Remedial Principles and Meaningful Engagement in Education Rights Disputes

Keywords: Meaningful engagement, constitutional education rights, school governance, public law remedial principles, participatory remedies, supervisory orders, Susan Sturm.

Abstract

 This article evaluates the meaningful engagement doctrine in the education rights jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court in the light of a set of normative principles developed by Susan Sturm for evaluating participatory public law remedies. It commences by identifying four principles for evaluating participatory remedies appropriate to South African constitutional law and jurisprudence. Thereafter the relevant jurisprudence is analysed and evaluated in the light of these principles. The article concludes by making proposals for the development of meaningful engagement as a participatory remedy in educational rights disputes. These proposals seek to ensure a better alignment between the meaningful engagement remedy and the four remedial principles identified. 

 

Google_Scholar_12013.png   ScienceOpen_Log034310.png

Author Biography

Sandra Liebenberg, University of Stellenbosch

BA LLB (UCT) LLM (Essex) LLD (Witwatersrand University). Distinguished Professor and H.F.Oppenheimer Chair in Human Rights Law, University of Stellenbosch. Email: sliebenb@sun.ac.za.

References

Literature

Bishop "Remedies"
Bishop M "Remedies" in Woolman S, Roux T and Bishop M (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2006) ch 9

Chenwi "Democratizing the Socio-economic Rights-Enforcement Process"
Chenwi L "Democratizing the Socio-economic Rights-Enforcement Process" in Alviar García H, Klare K and Williams LA (eds) Social and Economic Rights in Theory and Practice: Critical Inquiries (Routledge London 2015) 178-196

Dorf and Sabel 1998 Columbia LR
Dorf MC and Sabel CF "A Constitution of Democratic Experimentalism" 1998 Columbia LR 267-473

Fiss 1984 Yale LJ
Fiss O "Against Settlement" 1984 Yale LJ 1073-1090

Froneman 2005 Stell LR
Froneman J "Legal Reasoning and Legal Culture: Our 'Vision' of Law" 2005 Stell LR 3-20

Hoexter Administrative Law in South Africa
Hoexter C Administrative Law in South Africa 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2012)

Jamieson et al (eds) South African Child Gauge
Jamieson L et al (eds) South African Child Gauge (Children's Institute, University of Cape Town 2010-2011)

Liebenberg Socio-Economic Rights
Liebenberg S Socio-Economic Rights: Adjudication under a Transformative Constitution (Juta Cape Town 2010)

Liebenberg 2012 AHRLJ
Liebenberg S "Engaging the Paradoxes of the Universal and Particular in Human Rights Adjudication: The Possibilities and Pitfalls of 'Meaningful Engagement'" 2012 AHRLJ 1-29
Liebenberg and Young "Adjudicating Social and Economic Rights: Can Democratic Experimentalism Help?"

Liebenberg S and Young K "Adjudicating Social and Economic Rights: Can Democratic Experimentalism Help?" in Alviar García H, Klare K and Williams LA (eds) Social and Economic Rights in Theory and Practice: Critical Inquiries (Routledge London 2015) 237-257

Mbazira Litigating Socio-Economic Rights
Mbazira C Litigating Socio-Economic Rights: A Choice between Corrective and Distributive Justice (PULP Pretoria 2009)

McConnachie and McConnachie 2012 SALJ
McConnachie C and McConnachie C "Concretising the Right to Basic Education" 2012 SALJ 554-590

Muller 2011 Stell LR
Muller G "Conceptualising 'Meaningful Engagement" as a Deliberative Democratic Partnership" 2011 Stell LR 742-758

Muller and Liebenberg 2013 SAJHR
Muller G and Liebenberg S "Developing the Law of Joinder in the Context of the Eviction of People from their Homes" 2013 SAJHR 554-57
0
Mureinik 1994 SAJHR
Mureinik E "A Bridge to Where? Introducing the Interim Bill of Rights" 1994 SAJHR 31-48

Murungi 2015 PER
Murungi LN "Inclusive Basic Education in South Africa: Issues in its Conceptualisation and Implementation" 2015 PER 3160-3195

Nolan Children's Socio-Economic Rights, Democracy and the Courts
Nolan A Children's Socio-Economic Rights, Democracy and the Courts (Hart Oxford 2011

