The New Developments in International Investment Law: A need for Multilateral Investment Treaty?

  • Malebakeng A Forere WITS
Keywords: national laws, bilateral investment treaties, multilateral investment treaty, standards of protection

Abstract

This work contributes to the global discussion on the desirability of the multilateral investment treaty to ensure coherence in the way foreign investment is protected across the globe. The paper argues that whereas the international community is not ready yet to adopt multilateral rules on investment liberalisation, the time is ripe for multilateral rules on the standards of protection backed up by a multilateral court with a two-tier system. Most importantly, this contribution provides a template for the content of the standards of protection, having observed the new approaches to the traditional standards of protection typically enshrined in the bilateral investment treaties.

 

Google_Scholar38.png 

References

Bibliography

Literature

Alvarez Public International Law Regime
Alvarez JE The Public International Law Regime Governing International Investment (Hague Academy of International Law The Hague 2011)

Alvarez and Khamsi "Argentine Crisis and Foreign Investors"
Alvarez J and Khamsi K "The Argentine Crisis and Foreign Investors: A Glimpse into the Heart of the Investment Regime" in Sauvant KP (ed) The Yearbook of International Law and Polity 2008/2009 (Oxford University Press New York 2009) 379-478

Auslund 2013 Policy Brief
Auslund A "The World Needs a Multilateral Investment Treaty" 2013 Policy Brief 1-8

Avi-Yonah 2013 Colum J Transnat'l L
Avi-Yonah R "National Regulation of Multinational Enterprises: An Essay on Comity, Extraterritoriality and Harmonization" 2003 Colum J Transnat'l L 5-34

Berger "Multilateral Investment Agreement"
Berger A "A Multilateral Investment Agreement: A Road to Nowhere?" in Chen S (ed) G20 Hangzhou Summit 2016: Proposals for Trade, Investment, and Sustainable Development Outcomes (International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development Geneva 2016) 63-72

Borchard 1927 AJIL
Borchard EM "Limitations on Coercive Protection" 1927 AJIL 303-306

Chalamish 2009 Brook J Int'l L
Chalamish F "The Future of Bilateral Investment Treaties: A De Facto Multilateral Agreement?" 2009 Brook J Int'l L 303-354

Congyan 2008 Chinese JIL
Congyan C "International Investment Treaties and the Formation, Application and Transformation of Customary International Law Rules" 2008 Chinese JIL 659-679

Dattu 2000 Fordham Int'l LJ
Dattu R "A Journey from Havana to Paris: The Fifty-Year Quest for the Elusive Multilateral Agreement on Investment" 2000 Fordham Int'l LJ 275-316

Dolzer and Schreuer Principles of International Investment Law
Dolzer R and Schreuer C Principles of International Investment Law 2nd ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 2008)

Egli 2007 Pepp L Rev
Egli G "Don't Get Bit: Addressing ICSID's Inconsistent Application of Most-Favored-Nation Clauses to Dispute Resolution Provisions" 2007 Pepp L Rev 1045-1084

Elkins, Guzman and Simmons 2006 Int'l Org
Elkins Z, Guzman AT and Simmons BA "Competing for Capital: The Diffusion of Bilateral Investment Treaties, 1960-2000" 2006 Int'l Org 811-846

Fauchald 2008 EJIL
Fauchald KO "The Legal Reasoning of ICSID Tribunals – An Empirical Analysis" 2008 EJIL 301-364

Franck 2005 Fordham L Rev
Franck SD "The Legitimacy Crisis in Investment Treaty Arbitration: Privatizing Public International Law through Inconsistent Decisions" 2005 Fordham L Rev 1521-1626

Grisel "Sources of Foreign Investment Law"
Grisel F "The Sources of Foreign Investment Law" in Douglas Z, Pauwelyn J and Vinuales JE The Foundations of International Investment Law: Bringing Theory into Practice (Oxford University Press Oxford 2014) 213-234

Hackworth Digest of International Law
Hackworth G Digest of International Law (US Government Printing Office Washington 1942)

