The National Credit Act Regarding Suretyships and Reckless Lending

Keywords: National Credit Act, credit guarantees, suretyship, guarantees, reckless credit

Abstract

In terms of the National Credit Act a credit provider may conclude a credit agreement with a consumer only after he has made a proper financial assessment and concludes that the consumer will be able to satisfy all of his obligations under all his credit agreements. However, a practice of not conducting this affordability assessment has evolved amongst certain credit providers where the credit agreement involved is a suretyship agreement. This article investigates whether or not a suretyship agreement is indeed a credit agreement in terms of the National Credit Act, and if a financial assessment should be conducted in the case of a suretyship agreement. The main aim of the article is to try to identify what the concept of a “credit guarantee”, as defined in the Act, encompasses and ultimately if the common-law contract of suretyship falls under this definition. Our conclusion is that “credit guarantee” is as vague and problematic as many of the other definitions in the Act. If one reads the Act in its entirety (including the regulations to the Act), it seems unlikely that the legislature intended not to regulate common-law suretyships also.

    

References

Bibliography

Andrews and Millet Guarantees
Andrews GM and Millet R Law of Guarantees 4th ed (Sweet & Maxwell London 2005)

Bennett 1994 JBL
Bennett HN "Performance Bonds and the Principle of Autonomy" 1994 JBL 574-586

Caney Suretyship
Caney LR The Law of Suretyship in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 1970)

Coleman 1990 Lloyd’s Maritime and Commercial Law
Coleman M "Performance Guarantees" 1990 Lloyd’s Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly 223-243

De Ly 1999 Int’l Law
De Ly F "The UN Convention on Independent Guarantees and Stand-by Letters of Credit" 1999 Int’l Law 831-847

De Villiers Suretyship
De Villiers APM The Suretyship and the Indemnity Contract Differentiated (LLM dissertation Unisa not dated)

De Wet and Van Wyk Kontraktereg
De Wet JC and Van Wyk AH Die Suid-Afrikaanse Kontraktereg en Handelsreg (Vol 1) 5th ed (Butterworths Durban 1992)

Dolan Commercial and Standby Credits
Dolan JF The Law of Letters of Credit: Commercial and Standby Credits (Warren, Gorham & Lamont Boston 1996)


Eitelberg 2002 SALJ
Eitelberg E "Autonomy of Documentary Credit Undertakings in South African Law" (2002) SALJ 120-137

Ellinger Modern Banking Law
Ellinger EP Modern Banking Law (Clarendon Press Oxfordshire 1987)

Forsyth and Pretorius Suretyship
Forsyth CF and Pretorius JT Caney’s Law of Suretyship in South Africa 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2002)

Goode Guide to the URDG
Goode R Guide to the ICC Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees: ICC Publication No. 510 (ICC Paris 1992)

Goode 1995 St Louis Univ LJ
Goode R "Abstract Payment Undertakings and the Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce" 1995 St Louis Univ LJ 725-743

Gorton 1997 JBL
Gorton L "Draft UNCITRAL Convention on Independent Guarantees" 1997 JBL 240-253

Grové Borgstelling
Grové NJ Die Formaliteitsvereiste by Borgstelling (LLM dissertation UP 1984)

Hahlo and Kahn Union of South Africa
Hahlo HR and Khan E The Union of South Africa: The Development of It’s Laws and Constitution (Delran, NJ Datapro Research Corp 1960)

Hapgood Banking
Hapgood M Paget’s Law of Banking 12th ed (Butterworths London 2002)


Kelly-Louw 2008 SA Merc LJ
Kelly-Louw M "The Prevention and Alleviation of Consumer Over-indebtedness" 2008 SA Merc LJ 200-226

Kurkela Letters of Credit
Kurkela MS Letters of Credit and Bank Guarantees Under International Trade Law 2nd ed (Oxford University Press New York 2008)

Lotz "Suretyship"
Lotz JG "Suretyship" in Joubert WA (ed) The Law of South Africa (Durban Butterworths 1997)

Lubbe 1984 THRHR
Lubbe GF "Die Onderskeid tussen Borgtog en Ander Vorme van Persoonlike Sekerheidstellings" 1984 THRHR 383-393

Mostert 2009 De Rebus
Mostert D "Suretyship Agreement Must Comply with the NCA" 2009 June De Rebus 53-55

O’Brien "Letters of Intent"
O’Brien P "Letters of Intent and Demand Guarantees" in University of Johannesburg Centre for Banking Law Annual Banking Law Update Conference 1993 Johannesburg 134-180

Otto National Credit Act
Otto JM The National Credit Act Explained (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006)

Otto 2011 TSAR
Otto JM "Statutêr verbode bedinge in kredietooreenkomste" 2011 TSAR 38-61


Penn 1986 JIBL
Penn G "On-demand Bonds – Primary or Secondary Obligations?" 1986 JIBL 224-230

Perrignon 1991 JBFLP
Perrignon R "Performance Bonds and Standby Letters of Credit: The Australian Experience" 1991 JBFLP 157-166

