Inheritance Rights for Posthumously Procreated Children: A Growing Challenge for the Law

  • Frederick Noel Zaal University of KwaZulu-Natal
  • Justin d'Almaine University of KwaZulu-Natal
Keywords: Cryogenics; post-mortem conception; posthumous procreation; children's inheritance; nasciturus doctrine; intestate succession; posthumous child; in vitro fertilisation

Abstract

Significant advances in cryogenic technology render it possible to freeze and store human gametes. Under appropriate laboratory conditions frozen gametes can remain viable for long periods of time. In consequence, it is possible for a child to be conceived and procreated after the death of one or both parents. This raises some challenging juristic problems. Amongst these are implications for the law of inheritance. Where a valid will expressly refers to a child who will be procreated after the testator's death, the child's right to inherit will be secured. However, where a will merely refers to children as a class, or with intestate succession, it becomes uncertain whether a posthumously procreated child has a right to inherit. South African legislation governing succession, the common law and the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 all fail to provide definitive answers. Because of this and as the numbers of posthumously procreated children are likely to increase as artificial reproduction services become more widely available, there is a need for South African legislation to clarify their inheritance rights.

References

Bibliography

Literature

Alberta Law Reform Institute Assisted Reproduction after Death
Alberta Law Reform Institute Assisted Reproduction after Death: Parentage and Implications - Final Report 106 (Alberta Law Reform Institute Edmonton 2015)

Alberta Law Reform Institute Succession and Posthumously Conceived Children
Alberta Law Reform Institute Succession and Posthumously Conceived Children - Report 23 (Alberta Law Reform Institute Edmonton 2012)

Atherton 1999 Leg Stud
Atherton R "En Ventre sa Frigidaire: Posthumous Children in the Succession Context" 1999 Leg Stud 139-164

Bard and Penrose 2015 Health Matrix
Bard JS and Penrose L "Responding to Requests for Assisted Reproductive Technology Intervention Involving Women who cannot Consent" 2015 Health Matrix: The Journal of Law-Medicine 227-256

Black and Therriault 2010-2011 Est Tr & Pensions J
Black HS and Therriault J "Future Estate Planning Considerations: Cryopreservation, Cryonics and Cord Blood" 2010-2011 Est Tr & Pensions J 151-162

Boezaart "Child Law"
Boezaart T "Child Law, the Child in South African Private Law" in Boezaart T (ed) Child Law in South Africa (Juta Claremont 2009) 3-37

Croucher 2017 Trusts and Trustees
Croucher R 2017 "Laws of Succession versus the New Biology: Reflections from Australia" 2017 Trusts and Trustees 66-79

Diamond 1998 NY Int'l L Rev
Diamond KE "Cryogenics, Frozen Embryos and the Need for New Means of Regulation: Why the US is Frozen in its Current Approach" 1998 NY Int'l L Rev 77-99

Doucet 2013 Dalhousie J Legal Stud
Doucet CE "From en ventre sa mere to Thawing an Heir: Posthumously Conceived Children and the Implications for Succession Law in Canada" 2013 Dalhousie J Legal Stud 1-20

Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine 2013 Fertil Steril
Ethics Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine "Posthumous Collection and Use of Reproductive Tissue: A Committee Opinion" 2013 Fertil Steril 1842-1845

Heaton South African Law of Persons
Heaton J The South African Law of Persons 4th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2012)

Johnston 1997 CLJ
Johnston D "The Renewal of the Old" 1997 CLJ 80-95
Justinian Digest
Watson A (trans) The Digest of Justinian (University of Pennsylvania Press Philadelphia 1986)

Kruger 2011 SALJ
Kruger R "Equality and Unfair Discrimination: Refining the Harksen Test" 2011 SALJ 479-512

Lupton 1997 TSAR
Lupton M "Human Fertilisation Outside the Womb - Law and Policy" 1997 TSAR 746-759

Moodley Comparative Analysis
Moodley K A Comparative Analysis of the Legal Status of Cryopreserved Embryos Resulting from In Vitro Fertilisation, for the Purpose of Custody Issues during Divorce Proceedings (LLM-thesis University of KwaZulu-Natal 2014)

Moyo 2012 AHRLJ
Moyo A "Reconceptualising the ‘Paramountcy Principle’: Beyond the Individualistic Construction of the Best Interests of the Child" 2012 AHRLJ 142-177

Okohue et al 2009 Afr J Reprod Health
Okohue JE et al 2009 "The Effect of Endometrial Thickness on In Vitro Fertilisation, (IVF) - Embryo Transfer/Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI) Outcome" Afr J Reprod Health 113-122

Peart 2015 VU W L Rev
Peart N "Life beyond Death: Regulating Posthumous Reproduction in New Zealand" 2015 VU W L Rev 725-754

Peebles 2013 Mo L Rev
Peebles AT "Challenges and Inconsistencies Facing the Posthumously Conceived Child" 2013 Mo L Rev 497-515

Peters 2006 UC Davis L Rev
Peters PG "The Ambiguous Meaning of Human Conception" 2006 UC Davis L Rev 199-228

Pickles 2012 PELJ
Pickles C "Termination-of-Pregnancy Rights and Foetal Interests in Continued Existence in South Africa: The Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996" 2012 PELJ 403-434

