Beyond Sexual Binaries? The German Federal Constitutional Court and the Rights of Intersex People

The German Federal Constitutional Court and the rights of intersexed people

  • Henk Botha University of Stellenbosch
Keywords: German Federal Constitutional Court, third gender judgment, intersex, transsexual and transgender, sex and gender identity, human dignity, equality and freedom, sexual minorities in South Africa

Abstract

In a recent judgment, the German Federal Constitutional Court held that it was unconstitutional to require every person's sex to be entered on the birth register, without providing for a third option for intersex persons. This article examines the intersex judgment in view of the Court's earlier jurisprudence on the rights of trans persons. It argues that this judgment was enabled, to a significant extent, by the fluid understanding of sex and gender identity shown in those judgments, and by the elaboration in those cases of the relationship between sexual freedom, human dignity and equality. It also comments on the possible relevance of the intersex judgment for South Africa, in view of some of the parallels and differences between German and South African constitutional jurisprudence.

 

Google_Scholar42.png  

Author Biography

Henk Botha, University of Stellenbosch
BLC LLB (Pretoria) LLM (Columbia) LLD (Pretoria). Professor at the faculty of law, Stellenbosch University, South Africa. Email: hbotha@sun.ac.za

References

Bibliography

Literature

Balibar Equaliberty
Balibar É Equaliberty: Political Essays (Duke University Press Durham 2014)

Bishop and Woolman "Freedom and Security of the Person"
Bishop M and Woolman S "Freedom and Security of the Person" in Woolman S, Bishop M and Brickhill J (eds) Constitutional Law of South Africa 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2006) 40/1-40/99

Botha 2009 SAJHR
Botha H "Equality, Plurality and Structural Power" 2009 SAJHR 1-37

Butler Gender Trouble
Butler J Gender Trouble (Routledge New York 1990)

Butler Performative Theory of Assembly
Butler J Notes toward a Performative Theory of Assembly (Harvard University Press Cambridge 2015)

Code 2009 Philosophical Papers
Code L "A New Epistemology of Rape?" 2009 Philosophical Papers 327-345

Cornell At the Heart of Freedom
Cornell D At the Heart of Freedom: Feminism, Sex, and Equality (Princeton University Press Princeton 1998)

Fraser "Social Justice"
Fraser N "Social Justice in the Age of Identity Politics: Redistribution, Recognition, and Participation" in Fraser N and Honneth A (eds) Redistribution or Recognition? A Political-Philosophical Exchange (Verso London 2003) 7-109

Klein 2012 Ethnoscripts
Klein T "Who Decides whose Gender? Medico-Legal Classifications of Sex and Gender and their Impact on Transgendered South Africans' Family Rights" 2012 Ethnoscripts 12-34

Michelman "Freedom by any other Name?"
Michelman F "Freedom by any other Name? A Comparative Note on Losing Battles While Winning Wars" in Barnard-Naudé AJ, Cornell D and Du Bois F (eds) Dignity, Freedom and the Post-Apartheid Legal Order: The Critical Jurisprudence of Laurie Ackermann (Juta Cape Town 2009) 91-111

Sen Development as Freedom
Sen A Development as Freedom (Oxford University Press Oxford 1999)

Sloth-Nielsen 2018 Stell LR
Sloth-Nielsen R "Gender Normalisation Surgery and the Best Interest of the Child in South Africa" 2018 Stell LR 48-72

Visser and Picarra 2012 SAJHR
Visser C and Picarra E "Victor, Victoria or V? A Constitutional Perspective on Transsexuality and Transgenderism" 2012 SAJHR 506-531

Case law

1 BvR 2019/16, judgment of 10 October 2017

BVerfGE 49, 286 (1978)

BVerfGE 60, 123 (1982)

BVerfGE 88, 87 (1993)

BVerfGE 115, 1 (2005)

BVerfGE 116, 243 (2006)

BVerfGE 121, 175 (2008)

BVerfGE 128, 109 (2011)

Dawood; Shalabi; Thomas v Minister of Home Affairs 2000 3 SA 936 (CC)