O'Regan 2008 Acta Juridica
O'Regan C "From Form to Substance: The Constitutional Jurisprudence of Laurie Ackermann" 1-17

Sabel and Simon 2004 Harvard LR
Sabel CF and Simon WH "Destabilization Rights: How Public Law Litigation Succeeds" 2004 Harvard LR 1015-1101

Simbo 2012 LDD
Simbo C "Defining the Term Basic Education in the South African Constitution: An International Law Approach" 2012 LDD 162-184

Smit and Oosthuizen 2011 South African Journal of Education
Smit MH and Oosthuizen IJ "Improving School Governance through Participative Democracy and the Law" 2011 South African Journal of Education 55-73

Sturm 1991 The Georgetown LJ
Sturm SP "A Normative Theory of Public Law Remedies" 1991 The Georgetown LJ 1355-1446

Van der Berg 2013 SAJHR
Van der Berg S "Meaningful engagement: Proceduralising socio-economic rights further or infusing administrative law with substance?" 2013 SAJHR 376-398

Woolman The Selfless Constitution
Woolman S The Selfless Constitution: Experimentalism and Flourishing as Foundations of South Africa's Basic Law (Juta Cape Town 2013)

Case law

AllPay Consolidated Investment Holdings v CEO, SA Social Security Agency (No 2) 2014 4 SA 179 (CC)
AllPay Consolidated Investment Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Chief Executive Officer of the South African Social Security Agency 2015 6 BCLR 653 (CC)
Christian Education South Africa v Minister of Education 2000 4 SA 757 (CC)
City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Hlophe [2015] 2 All SA 251 (SCA)
DPP, Transvaal v Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development 2009 4 SA 222 (CC)
Fose v Minister of Safety and Security 1997 3 SA 786 (CC)
Governing Body of the Juma Musjid Primary School v Essay NO 2011 8 BCLR 761 (CC)
Head of Department, Department of Education, Free State Province v Welkom High School 2014 2 SA 228 (CC)
Hoffman v South African Airways 2001 1 SA 1 (CC)
MEC for Education v Governing Body of the Rivonia Primary School 2013 6 SA 582 (CC)
Member of the Executive Council for Education, Gauteng v Federation of Governing Bodies for South African Schools [2015] 4 All SA 591 (SCA).
Minister of Basic Education v Basic Education for All [2016] 1 All SA 369 (SCA)
Minister of Health v Treatment Action Campaign (No.2) 2002 5 SA 721 (CC)
Mpumalanga Department of Education v Hoërskool Ermelo 2010 2 SA 415 (CC)
National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 2 SA 1 (CC)
Occupiers of 51 Olivia Road, Berea Township and 197 Main Street Johannesburg v City of Johannesburg 2008 3 SA 208 (CC)
Pheko v Ekhurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality 2015 5 SA 600 (CC)
Residents of Joe Slovo Community, Western Cape v Thubelisha Homes 2010 3 SA 454 (CC)
Residents of Joe Slovo Community, Western Cape v Thubelisha Homes 2011 7 BCLR 723 (CC)
S v Bhulwana; S v Gwadiso 1996 1 SA 388 (CC)
Schubart Park Residents Association v City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality 2013 1 SA 323 (CC)
Pheko v Ekhurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality 2012 2 SA 598 (CC)

Legislation

Housing Act 107 of 1997
Municipal Systems Act 32 of 2000
Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998
Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000
Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000
South African Schools Act 84 of 1996

Internet sources
Spaull 2012 Poverty and Privilege
Spaull N Poverty & Privilege: Primary School Inequality in South Africa, Stellenbosch Economic Working Papers: 13/12, University of Stellenbosch and Bureau for Economic Research http://www.ekon.sun.ac.za/wpapers/
2012/wp132012/wp-13-2012.pdf accessed 5 January 2016
Clowes 1995
Clowes A "Schools' Bias Stymies Black Pupils" http://mg.co.za/article/2015-12-02-schools-bias-stymies-black-pupils accessed 5 January 2016
Views
  • Abstract 1308
  • PDF 498
  • XML 2
  • epub 6
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2017-05-17
Section
Articles