Higgins 1983 Recueil des Courts
Higgins R "The Taking of Property by the State: Recent Developments in International Law" 1983 Recueil des Cours 259-391

Jackson World Trade
Jackson J World Trade and the Law of the GATT (Bobbs-Merrill Indianapolis 1969)

Kelly 2000 Colum J Transnat'l L
Kelly G "Multilateral Investment Treaties: A Balanced Approach to Multinational Corporations" 2000 Colum J Transnat'l L 484-532

Kurtz 2014 U Pa J Int'l L
Kurtz J "A General Investment Agreement in the WTO? Lessons from Chapter 11 of NAFTA and the OECD Multilateral Agreement on Investment" 2014 U Pa J Int'l L 713-790

Kwaw 1991 NC J Int'l L & Com Reg
Kwaw E "Trade Related Investment Measures in the Uruguay Round: Towards a GATT for Investment?" 1991 NC J Int'l L & Com Reg 309-350

Lin "China's G20 Agenda"
Lin JY "China's G20 Agenda: Call for a Multilateral Investment Framework for Development" in Cheng S (ed) G20 Hangzhou Summit 2016: Proposals for Trade, Investment, and Sustainable Development Outcomes (International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development Geneva 2016) 55-62

Moran Impact of Trade-Related Investment Measures
Moran T The Impact of Trade-Related Investment Measures on Trade and Investment: Theory, Evidence and Policy Implications (United Nations New York 1991)

Moran Foreign Direct Investment and Development
Moran T Foreign Direct Investment and Development: The New Policy Agenda for Developing Countries and Economies in Transition (Institute for International Economics Washington 1998)

Muchlinski "Rise and Fall of the Multilateral Agreement on Investment"
Muchlinski PT "The Rise and Fall of the Multilateral Agreement on Investment: Lessons for the Regulation of International Business" in Fletcher I, Mistelis L and Cremona M (eds) Foundations and Perspectives of International Trade Law (Sweet and Maxwell London 2001) 114-134

Newcombe 2007 JWIT
Newcombe A "Sustainable Development and Investment Treaty Law" 2007 JWIT 357-407

Nicholson 1965 BC L Rev
Nicholson FJ "The Protection of Foreign Property under Customary International Law" 1965 BC L Rev 391-416

Pauwelyn "Rational Design or Accidental Evolution?"
Pauwelyn J "Rational Design or Accidental Evolution? The Emergence of International Investment Law" in Douglas Z, Pauwelyn J and Vinuales JE (eds) The Foundations of International Investment Law: Bringing Theory into Practice (Oxford University Press Oxford 2014) 11-44

Polanco 2015 ICSID Review
Polanco RL "The no of Tokyo Revisited: Or how Developed Countries Learned to Start Worrying and Love the Calvo Doctrine" 2015 ICSID Review 172-193

Radi 2007 EJIL
Radi Y "The Application of the Most Favoured Nation Clause to the Dispute Settlement Provisions of Bilateral Investment Treaties: Domesticating the Trojan Horse" 2007 EJIL 757-774

Salacuse 1984 J Air L & Com
Salacuse J "Towards a New Treaty Framework for Direct Foreign Investment" 1984 J Air L & Com 969-1010

Salacuse and Sullivan 2005
Salacuse JW and Sullivan NP "Do BITs Really Work? An Evaluation of Bilateral Investment Treaties and their Grand Bargain" 2005 Harv Int'l LJ 67-130

Sauvant 2016 China & World Economy
Sauvant KP "China, the G20 and the International Investment Regime" 2016 China & World Economy 72-92

Schreuer 2010 JIDS
Schreuer C "Full Protection and Security" 2010 JIDS 1-17

Shaffer Defending Interests
Shaffer G Defending Interests: Public-Private Partnerships in WTO Litigation (Brookings Institution Press Washington 2003)

Shan Toward a Multilateral or Plurilateral Framework
Shan W Toward a Multilateral or Plurilateral Framework on Investment. E15 Initiative (International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development Geneva 2015)