Pickles 2013 Stell LR
Pickles C "Personhood: Proving the Significance of the Born Alive Rule with Reference to Medical Knowledge of Foetal Viability" 2013 Stell LR 146-164

Pillay 2010 Stell LR
Pillay R 2010 "The Beginning of Human Personhood: Is South African Law Outdated?" Stell LR 230-238

Schäfer Child Law in South Africa
Schäfer L Child Law in South Africa. Domestic and International Perspectives (LexisNexis Durban 2011)

Smit 2015 De Rebus
Smit VT "Everyone has the Right to Life - Fact or a Nasciturus Fiction?" March 2015 De Rebus 42

Smith 2014 AHRLJ
Smith A 2014 "Equality Constitutional Adjudication in South Africa" AHRLJ 609-632

Thomasson 2013-2014 Denv U L Rev
Thomasson L "Burns v Astrue: 'Born in Peculiar Circumstances,' Posthumously Conceived Children and the Adequacy of State Intestacy Laws" 2013-2014 Denv U L Rev 715-740

Walmsley 2014 Obstet Gynaecol Forum
Walmsley LJ "Obstetric Outcome after Assisted Conception" 2014 Obstet Gynaecol Forum 29-35

Walters 2014 Val U L Rev
Walters J "Thawing the Inheritance Rights of Maybe Babies: An Answer to Indiana's Statutory Silence on Posthumously Conceived Children" 2014 Val U L Rev 1229-1268

Wood 2010 Ga L Rev
Wood MK 2010 "It takes a Village: Considering other Interests at Stake when Extending Inheritance Rights to Posthumously Conceived Children" Ga L Rev 873-912

Case law
Chisholm v East Rand Property Mines Ltd 1909 TH 297
Christian Lawyers Association of SA v Minister of Health 1998 4 SA 1113 (T)
Christian League of Southern Africa v Rall 1981 2 SA 821 (OPA)
East Zulu Motors (Pty) Limited v Empangeni/Ngwezelane Transitional Local Council 1998 2 SA 61 (CC)
Ex Parte Boedel Steenkamp 1962 3 SA 954 (O)
H v Fetal Assessment Centre 2015 2 SA 193 (CC)
H v Kingsbury Foetal Assessment Centre (Pty) Ltd 2014 ZAWCHC 61 (24 April 2014)
Harksen v Lane 1998 1 SA 300 (CC)
Jooste v Score Supermarket 1999 2 SA 1 (CC)
National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 2 SA 1 (CC)
Pinchin v Santam Insurance Co Ltd 1963 2 SA 254 (W)
President of the Republic of South Africa v Hugo 1997 4 SA 1 (CC)
Prinsloo v Van der Linde 1997 3 SA 1012 (CC)
Re Estate of the Late K and Re the Administration and Probate Act 1935: Ex Parte the Public Trustee 1996 TASSC 24 (22 April 1996)
S v M 2008 3 SA 232 (CC)
Shields v Shields 1946 CPD 242
Stewart v Botha 2008 6 SA 310 (SCA)

Legislation
California Probate Code, 2015
Children's Act 38 of 2005
Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996
Constitution Act, 1982 [Canada]
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 200 of 1993
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987
Law of Succession Amendment Act 43 of 1992
Succession Law Reform Act, RSO 1990 [Ontario]
Wills Act 7 of 1953
Wills, Estates and Succession Act, 2009 [SBC 2009] British Columbia

International instruments
African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (1990)
United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989)

Internet sources
Albertyn and Goldblatt 2006 http://www.chr.up.ac.za/chr_old/closa/
chapters/Conference_Paper_on_the_Right_to_Equality.pdf
Albertyn C and Goldblatt B 2006 Section 9: The Right to Equality http://www.chr.up.ac.za/chr_old/closa/chapters/Conference_Paper_on_the_Right_to_Equality.pdf accessed 13 November 2017

Deane 2009 http://uir.unisa.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10500/2012/10chapter
9.pdf
Deane T 2009 The Constitutional Dimensions of Affirmative Action in South Africa http://uir.unisa.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10500/2012/10chapter9.pdf accessed 13 November 2017

Gary 2005 https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/publishing/pro
bate_property_magazine
Gary SN 2005 Posthumously Conceived Heirs. Where the Law stands and what to do about It now https://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/
publishing/probate_property_magazine accessed 15 September 2017

Human Fertilization Embryology Authority 2014 http://
www.hfea.gov.uk/IVF.html
Human Fertilization Embryology Authority 2014 IVF – What Is In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF) and How Does It Work? http://www.hfea.gov.uk/IVF.html accessed 12 October 2017

Shayne 2015 https://www.hklaw.com/privatewealthblog/benefits-due-a-child
Shayne D 2015 Posthumously Conceived Child as Heir Depends on where https://www.hklaw.com/privatewealthblog/benefits-due-a-child accessed on 13 September 2017

Zago 2014 http://scholarship.shu.edu/student_scholarship/609
Zago MK 2014 Second-Class Children: The Intestate Inheritance Rights Denied to Posthumously Conceived Children and how Legislative Reform and Estate Planning Techniques can Create Equality http://scholarship.shu.edu/student_scholarship/609 accessed 13 November 2017
Views
  • Abstract 0
  • pdf 0
  • xml 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2018-06-21
Section
Articles