Pretorius 1982 THRHR
Pretorius JT "Diners Club South Africa (Pty) Ltd v Durban Engineering (Pty) Ltd 1980 3 SA 53 (A): Borgkontrak of Vrywaringskontrak?" 1982 THRHR 73-76

Pretorius 2001 SA Merc LJ
Pretorius JT "Surety and Indemnity" 2001 SA Merc LJ 95-101

Renke, Roestoff and Haupt 2007 Obiter
Renke S, Roestoff M and Haupt F "The National Credit Act: New Parameters for the Granting of Credit in South Africa" 2007 Obiter 229-270

Roberts Law of Contract
Roberts AA Wessels, Sir JW: The Law of Contract in South Africa 2nd ed (Butterworths Durban 1951)

Roestoff and Renke 2005 Obiter
Roestoff M and Renke S "Debt relief for consumers - the interaction between insolvency and consumer protection legislation: Part 1" 2005 Obiter 561-574

Scholtz et al National Credit Act
Scholtz JW et al Guide to the National Credit Act (LexisNexis Durban 2008)

Schwank 1991 Comp LYB Int'l Bus
Schwank F "Electronic International Bank Guarantees and Letters of Credit" 1991 Comp LYB Int’l Bus 317-330

Scott et al Law of Commerce
Scott TJ et al Law of Commerce in South Africa (Oxford University Press Cape Town 2009)

Sonnekus 2009 TSAR
Sonnekus JC "Indemniteitsborgstelling en Borgbeskerming: Fedbond Nominees (Pty) Ltd v Meier" 2009 TSAR 165-184

Stoop 2008 De Jure
Stoop PN "Kritiese Evaluasie van die Toepassingsveld van die 'National Credit Act'" 2008 De Jure 352-370

Strydom Aksessoriteitsbeginsel
Strydom N Die Aksessoriteitsbeginsel in die Suid-Afrikaanse Reg (LLM dissertation UJ 2000)

Thomas Roman Law
Thomas JAC Textbook of Roman Law 2nd ed (North-Holland Pub Co Amsterdam 1981)

Van Niekerk and Schulze International Trade
Van Niekerk JP and Schulze WG The South African Law of International Trade: Selected Topics 2nd ed (SA Legal Publications Pretoria 2006)

Wood Security and Guarantees
Wood PR Law and Practice of International Law: Comparative Law of Security and Guarantees (Sweet & Maxwell London 1995)

Register of court cases

Basil Read (Pty) Ltd v Beta Hotels (Pty) Ltd 2001 2 SA 760 (C)
Business Buying and Investment Co Ltd v Linaae 1959 3 SA 93 (T)
Carrim v Omar 2001 3 All SA 71 (W)
Cohen v Louis Blumberg (Pty) Ltd 1949 2 SA 849 (W)
Corrans v Transvaal Government and Coull’s Trustee1909 TS 605
First National Bank of Southern Africa Ltd v Bophuthatswana Consumer Affairs Council 1995 2 SA 853 (BG)
Firstrand Bank Ltd v Carl Beck Estates (Pty) Ltd 2009 3 SA 384 (T)
Gerber v Wolson 1955 1 SA 158 (A)
Harrowsmith v Ceres Flats (Pty) Ltd 1979 2 SA 722 (T)
Hutchinson v Hylton Holdings 1993 2 SA 405 (T)
List v Jungers 1979 3 SA 106 (A)
Mahomed v Lockhat Bros & Co Ltd 1944 AD 230
Marubeni Hong Kong and South China Ltd v The Mongolian Government 2004 2 Lloyd’s Rep 198 (QB (Com Ct))
Mouton v Die Mynwerkersunie 1977 1 SA 119 (A)
Nedbank Ltd v Wizard Holdings 2010 (5) SA 523 (GSJ)
Neuhoff v York Timbers Ltd 1984 4 SA 666 (T)
Pangbourne Properties Ltd v Nitor Construction (Pty) Ltd 1993 4 SA 206 (W)
Sapirstein v Anglo African Shipping Co (SA) Ltd 1978 4 SA 1 (A)
State Trading Corporation of India Ltd v ED and F Man (Sugar) Ltd and ANR 1981 Com LR 235 (CA)
Structured Mezzanine Investments (Pty) Ltd v Davids 2010 (6) SA 622 (WCC)
Trans-Drakensberg Bank Ltd v The Master 1962 4 SA 417 (N)
Trust Bank of Africa Ltd v Frysch 1977 3 SA 562 (A)
Union and South-West Africa Insurance Co Ltd v Hull 1972 4 SA 481 (D)
Union Government v Van der Merwe 1921 TPD 318

Register of legislation

National Credit Act 34 of 2005
General Law Amendment Act 50 of 1956
Statute of Frauds 1677 (England)

Register of government publications

GN R489 in GG 28864 of 31 May 2006

Register of internet sources

Logan 2008 www.debtpack.com
Logan S 2008 The National Credit Act 34 of 2005: A Basic Guide for Attorneys www.debtpack.com/Portals/0/docs/LSSA_NCA_GUIDE.pdf [23 April 2011]
Views
  • Abstract 192
  • PDF 46
  • XML 2
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2017-06-06
Section
Articles