Regulating Traditional Justice in South Africa: A Comparative Analysis of Selected Aspects of the Traditional Courts Bill

  • Caiphas Brewsters Soyapi North West University
Keywords: Traditional Courts Bill, traditional justice systems, customary law, ascertainment, legal representation, hierarchy of courts, gender

Abstract

Traditional justice systems have been in place for a very long time in South Africa and in Africa in general. They are characterised by informal systems that are not beset by the normal technicalities prevalent in formal justice systems. In recent times South Africa has sought to do away with the Black Administration Act, which was the regulating legislation on traditional justice systems, by introducing the Traditional Courts Bill. Initially introduced in Parliament in 2008 and withdrawn for another tabling in 2012, the Bill has been met with much criticism. Instead of venturing on a clause by clause analysis of the provisions of the Bill this note considers selected aspects of it which are perceived to be significant and which have courted controversy. These are ascertainment, legal representation, jurisdiction, gender, and the hierarchy of courts. The essential arguments are that the Bill has not been properly aligned with the Traditional Leadership and Governance Framework Act 41 of 2003 (as amended in 2009) or the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 and that the above issues have not been addressed adequately or are at times only vaguely addressed.

The note also considers various provisions from other African countries with similar legislation and which also regulate on the same issues, for the purposes of identifying better ways of addressing the selected issues. In the final analysis, the recommendations are not that the South African legislature must transpose the provisions of other countries, but that the framers of the Bill must reconsider these issues along the lines in which they are addressed in the countries with which comparisons are drawn here. Without a reconsideration of the issues, the Bill will still be met with criticism even from those it is meant to regulate, and could potentially result in various constitutional challenges and litigations.

  ScienceOpen_Log0343241.png

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Literature

AHSI Criminal Justice System in Zambia

African Human Security Initiative The Criminal Justice System in Zambia: Enhancing the Delivery of Security in Africa (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2009)

Bennett "Conflict of Laws"

Bennett TW "The Conflict of Laws" in Bekker JC, Rautenbach C and Goolam NI (eds) Introduction to Legal Pluralism in South Africa 2nd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006)

Bennett Human Rights and African Customary Law

Bennett TW Human Rights and African Customary Law (Juta Cape Town 1995)

Bennett Customary Law

Bennett TW Customary Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2004)

Blackwell Essential Law Dictionary

Blackwell HA The Essential Law Dictionary (Sphinx Naperville, Ill 2008)

Boko 2000 Criminal Law Forum

Boko BD "Fair Trial and the Customary Courts in Botswana: Questions on Legal Representation" 2000 Criminal Law Forum 445-460

Claassens 2009 Agenda

Claassens A "Who Told Them We Want This Bill? The Traditional Courts Bill and Rural Women" 2009 Agenda 9-22

Gasa 2011 SA Crime Quarterly

Gasa N "The Traditional Courts Bill: A Silent Coup?" 2011 SA Crime Quarterly 23-30

Harper Customary Justice

Harper E Customary Justice: From Program Design to Impact Evaluation (IDLO Rome 2011)

Himonga "Future of Living Customary Law"

Himonga C "The Future of Living Customary Law in African Legal Systems in the Twenty-first Century and Beyond, with Special Reference to South Africa" in Fenrich J, Galizzi P and Higgins TE (eds) The Future of African Customary Law (Cambridge University Press New York 2011)

Hinz "Traditional Courts in Namibia"

Hinz MO "Traditional Courts in Namibia – Part of the Judiciary? Jurisprudential Challenges of Traditional Justice" in Hinz MO (ed) In Search of Justice and Peace: Traditional and Informal Justice in Africa (Namibia Scientific Society Windhoek 2010) 23-29

Khumalo Civil Practice of All Courts

Khumalo JAM The Civil Practice of All Courts for Blacks in Southern Africa 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 1984)

Koyana "Traditional Courts in South Africa"

Koyana DS "Traditional Courts in South Africa in the Twenty-first Century" in Fenrich J, Galizzi P and Higgins TE (eds) The Future of African Customary Law (Cambridge University Press New York 2011) 227-246

Koyana, Bekker and Mqeke "Traditional Authority Courts"

Koyana DS, Bekker JC and Mqeke RB "Traditional Authority Courts" in Bekker JC, Rautenbach C and Goolam NI (eds) Introduction to Legal Pluralism in South Africa 2nd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2006) Chapter 10

Lehnert 2005 SAJHR

Lehnert W "The Roe of the Courts in the Conflict between African Customary Law and Human Rights" 2005 SAJHR 241-277

Matavire 2012 IJHSS

Matavire M "Interrogating the Zimbabwean Traditional Jurisprudence and the Position of Women in Conflict Resolution: A Case of the Shona Tribes in Muzarabani District" 2012 IJHSS 218-223

McQuoid-Mason 1999 Windsor YB Access Just

McQuoid-Mason D "Access to Justice in South Africa" 1999 Windsor YB Access Just 1-16

