative Education (University of Chicago Press Chicago 1986) 1-10

Biggs and Tang Teaching for Quality Learning

Biggs J and Tang C Teaching for Quality Learning at University (Society for Research into Higher Education and Open University Press Berkshire 2011)

Brockopp, Hardin-Pierce and Welsh 2006 Journal of Nursing Education

Brockopp DY, Hardin-Pierce M and Welsh JD "An Agency-financed Capstone Experience for Graduating Seniors" 2006 45(4) Journal of Nursing Education 137-140

Collier 2000 Sociology of Education

Collier PJ "The Effects of Completing a Capstone Course on Student Identity" 2000 Sociology of Education 285-299

Cilliers 2005 Theory, Culture & Society

Cilliers P "Complexity, Deconstruction and Relativism" 2005 22(5) Theory, Culture & Society 255-267

De Klerk 2005 SALJ

De Klerk W "University Law Clinics in South Africa" 2005 SALJ 929-950

Dicker 2013 Advocate

Dicker L "The 2013 LLB Summit" 2013 26(2) Advocate 15-20

Durel 1993 Teaching Sociology

Durel RJ "The Capstone Course: A Rite of Passage" 1993 Teaching Sociology 223-225

Gardner and Van der Veer "The Emerging Movement"

Gardner JN and Van der Veer G "The Emerging Movement to Strengthen the Senior Experience" in The Senior Year Experience: Facilitating Integration, Reflection, Closure, and Transition (Jossey-Bass Publishers San Francisco 1998) 3-20

Gillespie 2007 JCLLE

Gillespie AA "Mooting for learning" 2007 JCLLE 19-37

Greenbaum 2012 Stell LR

Greenbaum L "Current Issues in Legal Education: A Comparative Review" 2012 Stell LR 16-39

Hatchard and Slapper "The Role of the Commonwealth"

Hatchard J and Slapper G "The Role of the Commonwealth and Commonwealth Associations in Strengthening Administrative Law and Justice" in Corder H (ed) Comparing Administrative Justice Across the Commonwealth (Juta Cape Town 2006) 405-422

Henscheid Professing the Disciplines

Henscheid JM Professing the Disciplines: An Analysis of Senior Seminars and Capstone Courses (University of South Carolina Columbia SC 2000)

Jervis and Hartley 2005 Issues in Accounting Education

Jervis KJ and Hartley CA "Learning to Design and Teach Accounting Capstone" 2005 Issues in Accounting Education 311-339

Kift 2004 JCLLE

Kift S "A Tale of Two Sectors: Dynamic Curriculum Change for a Dynamically Changing Profession" 2004 2(2) JCLLE 5-22

Kift 2008 Legal Educ Rev

Kift S "21st Century Climate for Change: Curriculum Design for Quality Learning Engagement in Law" 2008 Legal Educ Rev 1-30

Kift, Field and Wells 2008 eLaw Journal

Kift S, Field R and Wells I "Promoting Sustainable Professional Futures for Law Graduates through Curriculum Renewal in Legal Education: A Final Year Experience (FYE2)" 2008 eLaw Journal 145-158

Kleyn and Viljoen Beginner's Guide

Kleyn D and Viljoen F Beginner's Guide for Law Students (Juta Claremont 2010)

Kloppenberg 2007 U Tol L Rev

Kloppenberg LA "Lawyer as a Problem Solver: Curricular Innovation at Dayton" 2007 U Tol L Rev 547-556

Kloppenberg 2009 Rutgers L Rev

Kloppenberg LA "Educating Problem Solving Lawyers for our Profession and Communities" 2009 Rutgers L Rev 1099-1114

Novitzki 2001 Informing Science

Novitzki JE "Critical Issues in the Administration of an Integrated Capstone Course" 2001 Informing Science 372-378

Pantazis 2013 Advocate

Pantazis A "The LLB" 2013 26(2) Advocate 22-23

Quinot 2012 SALJ

Quinot G "Transformative Legal Education" 2012 SALJ 411-433

Redmond 1998 Southern Communication Journal

Redmond MV "Outcomes Assessment and the Capstone Course in Communication" 1998 Southern Communication Journal 68-75

Rosenberry and Vicker 2006 Journalism & Mass Communication Educator

Rosenberry J and Vicker LA "Capstone Courses in Mass Communication Programs" 2006 Journalism & Mass Communication Educator 267-283

Rowles et al 2004 Assessment Update

Rowles CJ et al "Toward a Model for Capstone Experiences: Mountaintops, Magnets, and Mandates" 2004 Assessment Update 1-2, 13-15

Ruhl 2008 Georgia State LR

Ruhl JB "Law's Complexity: A Primer" 2008 Georgia State LR 885-911

Saunders "Apples, Oranges and Comparative Administrative Law"

Saunders C "Apples, Oranges and Comparative Administrative Law" in Corder H (ed) Comparing Administrative Justice Across the Commonwealth (Juta Cape Town 2006) 423-449

Sullivan et al Educating Lawyers

Sullivan WM et al Educating Lawyers: Preparation for the Profession of Law (Jossey-Bass San Francisco 2007)

TLU Interdisciplinary Higher Education

Teaching and Learning Unit, University of Melbourne Interdisciplinary Higher Education (The Teaching and Learning Unit Carlton 2010)

Van Acker and Bailey 2011 Asian Social Science

Van Acker L and Bailey J "Embedding Graduate Skills in Capstone Courses" 2011 Asian Social Science 69-76

Van der Merwe 2007 De Rebus

Van der Merwe P "The Trouble with LLB Graduates…" 2007 (April) De Rebus 2

Von Prondczynsky 2002 Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft

Von Prondczynsky A "Institutionalisierung und Ausdifferenzierung der Erziehungswissenschaft als Forschungsdisziplin" 2002 5(Special ed) Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft 221-230

