"Violence" In Sport and the Violenti non Fit Iniuria Defence: A Perspective on the Death of the Cricket Player Phil Hughes

Keywords: Defence of violenti non fit inuiria, contra bones mores, wrongfulness, sport, cricket

Abstract

The article evaluates the defence of violenti non fit inuiria in sport with specific reference to the principle of bones mores or the good morals in society to tolerate injuries in sport. The increase occurrences of serious injuries in sport in the professional era, where sportsmen earn their livelihood from sport, necessitate a revisit of the existing situation. The death of the Australian cricket player, Phil Hughes, as a result of fast short-pitched bowling in cricket, has again put the spotlight on aggressive and excessive use of "violence" in sport. The malicious intent in sport, to harm and even kill an opponent, has warranted and necessitated the question as to whether there should be any difference in the manner in which the perpetrator of violence in sport should be treated compared to ordinary criminal law assault and murder offenders. In the article a two-pronged approach is suggested as a possible solution to deal with wrongfulness in cricket.

 

Google_Scholar44.png  ScienceOpen_Log03431042.png

References

Bibliography

Literature

Anon 1976 Mich L Rev
Anon "Consent in Criminal Law: Violence in Sports"1976 Mich L Rev 148-
179

Anon Beeld
Anon "Bollinger wou Hughes Glo Doodboul"Beeld(15 March 2016) 15

Chic, Loy and Miracle 1997 CCR
Chic G, Loy JW and Miracle AW "Combative Sport and Warfare: A
Reappraisal of the Spill-over and Catharsis Effect"1997 CCR 10-21

Coakley Sport in Society
Coakley J Sport in Society: Issues and Controversies. (McGraw Hill New
York 2007)

Cornelius 2015
LitNet Akademies
Cornelius S "Wat die Drome nie Genees nie: Kan Toestemming tot
Benadeling steeds Aanspreeklikheid weens Sportbesering Uitsluit?"2015
LitNet Akademies 756-788

Cornelius 2016 GSLTR
Cornelius S "The Expendibles: Do Sport People Really Assume the Risk of
Sport?"2016 (7)1 GSLTR 6-11

David, Wolman and Fyfe 1989BMJ
David HG, Wolman R and Fyfe I "Cricketing Casualties and Sporting
Siblings"23-30 December 1989BMJ1574-1674

Donald White Lightening
Donald A White Lightening: Allan Donald -The Autobiography t(Human and
Rousseau Cape Town 1999)

Houlihan Sport, Policy and Politics
Houlihan HR Sport, Policy and Politics: A Comparative Analysis (Routledge
London 1997)

Kemp and Walker Criminal Law
Kemp G and Walker S (eds) Criminal Law in South Africa (Oxford University
Press Cape Town 2012)

Snyman Strafreg
Snyman CR Strafreg 4th ed (Butterworths Durban 1999)

Strauss 1964 SALJ
Strauss SA "Bodily Injury and the Defence of Consent"1964 SALJ332-345

Case law

Agar v Hyde 201 CLR 552

Boshoff v Boshoff 1987 2 SA 694 (O)

People v Samuels 250 Cal App 2d 501 (D Ct App 1967)

Roux v Hatting 2012 6 SA 428 (SCA)

State v Forbes No 63280 (Minn Dist Ct 1975)

Telematrix (Pty) Ltd t/a Matrix Vehicle Tracking v Advertising Standards
Authority SA 2006 1 SA 461 (SCA)

Internet sources

Anon 2016 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-11-04/conflicting-statements-
heard-during-phillip-hughes-inquest/7995410
Anon 2016 Phillip Hughes: Sledging, Bowling were Focus of Much of
Inquest into Cricketer's Death http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-11-
04/conflicting-statements-heard-during-phillip-hughes-inquest/7995410
accessed 15 April 2017

MCC 2017 https://www.lords.org/mcc/laws-of-cricket
Marylebone Cricket Club 2017 Laws of Crickethttps://www.lords.org/
mcc/laws-of-cricket accessed 3 April 2017

Sports Injury Doctor 2011 http://www.sportinjurybulletin.com/archive/
cricket-1
The Sports Injury Doctor 2011 Epidemiology of Injuries
http://www.sportinjurybulletin.com/archive/cricket-1 accessed 15 April 2017

Telegraph Sport 2016http://www.telegraph.co.uk/cricket/2016/10/14/an
gered-family-of-phil-hughes-walk-out-on-final-day-of-inquest-i/
Telegraph Sport 2016Angered Family of Phil Hughes Walk Out on Final
Day of Inquest into Cricketer's Death http://www.telegraph.co.uk/cricket/
2016/10/14/angered-family-o-phil-hughes-walk-out-on-final-dayof-
inquest-i/ accessed 15 April 2017
Views
  • Abstract 105
  • pdf 78
  • XML 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2018-03-27
Section
Notes