Proselytising the Regulation of Religious Bodies in South Africa: Suppressing Religious Freedom?

Keywords: Secular, freedom of religion, belief

Abstract

In democratic pluralistic and secular societies, freedom of religion is a fundamental right to be enjoyed by all individuals and religious organisations. A unique feature of this human right is the extent to which it is premised on a personal belief. The latter can be "bizarre, illogical or irrational", but nevertheless deserving of protection in the interests of freedom of religion. However, when the expression of a religious belief or practice transgresses the civil or criminal law it must be dealt with in the relevant legislative framework to hold the transgressor liable. Measures taken by the state to regulate religious bodies in terms of a general supervisory council or umbrella body are an unreasonable and unjustifiable interference with freedom of religion, and hence unconstitutional. I am of the view that the right to freedom of religion depends for its constitutional validity – and viability – on there being no interference (or regulation) by the state except in instances as provided for in terms of relevant legislation.

 

Google_Scholar69.png  ScienceOpen_Log03431066.png

Author Biography

Radley Henrico, The University of the Western Cape, Department of Public Law and Jurisprudence.

Faculty of Law

References

Literature

Al-Dawoody Islamic Law of War
Al-Dawoody A The Islamic Law of War: Justifications and Regulations (Palgrave MacMillan New York 2011)

Al-Dawoody 2015 Kansai U Rev L & Pol
Al-Dawoody A "ISIS and its Brutality under Islamic Law" 2015 Kansai U Rev L & Pol 101-117

Benson 1999 UBC Law Rev
Benson IT "Notes Towards (Re)Defining of the Secular" 1999 UBC Law Rev 520-551

Benson 2007 Emory Int'l L Rev
Benson IT "The Freedom of Conscience and Religion in Canada: Challenges and Opportunities" 2007 Emory Int'l L Rev 111-166

Benson 2008 CCR
Benson IT "The Case for Religious Inclusivism and the Judicial Recognition of Religious Associational Rights: A Response to Lenta" 2008 CCR 295-313

Benson 2010 JSR
Benson IT "Taking Pluralism Seriously: The Need to Reunderstand Faith, Beliefs, Religion and Diversity in the Public Sphere" 2010 JSR 17-41

Berger 2002 Can J L & Soc'y
Berger B "The Limits of Belief: Freedom of Religion, Secularism, and the Liberal State" 2002 Can J L & Soc'y 39-68

Berman, Bhargava and Laliberté Secular States and Religious Diversity
Berman BJ, Bhargava R and Laliberté A Secular States and Religious Diversity (UBC Press Vancouver 2013)

Campos 1994 Colum L Rev
Campos PF "Secular Fundamentalism" 1994 Colum L Rev 1814-1827

Chimuka 2016 Studie Historiae Ecclesiasticae
Chimuka TA "Afro-pentecostalism and Contested Holiness in Southern Africa" 2016 Studie Historiae Ecclesiasticae 124-141

Coertzen 2012 NGTT Supplementum 2
Coertzen P "Religion and the Common Good in a Pluralistic Society" 2012 NGTT Supplementum 2 175-190

Coertzen 2014 AHRLJ
Coertzen P "Constitution, Charter and Religions in South Africa" 2014 AHRLJ 126-141

Cook 2013 Yale J L & Human
Cook AE "God Talk in a Secular World" 2013 Yale J L & Human 435-461

Farrow Recognising Religion in a Secular Society
Farrow D Recognising Religion in a Secular Society: Essays in Pluralism, Religion, and Public Policy (McGill-Queen's University Press Montreal 2004)

Ferrari 2011 IJRF
Ferrari S "Religion and the Development of Civil Society" 2011 IJRF 29-36

Glendon 2004 Northwestern Journal of Human Rights
Glendon MA "The Rule of Law in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights" 2004 Northwestern Journal of Human Rights 1-19

Hackett "Tradition, African, Religious, Freedom?"
Hackett RIJ "Tradition, African, Religious, Freedom?" in Sullivan WF et al (eds) Politics of Religious Freedom (University of Chicago Press Chicago 2015) ch 7

