The Constitutional Rules of Succession to the Institution of Monarch in Lesotho

Keywords: Lesotho, Constitution of Lesotho, succession, customary law, King

Abstract

The rules that govern succession to the office of King in Lesotho are largely customary. The Constitution of Lesotho, 1993 provides that succession to the office of King shall be regulated in terms of customary law; the Constitution itself does not provide for the substantive and procedural rules governing succession. The zenith of customary rules is that succession to kingship in Lesotho is based on the principle of primogeniture. The primogeniture rule has always presented problems of application in Lesotho; more so in the era of equality and democracy. This paper critiques the rules of succession to the office of King. It contends that by leaving the regulation of succession exclusively to customary law without clear articulation in the Constitution, the Constitution is unduly yielding to a system of law (customary law) which is not only subservient to the Constitution but also based on a different set of values. The paper recommends that the rules of succession must be codified in the Constitution and must be realigned with contemporary notions of constitutionalism and equality.

 

GS.png

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY
Literature
Albertyn 2009 CCR
Albertyn C "'The Stubborn Persistence of Patriarchy'? Gender Equality and Cultural Diversity in South Africa" 2009 CCR 165-208
Ashton The Basuto
Ashton H The Basuto (Oxford University Press London 1952)
Basutoland Council Report of the Administrative Reform Committee
Basutoland Council Basutoland Report of the Administrative Reform Committee (The Council Maseru 1954)
Basutoland Council Report of the Basutoland Constitutional Commission
Basutoland Council Report of the Basutoland Constitutional Commission (The Council Maseru 1963)
Breytenbach Crocodiles and Commoners in Lesotho
Breytenbach WJ Crocodiles and Commoners in Lesotho: Continuity and Change in the Rulemaking System of the Kingdom of Lesotho (Africa Institute of South Africa Pretoria 1975)
De Smith New Commonwealth
De Smith SA The New Commonwealth and its Constitutions (Stevens London 1964)
Duncan Sotho Laws and Customs
Duncan P Sotho Laws and Customs (Morija Museum and Archives Morija 2006) (facsimile reprint of the original 1960 ed)
Ellenberger and MacGregor History of the Basuto
Ellenberger DF and MacGregor JC History of the Basuto: Ancient and Modern (Caxton London 1912)
Gill Short History of Lesotho
Gill SJ A Short History of Lesotho (Morija Museum and Archives Morija 1993)
Hailey Native Administration
Hailey L Native Administration in the British African Territories - Part V (HMSO London 1953)
Haliburton Historical Dictionary of Lesotho
Haliburton G Historical Dictionary of Lesotho (Scarecrow Press Metuchen 1977)
Hamnett Chieftaincy and Legitimacy
Hamnett I Chieftaincy and Legitimacy (Routledge and Kegan Paul London 1975)
Himonga and Bosch 2000 SALJ
Himonga C and Bosch C "The Application of African Customary Law under the Constitution of South Africa: Problems Solved or Just Beginning?" 2000 SALJ 306-341
Jones "Chiefly Succession in Basutoland"
Jones GB "Chiefly Succession in Basutoland" in Goody J (ed) Succession to High Office (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1966) 57-81
Juma 2011 Pace Int'l L Rev
Juma L "The Laws of Lerotholi: Role and Status of Codified Rules of Custom in the Kingdom of Lesotho" 2011 Pace Int'l L Rev 92-145
Lerotholi Laws of Lerotholi
Lerotholi, Basuto Chief Laws of Lerotholi (Morija Sesuto Book Depot Morija 1959)
Laydevant Morena N Griffith Lerotholi
Laydevant F Morena N Griffith Lerotholi 1874-1939 (Mazenod Maseru 1953)
Macartney 1970 Parliamentary Affairs
Macartney WJA "African Westminster? The Parliament of Lesotho" 1970 Parliamentary Affairs 121-140
Machobane Government and Change in Lesotho
Machobane LLBJ Government and Change in Lesotho 1800-1966 (Macmillan London 1990)
Machobane 2000 Review of Southern African Studies
Machobane LLBJ "Gender, Succession and Dynastic Politics: The Saga of Senate and her Mot'soene Molapo Moshoeshoe 1858-1930" 2000 Review of Southern African Studies 19-41
MacMillan 1985 JMAS
MacMillan H "Swaziland: Decolonisation and the Triumph of 'Tradition'" 1985 JMAS 643-666
Maroleng 2003 Afr Secur Rev
Maroleng C "Swaziland: The King's Constitution" 2003 Afr Secur Rev 45-49
Mmusinyane 2009 PELJ
Mmusinyane B "The Role of Traditional Authorities in Developing Customary Laws in Accordance with the Constitution: Shilubana and Others v Nwamitwa 2008 (9) BCLR 914 (CC)" 2009 PELJ 135-161
Mohau "Scoping of All Primary and Secondary Legislation"
Mohau KK "Scoping of All Primary and Secondary Legislation Related to Chieftaincy" Unpublished report undertaken on behalf of LGNSP, 2010
