An Employer's Recourse to Lock-Out and Replacement Labour: An Evaluation of Recent Case Law

Keywords: Collective bargaining, Industrial relations, strikes, Defensive and offensive lockouts, Pickets, Replacement (scab) labour


South African labour affairs are in a volatile state. Conflicting rights and interests as well as the balancing of these rights and interests are contributing to this state of affairs. In recent years, the contentious issues of workers' right to use their economic power to put pressure on employers and employers' recourse to lock-out and replacement labour have come under the spotlight again. Prolonged, violent and unprotected strikes have raised the question whether our industrial relations framework should be revisited, and have complicated matters even further. The question whether employers may use replacement labour and have recourse to lock-outs when an impasse exists during wage negotiations has come to the fore again and is evaluated in the context of the adversarial collective bargaining framework in South Africa.


Google_Scholar_93.png    ScienceOpen_Log0331.png

Author Biography

Monray Marsellus Botha, University of Pretoria

BLC LLB LLM BCom (Hons) (Pret), MCom (UJ), LLD (NWU), Advanced Diploma in Insolvency and Practice (AIPSA) (Pret), Advanced Diploma in Corporate Law (UJ), Advanced Diploma in Alternative Dispute Resolution (AFSA/Pret). Head of Department of Mercantile Law, Faculty of Law, University of Pretoria. E-mail: monray.botha


Anstey 2013 SAJLR
Anstey M "Marikana – and the Push for a New South African Pact" 2013 SAJLR 133-145
Bendix Industrial Relations
Bendix S Industrial Relations in South Africa 5thed (Juta Cape Town 2010)
Benjamin 2014 ILJ
Benjamin P "Beyond Dispute Resolution: The Evolving Role of Commissioner for Conciliation and Arbitration" 2014 ILJ 1-29
Botha 2015 De Jure
Botha MM "Responsible Unionism during Collective Bargaining and Industrial Ac-tion: Are we there yet?" 2015 De Jure 328-350
Botha 2015 Obiter
Botha MM "What Constitutes a Matter of Mutual Interest in Relation to a Strike? A Tale of Two Recent Cases" 2015 Obiter 194-209
Creamer 1998 ILJ
Creamer K "The Meaning and Implications of the Inclusion in the Constitution of a Right to Strike and the Exclusion of a Lock-out Right: Towards Asymmetrical Parity in the Regulation of Industrial Action" 1998 ILJ 1-23
Davies and Freedland Khan Freud's Labour and the Law
Davies P and Freedland M (eds) Khan Freud's Labour and the Law 3rd ed (Stevens London 1983)
Davis and Le Roux 2012 Acta Juridica
Davis D and Le Roux M "Changing the Role of Corporation: A Journey Away from Adversarialism" 2012 Acta Juridica 306-325
Department of Labour Annual Industrial Action Report 2006
Department of Labour Annual Industrial Action Report 2006 (Government Printers Pretoria 2006)
Department of Labour Annual Industrial Action Report 2010
Department of Labour Annual Industrial Action Report 2010 (Government Printers Pretoria 2010)
Department of Labour Annual Industrial Action Report 2014
Department of Labour Annual Industrial Action Report 2014 (Government Printers Pretoria 2014)
Department of Labour Annual Industrial Action Report 2015
Department of Labour Annual Industrial Action Report 2015 (Government Printers Pretoria 2015)
Du Toit 2007 ILJ
Du Toit D "What is the Future of Collective Bargaining (and Labour Law) in South Africa?" 2007 ILJ 1405-1435
Du Toit et al Labour Relations Act
Du Toit D et al The Labour Relations Act of 1995 (Butterworths Durban 1998)
Grogan Collective Labour Law
Grogan J Collective Labour Law (Juta Cape Town 2010)
Grogan Workplace Law
Grogan J Workplace Law 11thed (Juta Cape Town 2014)
Godfrey et al Collective Bargaining
Godfrey et al Collective Bargaining in South Africa: Past, Present & Future? (Juta Cape Town 2010)
Hepple and Leroux Laws against Strikes
Hepple B and Leroux S (eds) Laws against Strikes (FrancoAngeli Milan 2015)
Jordaan 1997 LDD
Jordaan B "Collective Bargaining under the New Labour Relations Act: The Resur-rection of Freedom of Contract" 1997 LDD 1-9
ILO Freedom of Association
ILO Freedom of Association: Digest of Decisions and Principles of the Freedom of Association Committee of the Governing Body of the ILO 5th ed (International La-bour Office Geneva 2006)
Lagrange 1995 Ann Surv SA L
Lagrange R "Labour Law" 1995 Ann Surv SA L 498-580
Levy "Strike Action"
Levy A "Strike Action: Will Things Ever be the Same" in Levy A and Motshabi K (eds) The Dispute Resolution Digest 2013 (Juta Cape Town 2013) 5-20
Levy "An examination of industrial action: 2013"
Levy A "An examination of industrial action: 2013" in Levy and Motshabi (eds) The Dispute Resolution Digest 2014 (Juta Cape Town 2014) 5-24
Manamela and Budeli 2013 CILSA
Manamela E and Budeli M "Employee's Right to Strike and Violence in South Afri-ca" 2013 CILSA 308-336
Masiloane 2010 Acta Criminologica
Masiloane D "Guaranteeing the Safety of Non-striking Employees during Strikes: The Fallacy of Policing" 2010 Acta Criminologica 31-41
McQuarrie Industrial Relations in Canada
McQuarrie F Industrial Relations in Canada 4th ed (Wiley Toronto 2015)
Myburgh 2004 ILJ
Myburgh J "100 Years of Strike Law" 2004 ILJ 962-976
National Planning Commission 2012
National Planning Commission “National Development Plan 2030: Our Future — Make it Work” 2012