Henrico 2012 Obiter
Henrico R "Mutual Accommodation of Religious Differences in the Workplace: A Jostling of Rights" 2012 Obiter 503-525

Hoexter Administrative Law
Hoexter C Administrative Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2012)

Ismail 2001 Ind Int'l & Comp L Rev
Ismail JS "South Africa's Sunday Law: Finding a Compromise" 2001 Ind Int'l & Comp L Rev 563-586

Leatt 2007 JSR
Leatt A "Faithfully Secular: Secularism and South African Political Life" 2007 JSR 29-44

Lenta 2005 SALJ
Lenta P "Religious Liberty and Cultural Accommodation" 2005 SALJ 352-377

Malherbe 2011 BYU L Rev
Malherbe R "The Background and Contents of the Proposed South African Charter of Religious Rights and Freedoms" 2011 BYU L Rev 612-636

Marshall 2013 IJRF
Marshall P "Conceptual Issues in Contemporary Religious Freedom Research" 2013 IJRF 7-16

Milonakis and Fine From Political Economy to Economics
Milonakis D and Fine B From Political Economy to Economics: Method, the Social and Historical in the Evolution of Economic Theory (Routledge New York 2009)

Mndende 2013 NGTT
Mndende N "Law and Religion in South Africa: An African Traditional Perspective" 2013 NGTT 74-82

Moon Law and Religious Pluralism
Moon RJ Law and Religious Pluralism in Canada (University of British Columbia Press Vancouver 2008)

Moosa 2001 J L Relig
Moosa E "The Dilemma of Islamic Rights Schemes" 2001 J L Relig 185-215

Powell "Law as Justification"
Powell C "Law as Justification: Glenister, Separation of Powers and the Rule of Law" in Andrews P, Davis D and Masengu T (eds) A Warrior of Justice: Essays in Honour of Dikgang Moseneke (Juta Cape Town 2017) 55-74

Rawls Political Liberalism
Rawls J Political Liberalism (Columbia University Press New York 1993)

Schlink 2012 Duke J Comp & Int'l L
Schlink B "Proportionality in Constitutional Law: Why Everywhere but Here?" 2012 Duke J Comp & Int'l L 291-302

Sedgwick 2015 Perspectives on Terrorism
Sedgwick M "Jihadism, Narrow and Wide: The Dangers of Loose Use of an Important Term" 2015 Perspectives on Terrorism 34-41

Ssenyonjo 2009 ICON
Ssenyonjo M "Limits on the Freedom to Manifest One's Religion in Educational Institutions in Uganda and the United Kingdom" 2009 ICON 275-305

Stilt 2010 Tex Int'l LJ
Stilt K "Islam is the Solution: Constitutional Visions of the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood" 2010 Tex Int'l LJ 74-104

Tolstoy War and Peace
Tolstoy L War and Peace (Penguin Random House South Africa Randburg 2007)

Van der Vyver 2000 Emory Int'l L Rev
Van der Vyver JD "State-sponsored Proselytization: A South African Experience" 2000 Emory Int'l L Rev 779-848

Van der Vyver and Green 2008 AHRLJ
Van der Vyver JD and Green MC "Law, Religion and Human Rights in Africa: An Introduction" 2008 AHRLJ 337-356

Van Praagh 2001 Can Bar Rev
Van Praagh S "Identity's Importance: Reflections of – and on – Diversity" 2001 Can Bar Rev 604-619

Venter Constitutionalism and Religion
Venter F Constitutionalism and Religion (Edgar Elgar Cheltenham 2015)

