The Reinstatement and Compensation Conundrum in South African Labour Law

  • Judith Geldenhuys UNISA
Keywords: Section 193 of the Labour Relations Act, section 194 of the Labour Relations Act, compensation, reinstatement, re-employment, unfair dismissal, waiver of reinstatement, non-patrimonial loss, back-pay

Abstract

The SBV Services (Pty) Ltd case brought a novel concept into the labour dispute resolution arena: arbitrators must inform employees who succeed in proving that they were dismissed for an unfair reason of the implications of a reinstatement or compensation order in terms of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 before making an award. This case discussion highlights how the court, under the pennant of the interests of justice, made injudicious errors in the interpretation and application of accepted legal principles, and the potential negative effects that enforcement of this principle could have.

 

Google_Scholar_12019.png    ScienceOpen_Log034313.png

Author Biography

Judith Geldenhuys, UNISA
LLB, LLM (UP), LLD (UNISA). Senior Lecturer in the Department of Mercantile Law, UNISA, South Africa.

References

Bibliography

Literature

Benjamin and Gruen Regulatory Efficiency of the CCMA
Benjamin P and Gruen G The Regulatory Efficiency of the CCMA: A
Statistical Analysis of the CCMA's CMS Database(University of Cape
Town Cape Town 2006)

Christie Law of Contract
Christie RH The Lawof Contract in South Africa 5th ed (LexisNexis
Butterworths Durban 2006)

Cohen 2003 ILJ
Cohen T "Exercising a Judicial Discretion –Awarding Compensation for
Unfair Dismissals" 2003 ILJ739

Dimatteo 1997 SC L Rev
Dimatteo LA "The Counterpoise of Contracts: The Reasonable Person
Standard and the Subjectivity of Judgment" 1997 SC L Rev293-355

Friedman et alTokiso Dispute Settlement
Friedman S et alTokiso Dispute Settlement 2010 Review 2009-2010 (Juta
Cape Town 2010)

Grogan Dismissal
Grogan J Dismissal 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2014)

Grogan 2015 EL
GroganJ "ReinstatementMeansJustThat: Resuming Employment after
Unfair Dismissal" 2015 Feb EL 11

Lewis, Sargeant and Schwab Employment Law
Lewis D, Sargeant M and Schwab B Employment Law: The Essentials 11th
ed (Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development London 2010)

Mischke 2005 CLL
Mischke "Calculating Compensation for Unfair Dismissal: Quantifying Just
and Equitable Compensation" 2005 CLL 24

Van Heerden and Coetzee 2011 De Jure
Van Heerden C and Coetzee H "Minister for Justice and Constitutional
Development v Tshishonga 2009 9 BLLR 862 (LAC): Just and Equitable
Compensation for Non-patrimonial Loss" 2011 De Jure479-489

Vettori Employment Contract
Vettori S The Employment Contract and the Changed World of Work
(Ashgate Burlington 2007)

Vettori 2012 PELJ
Vettori S "The Role of Human Dignity in the Assessment of Fair
Compensation for Unfair Dismissal" 2012 PELJ 102-123

Vettori 2013 SA Merc LJ
Vettori S "Enforcement of Labour Arbitration Awards in South Africa" 2013
SA Merc LJ 245-254

Visser and Potgieter Law of Damages
Visser PJ and Potgieter JM Law of Damages 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town
2009)

Waglay 2003 ILJ
Waglay B "The Proposed Re-organisation of the Labour Court and the
Labour Appeal Court" 2003 ILJ 1-223

Case law

Adams v Coin Security Group (Pty) Ltd 1999 20 ILJ 1192 (LC)

Addis v Gramophone Co Ltd 1909 AC 488

Alert Employment Personnel (Pty) Ltd v Leech 1993 14 ILJ 655 (LAC)

Amalgamated Beverages Industries v Jonker (Pty) Ltd 1993 14 ILJ 1232
(LAC)

Apollo Tyres South Africa (Pty) Ltd v CCMA 2013 5 BLLR 434 (LAC)

Bezuidenhout v Johnston 2006 27 ILJ2337 (LC)

Billiton Aluminium SA Ltd t/a Hillside Aluminium v Khanyile 2010 5 BLLR
465 (CC)

Boyo v London Borough of Lambeth 1995 IRLR 50

Camdons Realty (Pty) Ltd v Hart 1993 14 ILJ 1008 (LAC)

Chemical Energy Paper Printing Wood & Allied Workers Union v Glass &
Aluminium 2000 CC2002 23 ILJ 695 (LAC)

Chemical Workers Industrial Union v Latex Surgical Products (Pty) Ltd
2006 27 ILJ 292 (LAC)

Chillibush Communications (Pty) Ltd v Gericke 2010 31 ILJ1350 (LC)

Chiloane v Rema Tip Top Industries (Pty) Ltd 2002 11 BLLR 1066 (LC)