Mubangizi 2012 JIWS
Mubangizi JC "A South African Perspective on the Clash between Culture and Human Rights, with Particular Reference to Gender-related Cultural Practices and Traditions" 2012 JIWS 33-48
'Nyane 2019 De Jure
'Nyane H "A Critique of the Swazi Constitutional Rules on Succession to Kingship" 2019 De Jure Law Journal 65-84
Palmer and Poulter Legal System of Lesotho
Palmer VV and Poulter SM The Legal System of Lesotho (Michie Company Charlottesville 1972)
Patterson American Democracy
Patterson TE The American Democracy 6th ed (McGraw-Hill New York 2003)
Picard 1984 JCAS
Picard LA "Traditionalism in Swaziland: The Economic Basis of a Southern African Monarchy" 1984 JCAS 291-298
Poulter 1975 JSAS
Poulter S "An Essay on African Customary Law Research Techniques: Some Experiences from Lesotho" 1975 JSAS 181-193
Proctor 1969 Civilisations
Proctor JH "Building a Constitutional Monarchy in Lesotho" 1969 Civilisations 64-86
Proctor 1973 African Affairs
Proctor JH "Traditionalism and Parliamentary Government in Swaziland" 1973 African Affairs 273-287
Rautenbach 2008 J Comp L
Rautenbach C "South African Common and Customary Law on Intestate Succession: A Question of Harmonisation, Integration or Abolition" 2008 J Comp L 119-132
Rosenberg et al Historical Dictionary of Lesotho
Rosenberg S et al Historical Dictionary of Lesotho: New Edition (Scarecrow Press Lanham 2004)
Rugege "Future of Traditional Hereditary Chieftaincy"
Rugege S "The Future of Traditional Hereditary Chieftaincy in a Democratic Southern Africa: The Case of Lesotho and South Africa" in Santho S and Sejanamane M (eds) Southern Africa after Apartheid (SAPES Trust Harare 1991) 148-185
Select Committee Report on Basutoland Annexation Bill
Select Committee Report of the Select Committee Appointed by the Legislative Council to Consider the Provisions of the Basutoland Annexation Bill (The Committee Cape Town 1871)
Tebbe 2008 Journal of Religion
Tebbe N "Inheritance and Disinheritance: African Customary Law and Constitutional Rights" 2008 Journal of Religion 466-496
Thompson Survival in Two Worlds
Thompson L Survival in Two Worlds: Moshoeshoe of Lesotho 1786-1870 (Clarendon Press Oxford 1975)
Case law
Alexkor Ltd v Richtersveld Community 2004 5 SA 460 (CC)
Bereng Griffith v Mants'ebo Seeiso Griffith 1926-53 HCTLR 50
Bhe v Magistrate, Khayelitsha 2005 1 SA 580 (CC)
Chere v Sekara JC 137/47
Constantine Bereng Seeiso v Dr Ntsu Mokhehle CIV/APN/103/94
Joel Mots'oene v Sir Edward Harding 1954 HCTLR 1
Khauoe v Attorney General 1995-1996 LLR & LB 470
Letsoela v Chief of Kolojane CIV\APN\131\91
Letsoela v Chief of Kolojane 1995-1999 LAC 280
Majara v Thelingoane CIV/T/642/97
Maseela v Maseela 1971-1973 LLR 132 (HC)
Matala v Peete 1978 LLR 378
'Meli Ntsoele v 'Mamolomong Ramokhele 1975 LLR 130
Moteane v Moteane 1995-1996 LAC 307
Senate Masupha v Senior Resident Magistrate for the Subordinate Court of Berea (unreported) C of A (CIV) 29/2013
Shilubana v Nwamitwa 2009 2 SA 66 (CC)
Legislation
Basutoland (Constitution) Order in Council High Commissioners Notice 103 of 1959
Chieftainship Act 22 of 1968
Constitution of Lesotho, 1966 (Schedule to Lesotho Independence Order 1172 of 1966)
Constitution of Lesotho, 1993
Constitution of Lesotho (Commencement) Order 5 of 1993
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
King's Proclamation 578 of 1973
Office of King Order 51 of 1970
Office of King Order 14 of 1990
Office of King (Reinstatement) Order 10 of 1994
Offices of Chiefs Order 26 of 1970
International instruments
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (1979)
Interviews
Khoabane, Theko (Interview) (15 July 2010, 20 August 2010 and 22 August 2012)
Letsie, Tumisang (Interview) (22 October 2011 and 20 October 2012)
Nkuebe, Nkau (Interview) (2 October 2010)
Internet sources
United Nations 2019 https://treaties.un.org/pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=IND&mtdsg_no=IV-8&chapter=4&clang=_en#33
United Nations 2019 Treaty Collection: Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women https://treaties.un.org/pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=IND&mtdsg_no=IV-8&chapter=4&clang=_en#33 accessed 23 January 2019
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
Afr Secur Rev African Security Review
CCR Constitutional Court Review
J Comp L Journal of Comparative Law
JCAS Journal of Contemporary African Studies
JIWS Journal of International Women's Studies
JMAS Journal of Modern African Studies
JSAS Journal of Southern African Studies
Pace Int'l L Rev Pace International Law Review
PELJ Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
Views
  • Abstract 184
  • pdf 74
  • xml 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-05-30
Section
Articles