Harksen v Lane 1998 1 SA 300 (CC)

Ferreira v Levin and Vryenhoek v Powell 1996 1 SA 984 (CC)

KOS v Minister of Home Affairs 2017 6 SA 588 (WCC)

MEC for Education: KwaZulu-Natal v Pillay 2008 1 SA 474 (CC)

Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie 2006 1 SA 524 (CC)

National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Justice 1999 1 SA 6 (CC)

President RSA v Hugo 1997 6 BCLR 708 (CC)

Prince v President of the Law Society of the Cape of Good Hope 2002 2 SA 794 (CC)

Prinsloo v Van der Linde 1997 6 BCLR 759 (CC)

Legislation

Alteration of Sex Description and Sex Status Act 49 of 2003

Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany

Civil Status Act (Personenstandsgesetz) of 2007

Civil Union Act 17 of 2006

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Interim Constitution of the Republic of South Africa Act 200 of 1993

Marriages Act 25 of 1961

Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000

Recognition of Customary Marriages Act 120 of 1998

Transsexual Act (Transsexuellengesetz) of 1980

Internet sources

Anon Date Unknown https://medlineplus.gov/ency/article/001669.htm
Anon Date Unknown Intersex https://medlineplus.gov/ency/
article/001669.htm accessed 10 February 2018

Baars 2017 http://verfassungsblog.de/the-politics-ofrecognition-and-the-limits-of-emancipation-through-law/
Baars G 2017 The Politics of Recognition and the Limits of Emancipation through Law http://verfassungsblog.de/the-politics-ofrecognition-and-the-limits-of-emancipation-through-law/ accessed 10 January 2018

Baars 2018 https://verfassungsblog.de/new-german-intersex-law-thirdgender-but-not-as-we-want-it/
Baars G 2018 New German Intersex Law: Third Gender but not as we want it https://verfassungsblog.de/new-german-intersex-law-thirdgender-but-not-as-we-want-it/ accessed 20 November 2018

Collison 2018 https://mg.co.za/article/2018-01-24-00-intersex-babies-killed-at-birth-because-theyre-bad-omens/
Collison C 2018 Intersex Babies Killed at Birth because 'They're Bad Omens" https://mg.co.za/article/2018-01-24-00-intersex-babies-killed-at-birth-because-theyre-bad-omens/ accessed 5 February 2018

Gender DynamiX and Legal Resources Centre Date Unknown https://genderdynamix.org.za/wp-content/uploads/LRC-act49-2015-web.pdf
Gender DynamiX and Legal Resources Centre Date Unknown Briefing Paper: Alteration of Sex Description and Sex Status Act 49 of 2003 https://genderdynamix.org.za/wp-content/uploads/LRC-act49-2015-web.pdf accessed 8 February 2018

Intersex Society of North America Date Unknown http://www.isna.org/faq/what_is_intersex
Intersex Society of North America Date Unknown What is Intersex? http://www.isna.org/faq/what_is_intersex accessed 10 February 2018

Mangold 2017 http://verfassungsblog.de/nichtmann-nicht-frau-nicht-nichts-ein-verfassungsblog-symposium
Mangold A 2017 Nicht Mann. Nicht Frau. Nicht Nichts: Ein Verfassungsblog-Symposium http://verfassungsblog.de/nichtmann-nicht-frau-nicht-nichts-ein-verfassungsblog-symposium accessed 10 January 2018

Völzmann 2017 http://verfassungsblog.de/gleiche-freiheit-fuer-alle-zur-freiheitsrechtlichen-begruendungdes-bverfg-in-der-entscheidung-zur-dritten-option/
Völzmann B 2017 Gleiche Freiheit für alle! Zur freiheitsrechtlichen Begründung des BVerfG in der Entscheidung zur Dritten Option http://verfassungsblog.de/gleiche-freiheit-fuer-alle-zur-freiheitsrechtlichen-begruendungdes-bverfg-in-der-entscheidung-zur-dritten-option/ accessed 10 January 2018
Views
  • Abstract 68
  • pdf 49
  • xml 11
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2018-12-13
Section
Articles