The Protection of Children's Right to Self-Determination in South African Law with Specific Reference to Medical Treatment and Operations

  • Hanneretha Kruger
Keywords: Children’s autonomy; children’s right to self-determination; participation by children; children’s competence; adolescent capacity; informed consent; consent to medical treatment by children; consent to surgical operations by children

Abstract

The Children's Act 38 of 2005 provides that children over the age of 12 years can consent to their own medical treatment or that of their children, provided they are of sufficient maturity and have the mental capacity to understand the benefits, risks, social and other implications of the treatment (section 129(2)). The predecessor of the Children's Act set the age at which children could consent to medical treatment at 14 years, and no maturity assessment was required (Child Care Act 74 of 1983 section 39(4)). Children over the age of 12 years can consent to the performance of surgical operations on themselves or their children, provided that they have the level of maturity described above and they are duly assisted by their parents or guardians (Children's Act section 129(3)). Before the Children's Act came into operation, the Child Care Act allowed children over the age of 18 to consent to their own operations (section 39(4)). Neither a maturity assessment nor parental assistance was required. (Note that when the Child Care Act was in operation the majority age was still 21 years.) In this article the question is considered if the relaxation of the limitations on children's capacity to consent to medical treatment and surgical operations in the Children's Act recognises the right of children to make independent decisions without the assistance of their parents or guardians or other substitute decision-makers. Firstly the article investigates the theoretical foundations of the protection of children's rights, particularly their autonomy rights. Secondly the meaning of the concept "competence" in medical decision-making and the related concept of "informed consent" are discussed. Thirdly some developmental and neuroscientific research on children's decision-making capacities and how they influence children's competence to give consent valid in law are highlighted. Fourthly possible legal foundations for the protection of children's right to self-determination in medical decision-making are sought in the Constitution and international and regional human rights treaties. Finally the relevant provisions of the Children's Act are examined in order to ascertain whether children's right to self-determination is sufficiently protected in South African law

References

Literature

Alderson 2007 Social Science & Medicine
Alderson P "Competent children? Minors' consent to health care treatment and research" 2007 Social Science & Medicine 2272-2283

Ariès Centuries of Childhood
Ariès P Centuries of Childhood: A Social History of Family Life (Knopf New York 1962)

Arshagouni 2006 Journal of Health Care Law and Policy
Arshagouni P "'But I'm an adult now … sort of' Adolescent consent in health care decision-making and the adolescent brain" 2006 Journal of Health Care Law and Policy 315-364

Bainham Children
Bainham A Children: The Modern Law 3 ed (Family Law Bristol 2005)

Barratt 2002 THRHR
Barratt A "A child's right to be heard in custody and access determinations" 2002 THRHR 556-573

Bekink & Brand "Constitutional protection of children"
Bekink B and Brand D "Constitutional protection of children" in Davel CJ (ed) et al Introduction to Child Law in South Africa (Juta Lansdowne 2000) 169-196

Binford December 2012 Article 40
Binford W "Criminal capacity and the teenage brain: Insights from neurological research" December 2012 Article 40 1-6

Blakemore & Choudhury 2006 Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
Blakemore S and Choudhury S "Development of the adolescent brain: Implications for executive function and social cognition" 2006 Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 296-312

Buchanan & Brock Deciding for Others
Buchanan AE and Brock DW Deciding for Others: The Ethics of Surrogate Decision Making (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1989)

Boberg Persons and Family
Boberg PQR The Law of Persons and the Family (Juta Cape Town 1977)

Caufmann & Steinberg 2000 Behavioral Sciences and the Law
Caufmann E and Steinberg L "(Im)maturity of judgment in adolescence: Why adolescents may be less culpable than adults" 2000 Behavioral Sciences and the Law 741-760

Cockrell "Capacity to perform juristic acts: contracts"
Cockrell A "Capacity to perform juristic acts: contracts" in Van Heerden B, Cockrell A and Keightley R (eds) Boberg's Law of Persons (Juta Kenwyn 1999) 756-834