Case law
Afriforum v University of the Free State 2018 2 SA 185 (CC)
Albutt v Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation 2010 3 SA 293 (CC)
Chamberlain v Surrey School Board 2000 80 BCLR (3d) 181 (CA)
Christian Education South Africa v Minister of Education 2000 4 SA 757 (CC)
Dlamini v Green Four Security 2006 11 BLLR 1074 (LC)
EFF v Speaker of the National Assembly 2018 2 SA 571 (CC)
Everson v Board of Education 330 US 1 (1947)
Ex Parte Speaker of the Western Cape Provincial Legislature 1997 4 SA 795 (CC)
Kievits Kroon Country Estate (Pty) Ltd v Mmoledi 2014 35 ILJ 209 (SCA)
Lawrence, Negal, Solberg v State 1997 4 SA 1176 (CC)
Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie 2006 1 SA 524 (CC)
Occupiers of Erven 87 & 88 of Berea v Christiaan Frederick 2017 5 SA 346 (CC)
Prince v President of the Law Society of the Cape of Good Hope 2002 2 SA 794 (CC)
Publication Control Board v Gallo (Africa) Ltd 1975 3 SA 665 (A)
R v Big Drug Mart Ltd 1985 1 SCR 295

Legislation
Agricultural Stock Remedies Act 36 of 1947
Animals Protection Act 71 of 1962
Banks Act 94 of 1990
Commission for the Promotion and Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities Act 19 of 2002
Companies Act 71 of 2008
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Deeds Registries Act 47 of 1937
Group Areas Act 41 of 1950
Immigration Act 13 of 2002
Income Tax Act 58 of 1962
Non-Profit Organisations Act 71 of 1997
Prevention and Combatting of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004
Prevention of Organised Crime Act 121 of 1998
Promotion of Administrative Justice Act 3 of 2000
SA Reserve Bank Act 90 of 1989
Schools Act 84 of 1962
US Constitution (First Amendment)

Internet sources
Anon 2018 https://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/day-of-doom-for-pastor-as-court-finds-him-guilty-of-assault-20180209
Anon 2018 Day of Doom for Pastor as Court Finds Him Guilty of Assault https://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/day-of-doom-for-pastor-as-court-finds-him-guilty-of-assault-20180209 accessed 20 March 2018

CRL Rights Commission 2017 http://www.crlcommission.org.za/docs/
Report%20On%20Commecialization%20of%20Religion%20and%20Abuse%20of%20People's%20Believe%20Systems%20final.pdf
CRL Rights Commission 2017 Report of the Hearings on the Commercialisation of Religion and Abuse of People's Belief Systems http://www.crlcommission.org.za/docs/Report%20On%20Commecialization%20of%20Religion%20and%20Abuse%20of%20People's%20Believe%20Systems%20final.pdf accessed 20 March 2018

FOR SA 2018 https://forsa.org.za/parliamentary-committee-drafts-response-to-the-crls-report-on-regulation-of-religion/
Freedom of Religion South Africa 2018 Parliamentary Committee Responds to the CRL's Report on Regulation of Religion https://forsa.org.za/
parliamentary-committee-drafts-response-to-the-crls-report-on-regulation-of-religion/ accessed 22 March 2018

FOR SA and SACRRF 2017 http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/171017SARRF.pdf
Freedom of Religion South Africa and South African Council for the Protection and Promotion of Religious Rights and Freedoms 2017 Comments on the CRL Rights Commission’s Report on the "Commercialisation" of Religion http://pmg-assets.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/171017SARRF.pdf accessed 20 March 2018

Mitchley 2018 https://www.huffingtonpost.co.za/2018/01/15/afrikaans-medium-school-wins-court-battle-against-education-department_a_23333959
Mitchley A 2018 Afrikaans Medium School Wins Court Battle Against Education Department https://www.huffingtonpost.co.za/2018/01/15/afri-kaans-medium-school-wins-court-battle-against-education-depart-ment_a_23333959/ accessed 20 March 2018

Moloney 2015 https://www.wsj.com/articles/pope-denounces-deviant-forms-of-religion-1421067797
Moloney L 2015 Pope Denounces 'Deviant Forms of Religion' https://www.wsj.com/articles/pope-denounces-deviant-forms-of-religion-1421067797 accessed 20 March 2018

Motau 2018 http://ewn.co.za/2018/02/09/he-s-doomed-prophet-of-doom-found-guilty
Motau K 2018 He's Doomed: Lethebo Rabalago Found Guilty http://ewn.co.za/2018/02/09/he-s-doomed-prophet-of-doom-found-guilty accessed 18 March 2018