Wagenaar 1993 Teaching Sociology

Wagenaar TC "The Capstone Course" 1993 Teaching Sociology 209-214

Weaver and Partlett 2007 Review of Litigation

Weaver RL and Partlett DF "Remedies as a 'capstone' Course" 2007 The Review of Litigation 269-279

Webb 2005 Clev St L Rev

Webb J "Law, ethics, and complexity: Complexity theory and the normative reconstruction of law" 2005 Clev St L Rev 227-242

Government publications

DoHET 2012 Green Paper

Department of Higher Education and Training Green Paper for Post-school Education and Training Pretoria: Department of Higher Education and Training (Gen N 11 in GG 34935 of 13 January 2012)

Legal Practice Bill B20B-2012

Internet sources

ALTC 2010 www.olt.gov.au/resource-law-ltas-statement-altc-2010

Australian Learning and Teaching Council 2010 Learning and Teaching Standards Project: Bachelor of Laws. Learning and Teaching Academic Standards Statement www.olt.gov.au/resource-law-ltas-statement-altc-2010 accessed 15 October 2013

CALD 2013 http://www.cald.asn.au/slia/index.htm

Council of Australian Law Deans 2013 Studying Law in Australia http://www.cald.asn.au/slia/index.htm accessed 15 October 2013

IBA 2013 http://www.ibanet.org/PPID/Constituent/Student_Committee/qualify_

lawyer_NewYork.aspx

International Bar Association 2013 How to Qualify as a Lawyer in New York http://www.ibanet.org/PPID/Constituent/Student_Committee/qualify_lawyer_NewYork.aspx accessed 15 October 2013

Jeffery 2013 http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2013/20131018-dm-kzn-law-society.html

Jeffery JH 2013 Keynote Address by the Deputy Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development at the Annual General Meeting of the KwaZulu-Natal Law Society http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2013/20131018-dm-kzn-law-society.html accessed 23 October 2013

Kift et al 2012 https://wiki.qut.edu.au/display/capstone/Home

Kift S et al 2012 Curriculum Renewal in Legal Education: Capstone Experiences Toolkit https://wiki.qut.edu.au/display/capstone/Home accessed 15 October 2013

Kift et al 2013 https://wiki.qut.edu.au/display/capstone/Home

Kift S et al 2013 Curriculum Renewal in Legal Education: Final Report https://wiki.qut.edu.au/display/capstone/Home accessed 15 October 2013

LETR 2013 http://letr.org.uk/the-report/index.html

Legal Education and Training Review 2013 Setting Standards: The future of Legal Services Education and Training Regulation in England and Wales http://letr.org.uk/the-report/index.html accessed 15 October 2013

LSSA 2010 www.lssa.org/upload/LSSA%20Press%20Release%20LLB%20report_

_11_2010.pdf

Law Society of South Africa 2010 Press Release: Law Society Welcomes LLB Curriculum Review – Repeats Concern at Law Graduates' Lack of Basic Skills www.lssa.org/upload/LSSA%20Press%20Release%20LLB%20report_22_11_2010.pdf accessed 15 October 2013

McKenzie et al 2004 http://aaueng.com/Portals/0/AAU/Publications/Capstone

%20Design%20Courses%20and%20Assessment.pdf

McKenzie LJ et al 2004 Capstone Design Courses and Assessment: A National Study http://aaueng.com/Portals/0/AAU/Publications/Capstone%20Design%20Courses%20and%20Assessment.pdf accessed 20 October 2013

Nair 2012 http://www.timeslive.co.za/thetimes/2012/07/06/llb-report-urges-numeracy-literacy-training

Nair N 2012 'LLB Report Urges Numeracy, Literacy Training' The Times 6 July 2006 http://www.timeslive.co.za/thetimes/2012/07/06/llb-report-urges-numeracy-literacy-training accessed 15 October 2013

QAA 2007 http://www.qaa.ac.uk/Publications/InformationAndGuidance/Pages/

Subject-benchmark-satatement-Law-2007.aspx

Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education 2007 Subject Benchmark Statement: Law http://www.qaa.ac.uk/Publications/InformationAndGuidance/

Pages/Subject-benchmark-satatement-Law-2007.aspx accessed 21 October 2013

Radebe 2012 http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2012/20120517_min_budget-vote.html

Radebe JT 2012 Budget Vote Speech by Mr JT Radebe, MP, Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development, Tuesday, 17 May 2012, National Assembly, Parliament http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2012/20120517_min_budget-vote.html accessed 23 October 2013

SALDA, LSSA and GCB 2013 www.lssa.org/upload/LLB%20SUMMIT%20PRESS%

RELEASE.pdf

South African Law Deans Association, Law Society of South Africa and General Council of the Bar 2013 Joint Press Statement: Legal Education in Crisis? Law Deans and the Legal Profession Set to Discuss Refinement of LLB Degree www.lssa.org/upload/LLB%20SUMMIT%20PRESS%20RELEASE.pdf accessed 15 April 2013

SAQA date unknown http://regqs.saqa.org.za/viewQualification.php?id=22993

South African Qualifications Authority date unknown Registered Qualification: Bachelor of Laws http://regqs.saqa.org.za/viewQualification.php?id=22993 accessed 15 October 2013

Published
2017-04-11
How to Cite
Quinot, G., & Van Tonder, S. (2017). The Potential of Capstone Learning Experiences in addressing perceived Shortcomings in LLB Training in South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 17(4), 1249-1390. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i4a2168
Section
Articles