The Million Rand Question: Does a Civil Marriage Automatically Dissolve the Parties' Customary Marriage?

Keywords: Customary marriage, Recognition of Customary Marriages Act;, ante-nuptial contract, dual marriage, converted marriage

Abstract

In 2016 the Eastern Cape Local Division in Mthata heard a claim by Mrs Winnie Madikezela-Mandela that, amongst other things, her customary marriage to former President Nelson Mandela continued to exist until his death, despite the dissolution of their civil marriage. Not long thereafter, in 2017, former President Jacob Zuma's daughter made headlines by claiming half of her soon-to-be-ex-husband's multimillion-rand estate despite the couple’s having entered into a valid ante-nuptial contract. The claim was that her preceding customary marriage had not been accompanied by an ante-nuptial contract, and therefore the marriage was in community of property. These high-profile cases raise the fundamental legal question: what effect does a civil marriage between parties have on the parties' customary marriage to each other?

Historically the subsequent civil marriage terminated the customary marriage, as such marriages were not legally recognised in South Africa. The Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998 allows for such dual marriages without specifying the consequences thereof. Most commentators have interpreted the provisions to perpetuate the historical position; the civil marriage terminates the customary marriage. While this appears distasteful, the rationale is legal certainty and accords with the recommendations of the South African Law Commission. Furthermore, alternative customary dispute resolution mechanisms are still available to the parties, who are unlikely to suffer prejudice under the interpretation. In addition, given the social reality in which dual marriages are conducted and how they are perceived by parties, parties should be allowed to conclude an ante-nuptial contract after their customary marriage but before their civil marriage to regulate the proprietary consequences of their marriage.

 

Google_Scholar92.png 

References

Bibliography

Literature

Bakker and Heaton 2012 TSAR.
Bakker P and Heaton "The co-existence of customary and civil marriages under the Black Administration Act 38 of 1927 and the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998 - the Supreme Court of Appeal introduces polygyny into some civil marriages Netshituka v Netshituka 2011 5 SA 453 SCA" 2012 TSAR 586-593.

Barker 2011 International Journal of Law in Context.
Barker N "Ambigious symbolisms: Recognising customary marriages and same sex marriages in South Africa" 2011 International Journal of Law in Context 447-466.

Bekker Seymour's Customary Law in Southern Africa.
Bekker JC Seymour's Customary Law in Southern Africa (Juta Cape Town 1989).

Bennett Customary Law in South Africa.
Bennett TW Customary Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2004).

Bonthuys and Sibanda 2003 SALJ.
Bonthuys E and Sibanda S "Til death do us part: Thembisile v Thembisile" 2003 SALJ 784-796.

Budlender et al Women, Land and Customary Law.
Budlender D, et al Women, Land and Customary Law (Community Agency for Social Enquiry South Africa 2011).

Burman 1991 Acta Juridica.
Burman S "Illegitimacy and the African family in a changing South Africa" 1991 Acta Juridica 36-51.

Church 1978 CILSA.
Church J "The dichotomy of marriageby customary and by civil rites - a note on a recent Swaziland decision" 1978 CILSA 80-82.

De Koker 2001 JSAfrL.
De Koker JY "Proving the existence of African customary marriage" 2001 JSAfrL 257-275.

De Ville Constitutional and Statutory Interpretation.
De Ville J Constitutional and Statutory Interpretation (Interdoc Consultants Pty Ltd Western Cape 2000).

Dlamini 1989 JSAfrL.
Dlamini CRM "The new marriage legislation affecting Blacks in South Africa" 1989 JSAfrL 408-419.

Griffiths 1986 Journal of Legal Pluralism.
Griffiths J "What is Legal Pluralism?" 1986 (24) Journal of Legal Pluralism 1-55.

Himonga and Moore Reform of Customary Marriage, Divorce and Succession in South Africa.
Himonga C and Moore E Reform of Customary Marriage, Divorce and Succession in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2015).