Chotia v Hall Longmore & Co (Pty) Ltd 1997 6 BLLR 739 (LC)

Consolidated Frame Cotton Corporation Ltd v President of the Industrial
Court; Consolidated Woolwashing and Processing Mills Ltd v President of
the Industrial Court 1986 3 SA 786 (A)

De la Guerre v Ronald Bobroff and Partners Incorporated ‘[2013] ZAGPPH
33 (13 February 2013) Dietman v London Borough of Brent1987 IRLR
167

Dladla and On-Time Labour Hire CC 2006 27 ILJ216 (BCA)

Dr DC Kemp t/a Centralmed v Rawlins 2009 11 BLLR 1027 (LAC)

Edelweiss Glass and Aluminium (Pty) Ltd v NUMSA 2011 32 ILJ 2939
(LAC)

Equity Aviation Services (Pty) Ltd v CCMA 2008 29 ILJ 2507 (CC)

Ex parte Parfitt 1954 3 SA 894 (O)

Ferodo (Pty) Ltd v De Ruiter 1993 14 ILJ974 (LAC)

First National Bank -A Division of First Bank Ltd v Language 2013 34 ILJ
3103 (LAC)

Foodpiper CC t/a Kentucky Fried Chicken v Shezi 1993 14 ILJ 126 (LAC)

Foster v Stewart Scott Inc 1997 18 ILJ 367 (LAC)

Fouldien v House of Trucks (Pty) Ltd2002 23 ILJ2259 (LC)

Gubevu Security Group Pty Ltd and Ruggiero 2012 33 ILJ 1171 (LC)

Independent Municipal & Allied Trade Union obo Erasmus v City of
Johannesburg 2013 34 ILJ1741 (LC)

Jabari v Telkom SA (Pty) Ltd 2006 27 ILJ 1854 (LC)

Jayiya v MEC for Welfare, Eastern Cape 2004 2 SA 611 (SCA)

Johnson & Johnson (Pty) Ltd v CWIU 1999 20 ILJ 89 (LAC)

Kemp t/a Centralmed v Rawlins2009 30 ILJ2677 (LAC)

Khumalo v Supercare Cleaning 2000 8 BALR 892 (CCMA)

Kroukam v SA Airlink (Pty) Ltd2005 26 ILJ 2153 (LAC)

Kylie v CCMA 2010 31 ILJ1600 (LAC)

Lakomski v TTS Tool Technic Systems (Pty) Ltd 2007 28 ILJ 2775 (LC)

Masawi v Chabata1991 4 SA 764 (ZH)

Media 24 Ltd v Grobler 2005 26 ILJ 1007 (SCA)

Mediterranean Textile Mills v SA Textile WorkersUnion 1998 6 BLLR 549
(A)

Mediterranean Textile Mills (Pty) Ltd v SA Clothing &Textile Workers
Union 2012 33 ILJ 160 (LAC)

Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development v Tshishonga 2009 30
ILJ 1799 (LAC)

Myers v Abrahamson 1952 3 SA 121 (C)

Myers v National Commissioner of the SA Police Service 2013 JOL 30564
(SCA)

Mzeku v Brand 2001 8 BLLR 857 (LAC)

Mzeku Volkswagen SA (Pty) Ltd 2001 22 ILJ 1575 (LAC)

NAAWU (now NUMSA) v Borg-Warner SA (Pty) Ltd 1994 15 ILJ 509 (A)

Nathan v the Reclamation Group (Pty) Ltd2002 23 ILJ 588 (CCMA)

National Industrial Workers Union v Chester Wholesale Meats KZN (Pty)
Ltd2004 25 ILJ 1293 (LC)

National Union of Metalworkers of Southern Africa v Precious Metal
Chains (Pty) Ltd 1997 8 BLLR 1068 (LC)

NEHAWU v University of Cape Town2003 3 SA 1 (CC)

Nel v Oudtshoorn Municipality 2013 34ILJ1737 (SCA)

Netherburn Engineering CC t/a Netherburn Ceramics v Mudau 2003 23
ILJ 1712 (LC)

Netherburn Engineering CC t/a Netherburn Ceramics v Mudau 2010 2 SA
269 (CC)

Nieuwenhuis v Group Five Roads 2000 21 ILJ 2074 (LC)

Nieuwoudt v All-Pak 2009 30 ILJ 2444 (LC)

Nkopane v IEC 2007 28 ILJ 670 (LC)

NUM v East Rand Gold & Uranium Co Ltd 1991 12 ILJ 1221 (A)

NUMSA v Edelweiss Glass and Aluminium (Pty) Ltd 2009 11 BLLR 1083
(LC)

Pedzinski v Andisa Security (Pty) Ltd 2006 2 BLLR 184 (LC)

PG Group (Pty) Ltd v Mbambo 2005 1 BLLR 71 (LC)

Pretoria Society for the Care of the Retarded v Loots 1997 18 ILJ981
(LAC)