Coons & Mnookin "Towards a theory of children's rights"
Coons JE and Mnookin RH "Towards a theory of children's rights" in Baxter IFG and Eberts MA (eds) The Child and the Courts (Sweet & Maxwell London 1978)

Currie & De Waal The Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 6 ed Second Impression (Juta Cape Town 2016)

Delmage 2013 Youth Justice
Delmage E "The minimum age of criminal responsibility: A medico-legal perspective" 2013 Youth Justice 102-110

De Villiers 1993 Stell LR
De Villiers B "The rights of children in international law: guidelines for South Africa" 1993 Stell LR 289-310

Du Toit "Legal representation of children"
Du Toit C "Legal representation of children" in Boezaart T (ed) Child Law in South Africa (Juta Claremont 2009) 93-111

Eekelaar 1986 Law Quarterly Review
Eekelaar J "The eclipse of parental rights" 1986 Law Quarterly Review 4-9

Eekelaar 1986 Oxford JLS
Eekelaar "The emergence of children's rights" 1986 Oxford JLS 161-182

Fleming 2005 AJEDP
Fleming M "Adolescent autonomy: Desire, achievement and disobeying parents between early and late adolescence" 2005 AJEDP 1-16

Fortin Children's Rights
Fortin J Children's Rights and the Developing Law (Butterworths London 1998)

Foster & Freed 1972 Family Law Quarterly
Foster HH and Freed DJ "A Bill of Rights for children" 1972 Family Law Quarterly 343-375

Freeman 1980 CLP
Freeman MDA "The rights of children in the international year of the child" 1980 CLP 1-31

Freeman 1992 IJLPF
Freeman MDA "Taking children's rights more seriously" 1992 IJLPF 52-71

Freeman 1998 IJCR
Freeman MDA "The sociology of childhood and children's rights" 1998 IJCR 433-444

Freeman "The limits of children's rights"
Freeman MDA "The limits of children's rights" in Freeman MDA and Veerman PE (eds) The Ideologies of Children's Rights (Martinus Nijhoff Dordrercht 1992) 29-46

Freeman Rights and Wrongs
Freeman MDA The Rights and Wrongs of Children (F Pinter Dover 1983)

Gose African Charter
Gose M The African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (Community Law Centre University of the Western Cape 2000)

Grisso & Vierling 1978 Professional Psychology
Grisso T and Vierling L "Minor's consent to treatment: a developmental perspective" 1978 Professional Psychology 412-427

Hartman 2000 Hastings Law Journal
Hartman RG "Adolescent autonomy: Clarifying an ageless conundrum" 2000 Hastings Law Journal 1265-1362

Hartman 2002 American Journal of Law & Medicine
Hartman RG "Coming of age: Devising legislation for adolescent medical decision-making" 2002 American Journal of Law & Medicine 409-453

Haupt & Robinson 2001 THRHR
Haupt LC and Robinson JA "'n Oorsig oor die ontwikkeling van kinderregte met verwysing na die benaderings van die sogenaamde kiddie libbers en kiddie savers" 2001 THRHR 23-31

Heaton "Capacity to perform juristic acts: marriage"
Heaton J "Capacity to perform juristic acts: marriage and other acts" in Van Heerden B, Cockrell A and Keightley R (eds) Boberg's Law of Persons (Juta Kenwyn 1999) 835-854

Heaton 2009 JJS
Heaton J "An individualized, contextualized and child-centred determination of the child's best interests, and the implications of such an approach in the South African context" 2009 JJS 1-18

Heaton Law of Persons
Heaton J The South African Law of Persons 4th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2012)

Himonga & Cooke 2007 IJCR
Himonga C and Cooke A "A child's autonomy with special reference to reproductive medical decision-making in South African law: mere illusion or real autonomy?" 2007

Human 2000 THRHR
Human S "Die effek van kinderregte op die privaatregtelike ouer-kind verhouding" 2000 THRHR 393-402