Ndungu 2009 Int'l J Labour Res
Ndungu S "Perspectives on Collective Bargaining in the Global South: The Case of South Africa" 2009 Int'l J Labour Res 81-98
Rycroft 2015 ILJ
Rycroft A "Strikes and Amendments to the LRA" 2015 ILJ 1-20
Samuel 2013 J Contemp Man
Samuel M "The Mineworkers' Unprocedural Strike: Setting the Path for Redefining Collective Bargaining Practice in South Africa" 2013 J Contemp Man 238-258
Satgar 1998 LDD
Satgar V "The LRA and Work-place Forums: Legislative Provisions, Origins, and Transformative Possibilities" 1998 LDD 42-63
Stewart and Townsend 1966 U Pa L Rev
Stewart F and Townsend R "Strike Violence and the Need for Federal Injunctions" 1966 U Pa L Rev 459-486
Tenza 2015 LDD
Tenza M "An Investigation into the Causes of Violent Strikes in South Africa: Some Lessons from Foreign Law and Possible Solutions" 2015 LDD 211-231
Todd Collective Bargaining Law
Todd C Collective Bargaining Law (Siber Ink Cape Town 2004)
Van der Welden and Dribbusch Strikes Around the World
Van der Welden S and Dribbusch H (eds) Strikes Around the World 1965-2005: Case-Studies of 15 Countries (Ascant Amsterdam 2007)
Van Niekerk and Smit Law@Work
Van Niekerk A and Smit N (eds) Law@Work 3rded (LexisNexis Durban 2015)
Von Holdt 2010 Transformation
Von Holdt K "Institutionalisation, Strike Violence and Local Moral Orders" 2010 Transformation 127-151
Case law
Betha v BTR Sarmcol (a Division of BTR Dunlop Ltd) 1998 19 ILJ 459 (SCA)
FAWU v National Co-operative Dairies 1989 10 ILJ 490 (IC)
FAWU v Premier Foods 2010 31 ILJ 1654 (LC)
In re Certification of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 1996 4 SA 744 (CC)
Mahlangu v SA Transport & Allied Workers Union 2014 35 ILJ 1193 (GSJ)
National Construction Building and Allied Workers Union v Betta 1999 20 ILJ 1617 (CCMA)
National Union of Technikon Employees v Technikon 2000 21 ILJ 1645 (LC)
Ntimane v Agrinet 1999 20 ILJ 809 (LC)
NUMSA v Bader Bop 2003 24 ILJ 305 (CC)
NUMSA v GM Vincent 1991 4 SA 304 (SCA)
Putco v TAWUSA 2015 36 ILJ 2048 (LAC)
S v Matshili 1991 3 SA 264 (A)
SACCAWU v Sun International 2016 1 BLLR 97 (LC)
SACWU v Afrox 1999 20 ILJ 1718 (LC)
SACTWU v Coats 2001 22 ILJ 1413 (LC)
TAWUSA obo members v Algoa Bus Company and Putco 2013 34 ILJ 2949 (LC)
TAWUSA v Putco 2016 6 BLLR 537 (CC)
Technikon SA v National Union of Technikon Employees of SA 2001 22 ILJ 427 (LAC)
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa (Interim), 1993
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Labour Relations Act 28 of 1956
Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995
National Economic Development and Labour Council Act 35 of 1994
Railway Regulation Act of 1908
Government publications
Draft Labour Relations Bill of 1995
Explanatory Memorandum to the Labour Relations Bill (1995 16 ILJ 278)
GN 765 in GG 18887 of 15 May 1998
International instruments
ILO Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining Convention (No 98 of 1949)
Internet sources
Odendaal 2014
Odendaal N 2014 SA One of the World's Most Violent, Strike-prone Countries accessed 10 September 2016
  • Abstract 128
  • PDF 271
  • XML 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018