Republican Press (Pty) Ltd v CEPPWAWU 2007 28 ILJ 2503 (SCA)

S v De Blom 1977 3 SA 513 (A)

SA Chemical Workers Union v Afrox Ltd 1999 20 ILJ 1718 (LAC)

SA Maritime Safety Authority v McKenzie 2010 31 ILJ 529 (SCA)

SACCAWU obo Makubalo v Pro-Cut Fruit & Veg 2002 5 BALR 543
(CCMA)

SBV Services (Pty) Ltd v CCMA 2013 34 ILJ 996 (LC)

Sejake v Naledi Municipality2014 35 ILJ 500 (LC)

Shoprite Checkers (Pty) Ltd v CCMA 2008 12 BLLR 1211 (LAC)

Shoprite Checkers (Pty) Ltd v CCMA 2009 7 BLLR 619 (SCA)

Sidumo v Rustenburg Platinum Mines Ltd 2007 28 ILJ 2405 (CC)

Solidarity obo McCabe v SA Institute for Medical Research 2003 9 BLLR
927 (LC)

Stevenson v Sterns Jewellers (Pty) Ltd 1986 7 ILJ 318 (IC)

Themba v Mintroad Sawmills 2015 2 BLLR 174 (LC)

Tshishonga v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development 2007 4
BLLR 327 (LC)

Tshongweni v Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Municipality 2012 33 ILJ 2847
(LAC)

Van Rensburg v Austen Safe Co 1998 19 ILJ 158 (LC)

Viljoen v Nketoana Local Municipality 2003 24 ILJ 437 (LC)

Vorster v Rednave Enterprises CC t/a Cash Converters Queenswood
2009 30 ILJ 407 (LC)

Woolworths (Pty) Ltd v Whitehead 2000 21 ILJ 571 (LAC)

Legislation

Basic Conditions of Employment Act 75 of 1997

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Contingency Fees Act66 of 1997

Employment Rights Act, 1996 (United Kingdom)

Estatuto de Los Trabajadores of 1996 (Spain)

Labour Relations Act 28 of 1956

Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995

Labour Relations Amendment Act 6 of 2014

Labour Standards Act 5309 of 1997 (Korea)

Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000

Protection against Dismissal Act, 1969 (Germany)

Works Constitution Act, 2001 (Germany)

Government publications

Explanatory Memorandum for the Labour Relations Amendment Bill
(1995) 16 ILJ 278

Labour Court Rules

Rules of Conduct of Proceedings before the CCMA

Uniform Rules of Court: Rules Regulating the Conduct of the Proceedings
of the Several Provincial and Local Divisions of the High Court of South
Africa (High Court Rules)

Uniform Rules of the High Court

Internet sources

Benjamin and SBP 2010 http://www.labour.gov.za/DOL/
downloads/documents/useful-documents/labour-relations/RIA13
Sept2010.pdf
Benjamin P and SBP 2010 "Option Analysis: Protection of Atypical
Employees. Assessment of Selected Provisions of the Labour Relations
Amendment Bill 2010 and the Basic Conditions of Employment
Amendment Bill 2010" in Benjamin P et al Regulatory Impact Assessment
of Selected Provisions of the: Labour Relations Amendment Bill, 2010;
Basic Conditions of Employment Amendment Bill, 2010; Employment
Equity Amendment Bill, 2010 Employment Services Bill, 2010 12-49
http://www.labour.gov.za/DOL/downloads/documents/
useful-documents/labour-relations/RIA13Sept2010.pdf accessed 24
November 2014

Bhorat and Cheadle 2010 http://www.dpru.uct.ac.za/sites/defaults/
files.site/default/files/DPRU%20PB%2010-27.pdf
Bhorat H and Cheadle H 2010 Labour Reform in South Africa: Measuring
Regulation and a Synthesis of Policy Suggestions
http://www.dpru.uct.ac.za/sites/defaults/files.site/default/files/DPRU%20PB
%2010-27.pdf accessed 24 November 2014

Department of Labour 2012 https://www.labour.gov.za/downloads/
legislation/bills/proposed-amendment-bills/memoofobjectslra.pdf
Department of Labour 2012 Memorandum of the Objects of the Labour
Relations Amendment Bill, 2012 https://www.labour.gov.za/downloads/
legislation/bills/proposed-amendment-bills/memoofobjectslra.pdf accessed
24 November 2014

Van Niekerk 2007 http://www.dpru.uct.ac.za/sites/default/files/
image_tool/images/36/DPRU%20WP07-119.pdf
Van Niekerk A 2007 Regulated Flexibility and Small Business: Revisiting
the LRA and BCEA -A Response to Halton Cheadle's Concept Paper
http://www.dpru.uct.ac.za/sites/default/files/image_tool/images/36/DPRU%
20WP07-119.pdf accessed 24 November 2014
Views
  • Abstract 576
  • PDF 81
  • XML 7
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2017-05-17
Section
Articles