Human 2000 Stell LR
Human S "Kinderregte en ouerlike gesag: 'n Teoretiese perspektief" 2000 Stell LR 71-84

Kassan & Mahery "Special child protective measures in the Children's Act"
Kassan D and Mahery P "Special child protective measures in the Children's Act" in Boezaart T (ed) Child Law in South Africa (Juta Claremont 2009) 185-224

Kruger 2006 THRHR
Kruger JM "The philosophical underpinnings of children's rights theory" 2006 THRHR 436-453

Kruger 2018 SALJ
Kruger H “The realization of children’s rights to participate in selected medical decisions in South Africa” 2018 SALJ 73-100

Lutchman 2014 SAJHR
Lutchman S "'Child savers' v 'kiddie libbers': the sexual rights of adolescents" 2014 SAJHR 555-571

Mahery "Consent laws"
Mahery P "Consent laws influencing children's access to health care services" in Ijumba P and Padarath A (eds) South African Health Review 2006

Mahery, Proudlock & Jamieson A Guide to the Children’s Act for Health Professionals
Mahery P, Proudlock P and Jamieson L A Guide to the Children's Act for Health Professionals 4 ed (Children's Institute University of Cape Town 2010)

McCabe 1996 Journal of Pediatric Psychology
McCabe MA "Involving children and adolescents in medical decision making: Developmental and clinical considerations" 1996 Journal of Pediatric Psychology 505-516

McQuoid-Mason 2010 SAMJ
McQuoid-Mason D "Termination of pregnancy and children: Consent and confidentiality issues" 2010 SAMJ 213-214

McQuoid-Mason 2007 SAMJ
McQuoid-Mason D "The effect of the new Children's Act on consent to HIV testing and access to contraceptives by children" 2007 SAMJ 1252-1253

Neethling & Potgieter Law of Delict
Neethling J and Potgieter JM Neethling – Potgieter – Visser Law of Delict 7 ed (LexisNexis Durban 2015)

Ngwena 1996 Acta Juridica
Ngwena C "Health care decision-making and the competent minor: the limits of self-determination" 1996 Acta Juridica 132-147

Noom, Deković & Meeus 2001 Journal of Youth and Adolescence
Noom MJ, Deković M and Meeus W "Conceptual analysis and measurement of adolescent autonomy" 2001 Journal of Youth and Adolescence 577-595

Pope 2007 SALJ
Pope A "HIV preventive research and minors" 2007 SALJ 165-187

Robinson & Ferreira 2000 De Jure
Robinson JA and Ferreira GM "Die reg van die kind om gehoor te word: Enkele verkennende perspektiewe op die VN Konvensie oor die Regte van die Kind (1989)" 2000 De Jure 54-67

Robinson 1993 TRW
Robinson JA "'n Oorsig oor die vertrekpunte van die Engelse Children Act 1989" 1993 TRW 41-66

Robinson 2002 Stell LR
Robinson JA "An introduction to the international law on the rights of the child relating to the parent-child relationship" 2002 Stell LR 309-320

Rodman & Griffith 1982 JADP
Rodman H and Griffith SB "Adolescent autonomy and minors' legal rights: Contraception and abortion" 1982 JADP 312-318

Scott, Reppucci & Woolard 1995 Law and Human Behavior
Scott ES, Reppucci ND and Woolard JL "Evaluating adolescent decision-making in legal contexts" 1995 Law and Human Behavior 221-244

Skelton "Constitutional protection of children's rights"
Skelton A "Constitutional protection of children's rights" in Boezaart T (ed) Child Law in South Africa (Juta Claremont 2009) 265-290

Slabbert 2004 PELJ
Slabbert MN "Parental access to minor's health records in the South African health care context: Concerns and recommendations" 2004 PELJ 171.

