A Duty of Support for All South African Unmarried Intimate Partners Part 2

Developing Customary and Common Law and Circumventing the Volks Judgment

  • Elsje Bonthuys WITS
Keywords: Duty of support, customary law, contract, choice to marry

Abstract

Part I of this two-part article argued that post-constitutional developments of the right to support have excluded the largest and most vulnerable sector of South African women – African women in invalid customary marriages and in intimate partnerships which do not resemble monogamous Western nuclear households. Part II explores the avenues to develop customary and common law to extend rights to support to these women. It argues that the current position discriminates against poor, rural African women on multiple intersecting grounds, which creates a duty for courts to develop the current legal rules. Customary law affords scope for development in relation to women in invalid customary marriages. Common law rights to support can be extended either ex contractu or ex lege. Because contractual support rights are of limited use to poor women, the legacy of the majority judgments in Volks v Robinson 2005 5 BCLR 446 (CC) (Volks) must be confronted to strengthen the legal basis for an automatic duty of support to all women in unmarried intimate relationships. The argument in Volks that, women choose to forego legal rights by not getting married is criticised. The minority judgment in Laubscher v Duplan 2017 2 SA 264 (CC) does, however, create potential for overturning this reasoning.

References

Literature
Albertyn 2007 SAJHR
Albertyn C "Substantive Equality and Transformation in South Africa" 2007 SAJHR 253-276
Albertyn and Goldblatt 1998 SAJHR

Albertyn C and Goldblatt B "Facing the Challenge of Transformation: Difficulties in the Development of an Indigenous Jurisprudence of Equality" 1998 SAJHR 248-276

Bennett Customary Law
Bennett TW Customary Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2004)

Bonthuys 2008 Can J Women & L
Bonthuys E "Institutional Openness and Resistance to Feminist Arguments: The Example of the South African Constitutional Court" 2008 Can J Women & L 1-36

Bonthuys 2016 OSLS
Bonthuys E "A Patchwork of Marriages: The Legal Relevance of Marriage in a Plural Legal System" 2016 OSLS 1303-1323

Bonthuys 2017 SALJ
Bonthuys E "Proving Express and Tacit Universal Partnership Agreements in Unmarried Intimate Relationships" 2017 SALJ 263-273

Budlender et al Women, Land and Customary Law
Budlender D et al Women, Land and Customary Law (Community Agency for Social Enquiry Johannesburg 2011)

Dewar 2000 IJLPF
Dewar J "Family Law and its Discontents" 2000 IJLPF 59-85

Goldblatt 2000 SAJHR
Goldblatt B "Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accidents Fund (Commission for Gender Equality Intervening) 1999 (4) SA 1319 (SCA)" 2000 SAJHR 138-144

Goldblatt 2003 SALJ
Goldblatt B "Regulating Domestic Partnerships – A Necessary Step in the Development of South African Family Law" 2003 SALJ 610-629

Graveson 1941 MLR
Graveson RH "The Movement from Status to Contract" 1941 MLR 261-272

Heaton and Kruger South African Family Law
Heaton J and Kruger H South African Family Law 4th ed (Juta Cape Town 2015)

Himonga and Moore Reform of Customary Marriage
Himonga C and Moore E Reform of Customary Marriage, Divorce and Succession in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2015)

Hosegood 2013 Acta Juridica
Hosegood V "Women, Marriage and Domestic Arrangements in Rural KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa" 2013 Acta Juridica 143-168

Janse van Rensburg 2003 TSAR
Janse van Rensburg AM "(In)tolerance of Diversity: A Discussion on an Issue Never Decided" 2003 TSAR 585-590

Kruuse 2009 SAJHR
Kruuse H "'Here's to You, Mrs Robinson:' Peculiarities and Paragraph 29 in Determining the Treatment of Domestic Partnerships" 2009 SAJHR 380-391

Lind 2005 Acta Juridica
Lind C "Domestic Partnerships and Marital Status Discrimination" 2005 Acta Juridica 108-130

MacConnachie 2015 SAJHR
MacConnachie C "Transformative Unfair Discrimination Jurisprudence: The Need for a Baseline Intensity for Review" 2015 SAJHR 504-525

