Werknemers as Lasgewende Ouers in Surrogasie-Aangeleenthede: Die Geboorte van nuwe Verlof-behoeftes in Suid-Afrika / Employees as Commissioning Parents in Surrogacy Matters: The Birth of New Leave Requirements in South Africa

Anri Botes, Laetitia Fourie

Abstract


Commissioning parents, in terms of a surrogacy agreement, have the same parental obligations towards their child as traditional parents. Yet, despite the legitimising of surrogacy in the Children’s Act 38 of 2005, no provision has been made for suitable parental leave to be granted to these persons so that they may fulfil their parental obligations. The only leave that is currently available to commissioning parents is three days family responsibility leave in terms of section 27 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997 (BCEA). It is submitted that this leave is insufficient. In MIA v State Information Technology Agency 2015 36 ILJ 1905 (LC), the Labour Court indicated that amendments to labour legislation are necessary to address the lacuna in this respect. The Labour Laws Amendment Bill of 2015 has since proposed relevant amendments to such leave in terms of the BCEA. While the amendments are welcomed, the proposed period and management of the different types of leave give rise to concern and should be addressed. The latest developments in the United Kingdom in the field of parental leave make it a worthy comparator to provide guidelines for the improvement of the abovementioned Bill. In so doing, South African law can also sufficiently protect the interests of the parties to a surrogacy agreement, including the child born in terms thereof.

Lasgewende ouers ingevolge ʼn surrogasie ooreenkoms beskik oor dieselfde ouerlike verpligtinge as tradisionele ouers teenoor hulle kind. Alhoewel dit waar is, word sedert die statutêre erkenning van surrogasie in die Kinderwet nog geen geskikte ouerskapverlof vir hierdie persone gebied om aan sodanige ouerlike verpligtinge te voldoen nie. Die enigste verlof tans tot lasgewende ouers se beskikking is drie dae gesinsverantwoordelikheidsverlof ingevolge artikel 27 van die Wet op Basiese Diensvoorwaardes 75 van 1997 (WBDV). Dit word aan die hand gedoen dat hierdie verlof onvoldoende is. In MIA v State Information Technology Agency 2015 36 ILJ 1905 (LC) het die Arbeidshof aangetoon dat wysigings in hierdie verband aan die arbeidswetgewing noodsaaklik is ten einde die betrokke leemte aan te spreek. Die Labour Laws Amendment Bill van 2015 het sedertdien relevante wysigings aan verlof tot die WBDV voorgestel. Terwyl die vermelde wysigings verwelkom word, is die periodes en die bestuur van die verskillende tipes voorgestelde verlof kommerwekkend en behoort dit aangespreek te word. Die resente regsontwikkeling in die Verenigde Koninkryk op hierdie gebied kan as ʼn waardevolle vergelykende maatstaf dien ten einde riglyne vir die verbetering van bogenoemde konsepwet te bied. Sodoende kan ook die Suid-Afrikaanse reg die belange van die partye tot ʼn surrogaatooreenkoms, insluitende die van die kind daaruit gebore, na behore beskerm

 


Keywords


leave; surrogacy; commissioning parents; basic conditions of employment act; labour law; labour laws amendment bill; verlof; surrogasie; Wet op Basiese Diensvoorwaardes; gedeelde ouerskapsverlof; Verenigde Koninkryk

Full Text:

PDF XML

References


Botes en Kaplan 2015 Without Prejudice

Botes J en Kaplan J "It's Leave, Jim, but not as we know it" 2015 Without Prejudice 37-39

Clark 1993 SALJ

Clark B "Surrogate Motherhood: Comment on the South African Law Commission's Report on Surrogate Motherhood (Project 65)" 1993 SALJ 769-778

Crawshaw, Blyth en Van den Akker 2012 JSWFL

Crawshaw M, Blyth E en Van den Akker O "The Changing Profile of Surrogacy in the UK - Implications for National and International Policy and Practice" 2012 JSWFL 267-277

Fenton-Glynn 2015 CLJ

Fenton-Glynn C "The Difficulty of Enforcing Surrogacy Regulations" 2015 CLJ 34-37

Field, Bagraim en Rycroft 2012 SAJLR

Field CG, Bagraim JJ en Rycroft A "Parental Leave Rights: Have Fathers been Forgotten and does it Matter?" 2012 63(2) SAJLR 30-41

Griffith 2014 JBM

Griffith R "European Union Law Denies Commissioning Parents Paid Leave on the Birth of their Child" 2014 BJM 372-373

Hames "Lesbians and the Civil Union Act"

Hames M "Lesbians and the Civil Union Act in South Africa: A Critical Reflection" in Judge M, Manion A en De Waal S (red) To Have and to Hold: The Making of Same-Sex Marriage in South Africa (Jacana Auckland Park 2009) 258-267

HM Government Modern Workplaces

HM Government Modern Workplaces: Government Response to Flexible Parental Leave Proposal (Department for Business, Innovation and Skills Londen 2012)