Shenkin 1994 U Pitt L Rev
Shenkin T "Trade-Related Measures in Bilateral Investment Treaties and the GATT: Moving Toward a Multilateral Investment Treaty" 1994 U Pitt L Rev 541-606

Shu-Acquaye 2013 Fla A&M U L Rev
Shu-Acquaye F "The Protection of Foreign Direct Investments in Developing and Emerging Markets through the Instrumentality of Arbitration: Fair Game" 2013 Fla A&M U L Rev 47-82

Taffet and Walcher United States and Latin America
Taffet JF and Walcher D The United States and Latin America: A History with Documents (Routledge London 2017)

Tudor Fair and Equitable Treatment Standard
Tudor I The Fair and Equitable Treatment Standard in International Law of Foreign Investment (Oxford University Press Oxford 2008)

UNCTAD World Investment Report
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development World Investment Report: Investment, Trade and International Policy Arrangements (United Nations New York 1996)

UNCTAD Bilateral Investments Treaties
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development Bilateral Investments Treaties in the Mid 1990s (United Nations New York 1998)
UNCTAD Revitalising Development Growth and International Trade
United Nations Conference for Trade and Development Revitalising Development Growth and International Trade: Assessment and Policy Options (United Nations Conference for Trade and Development Geneva 2007)

Walker 1956 Am J Comp L
Walker H "Treaties for the Encouragement and Protection of Foreign Investment: Present United States Practice" 1956 Am J Comp L 229-247

Wenhua and Wang 2015 ICSID Review
Wenhua S and Wang L "The China-EU BIT and the Emerging Global BIT 2.0" 2015 ICSID Review 260-267

Case law
Azurix Corp v The Argentine Republic ICSID Case No ARB/01/12 (2006)
British Claims in the Spanish Zone of Morocco (Great Britain v Spain) Arbitration 2 UNRIAA 1924 641
Emilio Agustin Maffezini v Kingdom of Spain ICSID Case No ARB/02/08 (2004)
MTD Equity Sdn Bhd and MTD Chile SA v Republic of Chile ICSID Case No ARB/01/7 (2004)
Norwegian Shipowners' Claims (Norway v United States of America) (1921) 1 RIAA 307 ICGJ 393 (PCA 1922) 13th October 1922 Permanent Court of Arbitration [PCA] 316
Saluka Investments BV v The Czech Republic UNICITRAL Partial Award of 17 March 2006
Wena Hotels v Egypt ICSID Case No ARB/98/4 (2000)

Legislation
Protection of Investment Act 22 of 2015

International instruments
Agreement on Trade Related Investment Measures (1994) 1868 UNTS 186
Australia – China Free Trade Agreement (2015)
Brazil – Angola Cooperation and Facilitation Investment Agreement (2015)
Brazil – Mozambique Cooperation and Facilitation Investment Agreement (2015)
Canada – Cameroon BIT (2014)
Canada – Costa Rica BIT (1998)
Charter of Economic Rights and Duties of States GA Res 3281 (1974)
Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement India – Singapore (2005)
Draft International Code of Conduct on the Transfer of Technology UN Doc TD/Code TOT/25 (1980)
Declaration on the Establishment of a New International Economic Order GA Res A/RES/S-6/3201 (1974)
European Union – Canada Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (2017)
General Council Doha Work Programme WT/L/579 (2004)
Havana Charter for an International Trade Organization UN Doc E/CONF.2/ (1948)
India Model BIT (2016)
International Convention on the Settlement of Investment Disputes between States and Nationals of other States (1965) 4 ILM 532
Multilateral Agreement on Investment (Draft Consolidated Text) DAFFE/MAI(98)7/REV1 (1998)
Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigation between the United States of America and the Republic of China 63 Stat 1299 (1948)
North American Free Trade Area (1992) 32 ILM 289
Report of the Second Committee UN Doc A/9946 (1974) and GA Res 3281 29 UN Doc GAOR Supp (No 31) 50 UN Doc A/9631 (1974)
Republic of Korea – Australia Free Trade Agreement (2014)
Switzerland – Poland BIT (1989)
Treaty and Protocol between the United States of America and Japan (1953)
Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigation between the United States of America and the Republic of China 63 Stat 1299 (1948)
UNCITRAL Possible Reform of Investor-State Dispute Settlement
United Nations Commission on International Trade Law Working Group III Possible Reform of Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) A/CN.9/WG.III/WP.149 (2018)
UNCITRAL Possible Reform of Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS)
United Nations Commission on International Trade Law Working Group III Draft: Possible Reform of Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS) – Cost and Duration A/CN.9/WG.III/WP.153 (2018)
United Kingdom – Antiqua and Barbuda BIT (1987)
United States – Albania BIT (1995)
United States – Rwanda BIT (2008)
United States Model BIT (2012)
WTO Ministerial Declaration of the Fourth Session of Doha WT/MIN(01)/DEC/1 (2001)

