Tagging and Tracking of Persons with Albinism: A Reflection of Some Critical Human Rights & Ethical Issues Arising from the Use of the Global Positioning System (GPS) as Part of a Solution to Cracking Down on Violent Crimes Against Persons with Albinism

Keywords: Global Positioning System, Tagging, Tracking, Albinism, Privacy, Right to Liberty, dignity

Abstract

Recent years have seen an increase in the use of the Global Positioning System (GPS) by both private and public entities for the purpose of tracking and monitoring the location of human beings. The GPS tracking application is used as a locating system to monitor, among other people, children, the elderly who suffer from Alzheimer's, and the mentally ill, for personal protection purposes. This electronic monitoring system has also found application on parolees as a law enforcement measure. In trying to track down a tangible solution to prevent and mitigate brutal attacks on persons with albinism in South Africa, this article proposes the extension of the application of the use of the Global Positioning Tracking System to persons with albinism as a strategy to halt the continued attacks against this population. Although Malawi has pioneered the use of the GPS in the context of fighting violent crimes against persons with albinism, what is unsettling to the author is the fact that no debates have taken place on the ethical and legal concerns arising from electronically tagging and tracking people with albinism; especially in view of the fact that persons with albinism are already a vulnerable and stigmatised population. Could it be that ethical issues and human rights are to be ignored when it is affirmed that technology serves the common good of protecting persons with albinism? My emphasis here is on the need for a debate on what could otherwise be a controversial application of technology. Although the purpose of the GPS is undeniably worthy, sometimes the way these devices are used can be more problematic. More challenging is the desire to justify the encroachment of any rights, as arises through using this crime prevention strategy. The use of the electronic monitoring system to tag and track persons with albinism raises crucial human rights and ethical concerns, particularly relating to the right to privacy, liberty, perhaps equality, and notably, the right to dignity. There is a need to be conscious of the possibility of the misuse of the technology and precautionary measures must be put in place. This article therefore discusses the ethical and legal issues which could arise from the electronic tagging and tracking of persons with albinism

 

GS8.png

Author Biography

Mphoeng Maureen Mswela, University of South Africa

Department of Jurisprudence, Senior Lecturer in Law

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY
Literature

Ashcroft-Simpson 1999 Education & Ageing
Susan Ashcroft-Simpson “Nurses and the Use of Restraints” Education & Ageing 1999 14(1) 80

Barfield Fundamentals of Wearable Computers and Augmented Reality
Barfield W “Fundamentals of Wearable Computers and Augmented Reality” (Tylor & Francis Group London 2016)

Basdeo 2009 PER
Basdeo V “The Constitutional Validity of Search and Seizure Powers In South African Criminal Procedure” 2009 PER 310-332

Croome Taxpayers Rights in South Africa
Croome BJ Taxpayers Rights in South Africa (Juta Claremont 2010)

Cruz-Inigo et al 2011 Dermatologic Clinics
Cruz-Inigo AE et al “Albinism in Africa; Stigma, Slaughter and Awareness Campaigns” 2011 29 Dermatologic Clinics 79-87

Currie & De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I & De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook (Juta Cape Town 2013)

Grey How does GPS Work
Grey L How does GPS Work (Gareth’s Stephen New York 2014)

Hong et al 2006 BMC Public Health
Hong ES et al “Albinism in Africa as a Public Health Issue” 2006 6 (212) BMC Public Health 1-7

Hughes & Louw 2002 BMJ 847–848
Hughes JC & Louw SJ “Electronic tagging of people with dementia who wander
Ethical considerations are possibly more important than practical benefits” 2002 BMJ 847–848

Joint Economic Congress, Committee of the United Sates Chinas Economic Future: Challenges to US Policy
Joint Economic Congress, Committee of the United Sates Chinas Economic Future: Challenges to US Policy (ME Sharpe New York 1997)