Horsey 2015 Surrogacy UK

Horsey K "Surrogacy in the UK: Myth Busting and Reform" 2015 Surrogacy UK 1-58

Horsey 2016 Med L Rev

Horsey K "Fraying at the Edges: UK Surrogacy Law in 2015" 2016 Med L Rev 1-14

Hutchinson "Hague Convention on Surrogacy"

Hutchinson A "The Hague Convention on Surrogacy: Should we Agree or Disagree" Unpublished contribution delivered at the CLE Conference (October 2012 Philadelphia)

IAO Maternity and Paternity at Work

Internasionale Arbeidsorganisasie Maternity and Paternity at Work: Law and Practice across the World (International Labour Office Geneva 2014)

Larkey 2002-2003 Drake L Rev

Larkey AM "Redefining Motherhood: Determining Legal Maternity in Gestational Surrogacy Agreements" 2002-2003 Drake L Rev 605-632

Maillard Protect the Future

Maillard J Protect the Future: Maternity, Paternity and Work (International Labour Organisation Geneva 2009)

Mitchell 2015 ILJ

Mitchell G "Encouraging Fathers to Care: The Children and Families Act 2014 and Shared Parental Leave" 2015 ILJ 123-133

Motsiri en Timothy 2015 HR Future

Motsiri N en Timothy O "Sir, your Maternity Leave has been Granted…" 2015 HR Future 44-46

Nicholson en Bauling 2013 De Jure

Nicholson C en Bauling A "Surrogate Motherhood Agreements and their Confirmation: A New Challenge for Practitioners?" 2013 De Jure 510-538

Nicholson 2013 SAJHR

Nicholson C "When Moral Outrage Determines a Legal Response: Surrogacy as Labour" 2013 SAJHR 496-514

Rehel 2014 Gender & Society

Rehel ME "When Dad Stays Home too: Paternity Leave, Gender, and Parenting" 2014 Gender & Society 110-132

Russel 1989 J Fam L

Russel IS "Within the Best Interests of the Child: The Factor of Parental Status in Custody Disputes Arising from Surrogacy Agreements" 1989 J Fam L 585-671

Slabbert 2012 SAJBL

Slabbert MN "Legal Issues Relating to the Use of Surrogate Mothers in the Practice of Assisted Conception" 2012 SAJBL 27-32

Sloth-Nielsen 2013 FLN

Sloth-Nielsen J "Surrogacy, South African Style" 2013 FLN 19-20

Tieu 2009 J Med Ethics

Tieu MM "Altruistic Surrogacy: The Necessary Objectification of Surrogate Mothers" 2009 J Med Ethics 171-175

Van Niekerk 2015 PER

Van Niekerk C "Section 294 of the Children's Act: Do Roots Really Matter?" 2015 PER 398-428

WGO 2003 Progress in Reproductive Health Research

Wêreld Gesondheidsorganisasie "Assisted Reproduction in Developing Countries – Facing up to the Issues" 2003 (63)

Progress in Reproductive Health Research 1

Regspraak

B v C (Surrogacy: Adoption) 2015 EWFC 17

CD v ST 2014 EUECJ C-167/12

Ex Parte WH 2011 6 SA 514 (GNP)

MIA v State Information Technology Agency (Pty) Ltd 2015 36 ILJ 1905 (LC)

Z v A Government Department; The Board of Management of a Community School (Grand Chamber) saaknommer C-363/12 (18 Maart 2014)

Wetgewing, wetsontwerpe en kodes van goeie praktyk

Suid-Afrika

Children's Status Act 82 van 1987

Grondwet van die Republiek van Suid Afrika, 1996

Human Tissue Act 65 van 1983

Kinderwet 38 van 2005

Kode van Goeie Praktyk oor die Beskerming van Werknemers Tydens Swangerskap en na die Geboorte van ʼn Kind, 1998

Labour Laws Amendment Bill, 2015

Surrogacy Arrangements Act, 1985

Wet op Arbeidsverhoudinge 66 van 1995

Wet op Basiese Diensvoorwaardes 75 van 1997

Wet op Burgerlike Verbintenisse 17 van 2006

Wet op Gelyke Indiensneming 55 van 1998

Wet op Kindersorg 74 van 1983

Wet op Werkloosheidsversekering 63 van 2001

Verenigde Koninkryk

Children and Families Act, 2014

Employment Act, 2002

Employment Rights Act, 1996

Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act, 2008

Maternity and Adoption Leave Regulations, 2014

Maternity and Adoption Leave (Curtailment of Statutory Rights of Leave) Regulations, 2014

Maternity and Parental Leave etc. Regulations, 1999

Paternity and Adoption Leave Regulations, 2002

Shared Parental Leave Regulations, 2014

Surrogacy Arrangements Act, 1985

Internasionale instrumente

Convention for the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (1981)