Internet sources
Anonymous Date Unknown https://finances.worldbank.org/Shareholder-Equity/Top-8-countries-voting-power/udm3-vzz9/data
Anonymous Date Unknown Top 8 Countries Voting Power https://finances.worldbank.org/Shareholder-Equity/Top-8-countries-voting-power/udm3-vzz9/data accessed 9 October 2018

European Commission 2017 http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/docs/2017/
july/tradoc_155744.pdf
European Commission 2017 Fact Sheet http://trade.ec.europa.eu/doclib/
docs/2017/july/tradoc_155744.pdf accessed 9 October 2018

European Parliament 2015 http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news
/en/headlines/eu-affairs/20150706STO74853/plenary-highlights-greece-ttip-emissions-trading-reform
European Parliament 2015 Plenary Highlights: Greece, TTIP, Emissions Trading Reform http://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/headlines/eu-affairs/20150706STO74853/plenary-highlights-greece-ttip-emissions-trading-reform accessed 9 October 2018

ICSID Date Unknown http://investmentpolicyhub.unctad.org/
Download/TreatyFile/2841
International Convention on Settlement of Investment Disputes The Chilean Model Agreement on the Reciprocal Promotion and Protection of Investments http://investmentpolicyhub.unctad.org/Download/
TreatyFile/2841 accessed 9 October 2018

ICSID 2017 https://icsid.worldbank.org/en/Documents/resources/ICSID%
20Web%20Stats%202017-2%20%28English%29%20Final.pdf
International Convention on Settlement of Investment Disputes 2017 The ICSID Caseload – Statistics https://icsid.worldbank.org/en/
Documents/resources/ICSID%20Web%20Stats%202017-2%20%28English%29%20Final.pdf accessed 9 October 2018

Naidoo 2017 https://agoa.info/news/article/15112-south-africa-is-on-notice-opinion-piece.html
Naidoo P 2017 South Africa is on Notice – Opinion Piece https://agoa.info/news/article/15112-south-africa-is-on-notice-opinion-piece.html accessed 9 October 2018

Sauvant and Ortino 2013 http://ccsi.columbia.edu/files/2014/03/Improving-The-International-Investment-Law-and-Policy-Regime-Options-for-the-Future-Sept-2013.pdf
Sauvant PK and Ortino F 2013 Improving the International Investment Law and Policy Regime: Options for the Future http://ccsi.columbia.edu/files/2014/03/Improving-The-International-Investment-Law-and-Policy-Regime-Options-for-the-Future-Sept-2013.pdf accessed 9 October 2018

UNCTAD 2017 http://unctad.org/en/pages/newsdetails.aspx?Original
VersionID=1659
United Nations Conference on Trade and Development 2017 Global Foreign Direct Investment Slipped in 2017 http://unctad.org/en/
pages/newsdetails.aspx?OriginalVersionID=1659 accessed 9 October 2018

WTO 2003 https://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e/minist_e/
min03_e/draft_decl_e.htm
World Trade Organization 2003 Draft Cancún Ministerial Text https://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e/minist_e/min03_e/draft_decl_e.htm accessed 9 October 2018
Views
  • Abstract 102
  • pdf 119
  • xml 30
  • epub 6
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2018-12-13
Section
Articles