Kaplan & Hegarty Understanding GPS Principles and Applications
Kaplan E & Hegarty C Understanding GPS Principles and Applications (Artech House Norwood 2006)

Kim Transportation Engineering and Planning- Vol II: Encyclopedia of Life Support Systems 117
Kim JT Transportation Engineering and Planning- Vol II: Encyclopedia of Life Support Systems (EOLSS Publishers Oxford 2009)

Unknown 1994 The Global Positioning System
Unknown “GPS History, Chronology, and Budget” 1994 The Global Positioning System 237-270

McComb Monitoring Animals and their Habitats: A Practitioner’s Guide
McComb B et al Monitoring Animals and their Habitats: A Practitioner’s Guide (CRC Press Parkway 2010)

McQuoid-Mason Privacy in Woolman et al Constitutional Law of South Africa
McQuoid-Mason D "Privacy" in Woolman S et al Constitutional Law of South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2011)

Michael et al 2006 Faculty of Informatics Papers
Michael K et al “The Emerging Ethics of Humancentric GPS Tracking and Monitoring” 2006 Faculty of Informatics Papers 1-12

Milner Pinpoint: How GPS is Changing our World
Milner G Pinpoint: How GPS is Changing our World (WW Norton London 2016)


Mswela 2017 African Human Rights Law Journal
Mswela M “Violent attacks against persons with albinism in South Africa: A human rights Perspective” 2017 17 African Human Rights Law
Journal 114-133

Mswela & Slabbert 2013 South African Journal of Bioethics and Law
Mswela M & Slabbert MN “Colour Discrimination among People with Albinism in South Africa” 2013 6 (1) South African Journal of Bioethics
and Law 25-27

Nellis et al Electronically Monitored Punishment International and Critical Perspectives
Nellis et al Electronically Monitored Punishment. International and Critical Perspectives (Routledge London)

O’Neil 2003 BMJ
O’Neil DJ “Electronic tagging of people with dementia who wander should be reserved for babies, convicted criminals, and animals” (2003)
BMJ 281

Swanepoel 1997 CILSA
Swanepoel JP “Warrantless Search and Seizure in Criminal Procedure: A Constitutional Challenge” 1997 CILSA 374-391

Xhafa Advances in Intelligent Systems and Interactive Applications
Xhafa F et al Advances in Intelligent Systems and Interactive Applications (Springer New York 2018)

Wilson Safe Kids Safe Families
Wilson S Safe Kids Safe Families (HarperCollins 2005)

Case Law

Bernstein v Bester NO 1996 (2) SA 751 (CC)

Magajane v Chairperson, North West Gambling Board and Others [2006] ZACC 8, 2006 (5) SA 250 (CC), 2006 (10) BCLR 1133 (CC), 2006 (2) SACR 447 (CC)

United States v Jones 565 U.S. 400 (2012)

United States v Katzin No. 12-2548 (3d Cir. 2013)

Legislation

Children’s Act 38 of 2005
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
South African Police Service Act 68 of 1995
POPI Act 4 of 2013
Government Publications
Department of Environmental Affairs, 2010, National Strategy for the Safety and Security for the Rhinoceros Population 3

Non-Government Publications

Braathhen SH “Albinism in Malawi, A Qualitative Study on Attitudes and Beliefs” 2005
Thesis submitted as part of the Master of Philosophy Degree in International Community Health in the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Oslo 1-66

Mswela M “A selection of Legal Issues Relating to persons Living with Albinism” 2016
Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the Requirements of the degree of Doctor of Law, at the
College of Law, University of South Africa, 1-283

Punetha & Mehta 2014 International Conference on Advances in Computing, Communications and Informatics (ICACCI) 2349-2353

Rajan 2008 Presentation at the International Conference on Contemporary Issues in Air Transport, Air Law & Regulation 6