McQuoid-Mason 2013 Oñati Socio-legal Series

McQuoid-Mason D "Access to Justice in South Africa: Are there Enough Lawyers?" 2013 Oñati Socio-legal Series 561-579

Ntlama and Ndima 2009 International Journal of African Renaissance Studies

Ntlama N and Ndima D "The Significance of South Africa's Traditional Courts Bill to the Challenge of Promoting African Traditional Justice Systems" 2009 International Journal of African Renaissance Studies 6-30

Olivier et al Indigenous Law

Olivier NJJ et al Indigenous Law (Butterworths Durban 1995)

Oomen Chiefs in South Africa

Oomen B Chiefs in South Africa (UKZN Press and Palgrave New York 2005)

SALC Report on Traditional Courts

South African Law Commission Project 90: Report on Traditional Courts and the Judicial Function of Traditional Leaders (SALC Pretoria 2003)

Tshehla Traditional Justice in Practice

Tshehla B Traditional Justice in Practice: A Limpopo Case Study (Institute for Security Studies Pretoria 2005)

Weeks 2011a SA Crime Quarterly

Weeks SM "The Traditional Courts Bill: Controversy around Process, Substance and Implications" 2011 SA Crime Quarterly 3-10

Weeks 2011b SA Crime Quarterly

Weeks SM "The Traditional Courts Bill: Regulating Customary Courts in Line with Living Customary Law and the Constitution" 2011 SA Crime Quarterly 31-40

Williams and Klusener 2013 SAJHR

Williams J and Klusener J "The Traditional Courts Bill: A Women's Perspective" 2013 SAJHR 276-293

Case law

Bangindawo v Head of the Nyanda Regional Authority 1998 3 SA 262 (Tk)

Bhe v Khayelitsha Magistrate 2005 1 BCLR 1 (CC)

Ex Parte Chairperson of the Constitutional Assembly: In Re Certification of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 1996 4 SA 744 (CC)

Mhlekwa v Head of the Western Tembuland Regional Authority: Feni v Head of the Western Tembuland Regional Authority 2001 1 SA 574 (Tk)

Shilubana v Nwamitwa 2009 2 SA 66 (CC)

Legislation

Botswana

Customary Courts Act Proc 19 of 1961 (Chapter 04:05)

Customary Law Act 51 of 1969 (Chapter 16:01)

Namibia

Community Courts Act 10 of 2003

South Africa

Black Administration Act 38 of 1927

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Traditional Leadership and Governance Framework Act 41 of 2003

Traditional Leadership and Governance Framework Amendment Act 23 of 2009

Zimbabwe

Customary Law and Local Courts Act 2 of 1990

Government publications

Traditional Courts Bill [B1-2012]

Internet sources

Access to Justice Blog 2012 http://ma2j.wordpress.com/2012/03/26/traditional-courts-bill-sparks-controversies-in-south-africa/

Access to Justice Blog 2012 Traditional Courts Bill Sparks Controversies in South Africa http://ma2j.wordpress.com/2012/03/26/traditional-courts-bill-sparks-controversies-in-south-africa/ accessed 2 May 2014

DJCD 2009 http://www.lrg.uct.ac.za/usr/lrg/docs/TCB/2012/DOJ_report_2009.pdf

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development 2009 Report to the Portfolio Committee on Justice and Constitutional Development Re: The Traditional Courts Bill, 2008 http://www.lrg.uct.ac.za/usr/lrg/docs/TCB/2012/

DOJ_report_2009.pdf accessed 9 August 2014

LRC 2008 http://www.lrc.org.za/images/pdf_downloads/Law_Policy_Reform/200005

pcsubmission080514lrc.pdf

Legal Resource Centre 2008 Submissions to the Portfolio Committee on Justice and Constitutional Development http://www.lrc.org.za/images/

pdf_downloads/Law_Policy_Reform/200005pcsubmission080514lrc.pdf accessed 9 August 2014

Makinana 2013 http://mg.co.za/article/2013-10-17-traditional-courts-fracas-goes-on

Makinana A 2013 Traditional Courts Fracas Goes On http://mg.co.za/article/2013-10-17-traditional-courts-fracas-goes-on accessed 12 May 2014

Mkhwanazi 2013 http://www.thenewage.co.za/mobi/Detail.aspx?NewsID=90037&

CatID=1007

Mkhwanazi S 2013 Traditional Courts Bill to Via Provinces http://www.thenewage.co.za/mobi/Detail.aspx?NewsID=90037&CatID=1007 accessed 29 April 2014

Mtyala 2014 http://www.timeslive.co.za/thetimes/2014/02/28/anger-as-traditional-courts-bill-jettisoned

Mtyala Q 2014 Anger as Traditional Courts Bill Jettisoned http://www.timeslive.co.za/thetimes/2014/02/28/anger-as-traditional-courts-bill-jettisoned acessed 1 May 2014

Published
2017-04-11
How to Cite
Soyapi, C. B. (2017). Regulating Traditional Justice in South Africa: A Comparative Analysis of Selected Aspects of the Traditional Courts Bill. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 17(4), 1440-1469. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2014/v17i4a2170
Section
Articles