Himonga 2010 Tul. Eur. & Civ. LF.
Himonga C "State and individual perspectives of a mixed legal system in Southern African contexts with special reference to personal law" 2010 (25) Tul. Eur. & Civ. LF 23-36.

Herbst and Du Plessis 2008 JCL.
Herbst M and Du Plessis W "Customary law c common law marriages: A hybrid approach in South Africa" 2008 JCL 105-118.

Himonga and Nhlapo African Customary Law in South Africa: Post-Apartheid and Living Law Perspectives.
Himonga C and Nhlapo T African Customary Law in South Africa: Post-Apartheid and Living Law Perspectives (Oxford University Press Cape Town 2014).

Kaganas and Murray 1991 Acta Juridica.
Kaganas F and Murray C "Law, women and the family: The question of polygyny in a new South Africa " 1991 Acta Juridica 116-134.

Letsika 2005 Botswana Law Journal.
Letsika Q "The place of Sesotho customary law marriage within the modern Lesotho legal system" 2005 Botswana Law Journal 73-100.

Maqutu 1983 CILSA
Maqutu WCM "Lesotho's African marriage is not a 'customary union'" 1983 CILSA 374-382.

Meyer and Rudolph 2016 Policy and Procedure Manual: Administration of Intestate Deceased Estates at Service Points
Meyer MM and Rudolph MBE Policy and Procedure Manual: Administration of Intestate Deceased Estates at Service Points (Pretoria Justice College 2016).

Moore 1973 Law & Society Review 719 at 720.
Moore SF "Law and Social Change: The Semi-Autonomous Social Field as an Appropriate Subject of Study" 1973 (17 (4)) Law & Society Review 719-746.

Nhlapo 1991 Acta Juridica.
Nhlapo T "The African family and women's rights: friends or foes?" 1991 Acta Juridica 135-146.

Prinsloo 1986 TSAR.
Prinsloo TW "Omskepping van 'n inheemsregtelike huwelik in 'n gemeenregtelike huwelik" 1986 TSAR 244-24.

Simons 1961 Acta Juridica.
Simons HJ "The status of customary unions" 1961 Acta Juridica 17-37.

Case law
Alexkor Ltd v Richtersveld Community 2004 (5) SA 460 (CC).

Chotabhai v Union Government (Minister of Justice) and Registrar of Asiatics 1911 AD 13.

Gumede v President of the Republic of South Africa (2009) 3 SA 152 (CC).

Kumalo V Kumalo 1954 NAC (S) 54.

Kumalo v Jonas 1982 AHK 111 (S).

Lourens et Uxor 1986 (2) SA 291 (C)

Mandela v Executors Estate Late Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela [2016] 2 All SA 833 (ECM).

MM v MN (2013) (4) SA 415 (CC).

Nkambula v Linda 1951 (1) SA 377 (A).

Natal Joint Municipal Pension Fund v Endumeni Municipality 2012 (4) SA 593 (SCA)

Ramuhovhi v President of the Republic of South Africa [2017] ZACC 41.

Legislation
Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998.

Black Administration Act 38 of 1927.

Muslim Marriages Bill B-20.
Marriage and Matrimonial Property Law Amendment Act 3 of 1988.
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996.

Internet sources
The Citizen 2017 Zuma’s daughter unhappy with divorce settlement, wants half of hubby’s estate available at https://citizen.co.za/lifestyle/1396615/zumas-daughter-unhappy-divorce-settlement-wants-half-hubbys-estate/ accessed 18 January 2018.

Ranald Vise 20 October 2011 Change of marriage II available at http://www.ghostdigest.com/articles/change-of-marriage-ii/53961 accessed 18 January 2018.

Oxford English Dictionary 2017 http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/30467?rskey=fAtQjf&result=1#eid accessed 18 January 2018.
Views
  • Abstract 157
  • pdf 264
  • xml 9
  • epub 6
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-05-20
Section
Articles