Internet Sources

Africa Wildlife Tracking date unknown http://www.awt.co.za/
Africa Wildlife Tracking date unknown Africa Wildlife Tracking
http://www.awt.co.za/ accessed 10 February 2018
Bertagna P 2010 https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1278363
Bertagna 2010 How does a GPS tracking system work? https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1278363 accessed 10 February 2018

Brite House date unknown Rhino https://www.britehouse.co.za/Community/CSI/Documents/Rhino_Tagging.pdf
Brite House date unknown Rhino Tagging https://www.britehouse.co.za/Community/CSI/Documents/Rhino_Tagging.pdf accessed 13 April 2018

CSJ News 2017 http://csjnews.org/2017/04/10/malawi-bust-attacks-persons-albinism/
CSJ News 2017 Malawi Deploys GPS Trackers to bust Attacks on Persons with Albinism http://csjnews.org/2017/04/10/malawi-bust-attacks-persons-albinism/ accessed 14 February 2018

Kemp D 2013 https://verdict.justia.com/2013/11/04/warrant- requirement-gps-tracking-devices
Kemp 2013 The Warrant Requirement for GPS Tracking Devices
https://verdict.justia.com/2013/11/04/warrant- requirement-gps-tracking-devices accessed 14 February 2018

Meyer R 2015https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/03/supreme-court-if-youre-being-gps-tracked-youre-being-searched/389114/
Meyer 2015 U.S. Supreme Court: GPS Trackers Are a Form of Search and Seizure: When the government places a location monitor on you or your stuff, it could be violating the Fourth Amendment https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2015/03/supreme-court-if-youre-being-gps-tracked-youre-being-searched/389114/ accessed 13 April 2018
News 24 2012 https://www.news24.com/SciTech/News/Cape-farmer-counts-sheep-with-GPS-20120711 accessed 13 April 2018
News 24 2012 Cape famers count sheep with GPS https://www.news24.com/SciTech/News/Cape-farmer-counts-sheep-with-GPS-20120711 accessed 13 April 2018

Patterson T 2013 https://edition.cnn.com/2013/08/31/us/kal-fight-007-anniversary/index.html
Patterson 2013 The downing of Flight 007: 30 years later, a Cold War tragedy still seems surreal https://edition.cnn.com/2013/08/31/us/kal-fight-007anniversary/index.html 5 February 2018

Southern African Litigation Centre 2018
http://www.southernafricalitigationcentre.org/2018/03/23/a-call-for-an-end-and-a-holistic-response-to-attacks-on-persons-with-albinism-the-macdonald-masambuka-case/
Southern African Litigation Centre 2018 A Call for a Holistic Response to Attacks on Persons with Albinism: The Macdonald Masumbuka Case
http://www.southernafricalitigationcentre.org/2018/03/23/a-call-for-an-end-and-a-holistic-response-to-attacks-on-persons-with-albinism-the-macdonald-masambuka-case/ 7 February 2018

The Telegraph 2013
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/10029205/GPS-tags-for-dementia-patients.html
The Telegraph 2013 GPS tags for dementia patients https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/10029205/GPS-tags-for-dementia-patients.html13 April 2018

Thomas date unknown https://trackimo.com/real-time-tracking- kids/
Thomas A date unknown Monitor Children in School with GPS https://trackimo.com/real-time-tracking- kids/ 4 April 2018

Tracking System Direct date unknown https://www.tracking-system.com/for-consumers/gps-personal-tracking-system/315-gps-tracking-livestock.html
Tracking System Direct date unknown GPS Tracking Livestock https://www.tracking-system.com/for-consumers/gps-personal-tracking-system/315-gps-tracking-livestock.html 6 April 2018

FindLaw date unknown https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-3rd-circuit/1679462.html#footnote_1
FindLaw date unknown United States v Katzin
https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-3rd-circuit/1679462.html#footnote_1 9 March 2018
Views
  • Abstract 50
  • pdf 38
  • xml 1
  • epub 7
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-07-24
Section
Articles