Convention on the Rights of the Child (1990)

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1967)

Maternity Protection Convention 183 van 2000

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)

Publikasies in die Staatskoerant

Kennisgewing 1174 in SK 39448 van 25 November 2015

Internet bronne

Anon 2015 http://www.mymedholiday.com/article-info/50/639/surrogacy-statistics-numbers-success-rates-worldwide

Anonymous 2015 Surrogacy Statistics: Numbers and Success Rates Worldwide http://www.mymedholiday.com/article-info/50/639/surrogacy-statistics-numbers-success-rates-worldwide datum van gebruik 21 Junie 2016

Complaint Board 2016 http://www.complaintboard.com/department-of-labour-complaints-l15953.html

Complaint Board 2016 Consumer Complaints and Reviews about the Department of Labour http://www.complaintboard.com/department-of-labour-complaints-l15953.html datum van gebruik 23 Junie 2016

Departement Onderwys KZN 2000 http://www.kzneducation.

gov.za/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=XsaTcbqZp7k=

Departement Onderwys KZN 2000 Policy on Leave http://www.kzneducation.gov.za

/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=XsaTcbqZp7k= datum van gebruik 29 Junie 2016

European Parliament 2013 http://www.europarl.europa.eu/

RegData/etudes/etudes/join/2013/474403/IPOL-JURI_ET(2013)474403

_EN.pdf

European Parliament 2013 A Comparative Study on the Regime of Surrogacy in EU Member States http://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/

etudes/etudes/join/2013/474403/IPOL-JURI_ET(2013)474403_EN.pdf datum van gebruik 21 Junie 2016

Government of the United Kingdom 2016 https://www.gov.uk/employers-paternity-pay-leave/eligibility

Government of the United Kingdom 2016 Statutory Paternity Pay and Leave: Employer Guide https://www.gov.uk/employers-paternity-pay-leave/eligibility datum van gebruik 24 Junie 2016

IFAASA datum onbekend http://www.ifaasa.co.za/infertility-facts-statistics

Infertility Awareness Association of South Africa datum onbekend Facts and Statistics http://www.ifaasa.co.za/infertility-facts-statistics/ datum van gebruik 21 Junie 2016

Living and Loving 2016 http://www.livingandloving.co.za/family/adoption-everything-you-need-to-know

Living and Loving 2016 Adoption in South Africa: Everything You Need to Know http://www.livingandloving.co.za/family/adoption-everything-you-need-to-know datum van gebruik 29 Junie 2016

Nelson Mandela Children's Fund datum onbekend http://www.nelsonmandelachildrensfund.com/nelson-mandela-quotes-about-children

Nelson Mandela Children's Fund datum onbekend Quotes about Children http://www.nelsonmandelachildrensfund.com/nelson-mandela-quotes-about-children/ datum van gebruik 12 Julie 2016

Ruzicka 2015 http://www.moneybags.co.za/article/how-to-adopt-a-child-in-south-africa

Ruzicka A 2015 How yo Adopt a Child in South Africa http://www.moneybags.co.za/article/how-to-adopt-a-child-in-south-africa/ datum van gebruik 29 Junie 2016

Stats SA 2013 http://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P0307/

P03072013.pdf

Statistics South Africa 2013 Marriages and Divorces http://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P0307/P03072013.pdf datum van gebruik 12 Julie 2016

SurrogacyMed datum onbekend http://www.surrogacymed.com/surrogacy/what-is-surrogacy.html

SurrogacyMed datum onbekend What is Surrogacy? http://www.surrogacymed.com/surrogacy/what-is-surrogacy.html datum van gebruik 20 Junie 2016

University of Minnesota datum onbekend http://hrlibrary.umn.

edu/research/ratification-southafrica.html

University of Minnesota datum onbekend Ratification of International Human Rights Treaties - South Africa http://hrlibrary.umn.edu/research/ratification-southafrica.html datum van gebruik 22 Junie 2016

WebMD 2016 http://www.webmd.com/parenting/baby/tc/postpartum-first-6-weeks-after-childbirth-topic-overview

WebMD 2016 Post-partum: First 6 Weeks after Childbirth http://www.webmd.com/parenting/baby/tc/postpartum-first-6-weeks-after-childbirth-topic-overview datum van gebruik 30 Junie 2016

WGO datum onbekend http://www.who.int/genomics/gender/en

/index6.html

Wêreld Gesondheidsorganisasie datum onbekend Gender and Genetics: Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ATRs) http://www.who.int/genomics/

gender/en/index6.html datum van gebruik 20 Junie 2016

WGO datum onbekend http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/

topics/infertility/definitions/en/

Wêreld Gesondheidsorganisasie datum onbekend Sexual and Reproductive Health: Infertility Definitions and Terminology http://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/topics/infertility/definitions/en/ datum van gebruik 23 Junie 2016




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2017/v20i0a1373

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2017 Anri Botes, Laetitia Fourie

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.