Nemakonde 2015 https://citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/423976/pastor-mnguni-makes-congregation-eat-snakes/
Nemakonde V 2015 Pastor Mnguni Makes Congregation Eat Snakes https://citizen.co.za/news/south-africa/423976/pastor-mnguni-makes-congregation-eat-snakes/ accessed 20 March 2018

Pew Research Centre 2013 http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religion-politics-society-overview/
Pew Research Centre 2013 The World’s Muslims: Religion, Politics and Society http://www.pewforum.org/2013/04/30/the-worlds-muslims-religion-politics-society-overview/ accessed 27 February 2016
PMG 2017 https://pmg.org.za/page/CRL%20Rights?via=homepage-feature-card
Parliamentary Monitoring Group 2017 CRL Rights Commission Report: Commercialisation of Religion and Abuse of People's Belief Systems: Hearings Day 1 https://pmg.org.za/page/CRL%20Rights?via=homepage-feature-card accessed 20 March 2018

Reilly 2014 http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2537053/Lawn-Christians-South-African-preacher-makes-congregation-eat-GRASS-closer-God.html
Reilly J 2014 Lawn again Christians: South African Preacher Makes Congregation Eat GRASS to 'Be Closer to God' http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2537053/Lawn-Christians-South-African-preacher-makes-congregation-eat-GRASS-closer-God.html accessed 19 March 2018

Roald 2011 https://www.cmi.no/publications/file/4239.pdf
Roald AS 2011 Multiculturalism and Pluralism in Secular Society: Individual or Collective Rights? https://www.cmi.no/publications/file/4239.pdf accessed 20 March 2018

SACRRF 2010 https://www.strasbourgconsortium.org/content/blurb/files/
South%20African%20Charter.pdf
South African Council for the Protection and Promotion of Religious Rights and Freedoms 2010 The South African Charter of Religious Rights and Freedoms and the South African Council for the Protection and Promotion of Religious Rights and Freedoms https://www.strasbourgconsortium.org/
content/blurb/files/South%20African%20Charter.pdf accessed 22 March 2018

South African Government 2003 https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/
gcis_document/201409/religion0.pdf
South African Government 2003 National Policy on Religion and Education https://www.gov.za/sites/default/files/gcis_document/201409/religion0.pdf accessed 20 March 2018

Stats SA 2015 https://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P0318/
P03182015.pdf
Stats SA 2015 General Household Survey https://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/P0318/P03182015.pdf accessed 20 March 2018

Stats SA 2016 http://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/publications
/P0318/P03182016.pdf
Stats SA 2016 General Household Survey 2016 http://www.statssa.gov.za/publications/publications/P0318/P03182016.pdf accessed 20 March 2018

List of Abbreviations

AHRLJ African Human Rights Law Journal
ATR African Traditional Religions
BYU L Rev Brigham Young University Law Review
Can Bar Rev Canadian Bar Review
Can J L & Soc'y Canadian Journal of Law and Society
CCR Constitutional Court Review
COGTA Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on
Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs
Colum L Rev Columbia Law Review
CRL Rights Commission Commission for the Promotion and
Protection of the Rights of Cultural, Religious and Linguistic Communities
Duke J Comp & Int'l L Duke Journal of Comparative and International Law
Emory Int'l L Rev Emory International Law Review
FOR SA Freedom of Religion South Africa
ICON International Journal of Constitutional Law
IJRF International Journal for Religious Freedom
Ind Int'l & Comp L Rev Indiana International and Comparative Law Review
J L Relig Journal of Law and Religion
JSR Journal for the Study of Religion
Kansai U Rev L & Pol Kansai University Review of Law and Politics
NGTT Nederduitss Gereformeerde Teologiese Tydskrif
PMG Parliamentary Monitoring Group
PRC Peer-Review Committee
SACRRF South African Council for the
Protection and Promotion of Religious Rights and Freedoms
SALJ South African Law Journal
Tex Int'l LJ Texas International Law Journal
UBC Law Rev University of British Columbia Law Review
Yale J L & Human Yale Journal of Law and Humanities
Views
  • Abstract 425
  • pdf 243
  • xml 9
  • epub 9
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-03-12
Section
Articles