Sloth-Nielsen 1995 SAJHR
Sloth-Nielsen J "Ratification of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child: Some implications for South African law" 1995 SAJHR 401-420

South African Medical Research Council Guidelines on Ethics
South African Medical Research Council Guidelines on Ethics for Medical Research Book 1: General Principles (SAMRC Cape Town 2002)

Spear The Behavioral Neuroscience of Adolescence
Spear LP The Behavioral Neuroscience of Adolescence (WW Norton New York 2010)

Steinberg Adolescence
Steinberg LD Adolescence 3 ed (McGraw-Hill New York 1993)

Steinberg & Meyer Childhood (1995)
Steinberg L and Meyer R Childhood (McGraw-Hill New York 1995)

Strauss Doctor, Patient and the Law
Strauss S Doctor, Patient and the Law 3 ed (Van Schaik Hatfield 1991)

Thomas 2007 SALJ
Thomas R "Where to from Castell v De Greef? Lessons from recent developments in South Africa and abroad regarding consent to treatment and the standard of disclosure" 2007 SALJ 188-215

Van Bueren The International Law on the Rights of the Child
Van Bueren G The International Law on the Rights of the Child (M Nijhoff Dordrecht 1995)

Van Bueren "The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child"
Van Bueren G "The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child" in Davel CJ (ed) et al Introduction to Child Law in South Africa (Juta Lansdowne 2000) 210-212

Van Oosten The Doctrine of Informed Consent
FFW Van Oosten The Doctrine of Informed Consent in Medical Law (LLD Thesis University of South Africa 1989)

Van Wyk 2005 THRHR
Van Wyk C "HIV preventive vaccine research on children: Is this possible in terms of South African law and research guidelines?" 2005 THRHR 35-50

Viljoen "The African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child"
Viljoen F "The African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child" in Boezaart T (ed) Child Law in South Africa (Juta Claremont 2009)

Wald 1979 UCDLR
Wald MS "Children's rights: a framework for analysis" 1979 UCDLR 255-282

World Health Organisation The Health of Young People
World Health Organisation The Health of Young People: A Challenge and a Promise (WHO Geneva 2013)

Case law

Bannatyne v Bannatyne 2003 2 SA 363 (CC)
Castell v De Greeff 1994 4 SA 408 (C)
Christian Lawyers Association v Minister of Health (Reproductive Health Alliance as Amicus Curiae) 2005 1 SA 509 (T)
De Reuck v Director of Public Prosecutions (Witwatersrand Local Division) 2003 3 SA 389 (W)
Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority and the DHSS [1984] 1 All ER 365
Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority and the DHSS [1985] 1 All ER 533
Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority and the DHSS [1985] 3 All ER 402
Government of the Republic of South Africa v Grootboom 2001 1 SA 46 (CC)
Minister of Welfare and Population Development v Fitzpatrick 2000 3 SA 422 (CC)
S v M (Centre for Child Law as Amicus Curiae) 2008 3 SA 232 (CC)
Sonderup v Tondelli 2001 1 SA1171 (CC)

Legislation

Age of Majority Act 57 of 1972
Child Care Act 74 of 1983
Children's Act 38 of 2005
Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
National Health Act 61 of 2003
General Regulations Regarding Children, 2010 GN R261 in GG 33076 of 1 April 2010

International law instruments

United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989)
African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (1990)
Committee on the Rights of the Child General Comment No 12: The Right of the Child to be Heard (CRC/C/GC/12 20 July 2009)

IJCR International Journal of Children's Rights
IJLPF International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family
JADP Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology
JJS Journal for Juridical Science
Oxford JLS Oxford Journal of Legal Studies
PELJ Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal
SAJHR South African Journal on Human Rights
SALJ South African Law Journal
SAMJ South African Medical Journal
SAPR/PL SA Publiekreg/SA Public Law
Stell LR Stellenbosch Law Review
THRHR Tydskrif vir Hedendaagse Romeins-Hollandse Reg (Journal of Contemporary Roman-Dutch Law)
TRW Tydskrif vir Regswetenskap
UCDLR University of California, Davis Law Review
Views
  • Abstract 0
  • pdf 0
  • XML 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2018-10-15
Section
Articles