Mwambene and Kruuse 2013 Acta Juridica
Mwambene L and Kruuse H "Form over Function? The Practical Application of the Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 1998 in South Africa" 2013 Acta Juridica 292-317

Schäfer 2006 SALJ
Schäfer L "Marriage and Marriage-Like Relationships: Constructing a New Hierarchy of Life Partnerships" 2006 SALJ 626-647

Smith "Dissolution of a Life Partnership"
Smith B "The Dissolution of a Life or Domestic Partnership" in Heaton J (ed) The Law of Divorce and Dissolution of Life Partnerships in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2014) 389-474

Smith and Heaton 2012 THRHR
Smith B and Heaton J "Extension of the Dependant's Action to Heterosexual Life Partnerships after Volks v Robinson and the Coming into Operation of the Civil Union Act –Thus Far and No Further?" 2012 THRHR 472-484

Case law
AM v RM 2010 2 SA 223 (ECP)
Amod v Multilateral Motor Vehicle Accidents Fund 1999 4 SA 1319 (SCA)
Benefeld v West 2011 2 SA 379 (GSJ)
Brandt v Spies 1960 4 SA 14 (E)
Church of the Province of Southern Africa, Diocese of Cape Town v CCMA 2002 3 SA 385 (LCC)
Claassen v Van der Watt 1969 3 SA 68 (T)
Daniels v Campbell 2004 5 SA 331 (CC)
De Lange v Absa Makelaars 2010 3 All SA 403 (SCA)
Du Plessis v Road Accident Fund 2004 1 SA 359 (SCA)
Friedman v Harris 1928 CPD 43
Gory v Kolver 2007 4 SA 97 (CC)
Govender v Ragavayah 2009 3 SA 178 (D)
Gumede v President of the Republic of South Africa 2009 3 SA 152 (CC)
Harksen v Lane 1998 1 SA 300 (CC)
Hassam v Jacobs 2009 5 SA 572 (CC)
Hoosein v Dangor 2010 2 All SA 55 (WCC)
Ismail v Ismail 1983 1 SA 1006 (A)
Karp v Kuhn 1948 4 SA 825 (T)
Khan v Khan 2005 2 SA 272 (T)
Langemaat v Minister of Safety and Security 1998 3 SA 312 (T)
Laubscher v Duplan 2017 2 SA 264 (CC)
Lloyd v Mitchell 2004 2 All SA 542 (C)
McDonald v Young 2012 3 SA 1 (SCA)
Meyer v Road Accident Fund (TPD) (unreported) case number 29950/2004 of 28 March 2006
Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie (Doctors for Life International, Amici Curiae); Lesbian and Gay Equality Project v Minister of Home Affairs 2006 1 SA 524 (CC)
Paixão v Road Accident Fund 2011 ZAGPJHC 68 (1 July 2011)
Paixão v Road Accident Fund 2012 6 SA 377 (SCA)
Robinson v Volks 2004 6 SA 288 (C)
Rose v Rose 2015 2 All SA 352 (WCC)
Ryland v Edros 1997 2 SA 690 (C)
Satchwell v President of the Republic of South Africa 2002 6 SA 1 (CC)
Singh v Ramparsad 2007 3 SA 445 (D)
Standard Bank of SA v Ocean Commodities 1983 1 SA 276 (A)
Staples v Marquard 1919 CPD 181
Verheem v Road Accident Fund 2010 2 SA 409 (GP)
Volks v Robinson 2005 5 BCLR 446 (CC)
Wilkins v Voges 1994 3 SA 130 (A)

Legislation
Black Administration Act 38 of 1927
Black Laws Amendment Act 76 of 1963
Civil Union Act 17 of 2006
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 200 of 1993
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Divorce Act 70 of 1979
Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987
Maintenance of Surviving Spouses Act 27 of 1990
Marriage Act 25 of 1961
Matrimonial Affairs Act 37 of 1953
Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998

Government publications
Draft Domestic Partnerships Bill (Gen N 36 in GG 30663 14 January 2008)
Views
  • Abstract 0
  • pdf 0
  • XML 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2018-10-30
Section
Articles