Metaphysical Anthropocentrism, Limitrophy, and Responsibility: An Explication of the Subject of Animal Rights
This article undertakes a critical analysis of subjectivity and exposes the metaphysical and anthropocentric quasi-transcendental conditions that give rise to the construct(ion) of the Subject. I locate a critical moment for the metaphysical Subject in the work of Martin Heidegger which, whilst sadly not sustained in his later writings, provides a point of departure for an examination of the significance that animality plays in the metaphysical tradition and its constitutive relation to the construct of subjectivity. I discern this relation to be violent and sacrificial and draw on Jacques Derrida's nonanthropocentric ethics against the background of Drucilla Cornell's ethical reading of deconstruction to construct a critique of approaches that assimilate animals to the traditional model of subjectivity in order to represent their identity and interests in the legal paradigm. The main argument that I seek to advance is that such an approach paradoxically re-constructs the classical humanist subject of metaphysics and re-establishes the subject-centred system that silences the call of the animal Other, thereby solidifying and extending the legitimacy of a discourse and mode of social regulation that is fundamentally anthropocentric. I examine how we can address, incapacitate and move beyond this schemata of power through a rigorous deconstruction of the partitions that institute the Subject and how deconstruction clears a space for a de novo determination of the animal "subject" that can proceed from different sites of nonanthropocentric interruption. What follows is a call to refuse the mechanical utilisation of traditional legal constructs and I argue in favour of an approach to the question of the animal (in law) that identifies and challenges anthropocentrism as its critical target. I ultimately propose a critical engagement with the underlying metaphysical support of animal rights at a conceptual level, rather than simply utilising the law pragmatically as an instrument of immediate resolution.
Aristotle "Treatise on Government"
Aristotle "A Treatise on Government: Book I" in Ellis W (trans) Aristotle's Politics: A Treatise on Government (Routledge Manchester 1895) 9-35
Bernasconi and Critchley "Introduction"
Bernasconi R and Critchley S "Introduction" in Bernasconi R and Critchley S (eds) Re-reading Levinas (Indiana University Press Bloomington 1991) xi-xviii
Calarco 2004 Cont Philos Rev
Calarco M "Deconstruction is not Vegetarianism: Humanism, Subjectivity, and Animal Ethics" 2004 Cont Philos Rev 175-201
Calarco "Heidegger's Zoontology"
Calarco M "Heidegger's Zoontology" in Calarco M and Atterton P (eds) Animal Philosophy: Essential Readings in Continental Thought (Continuum London 2004) 18-30
Calarco M Zoographies: The Question of the Animal from Heidegger to Derrida (Columbia University Press New York 2008)
Cornell Philosophy of the Limit
Cornell D The Philosophy of the Limit (Routledge New York 1992)
Critchley Ethics, Politics, Subjectivity
Critchley S Ethics, Politics, Subjectivity: Essays on Derrida, Levinas and Contemporary French Thought (Verso London 1999)
Critchley "Question of the Question"
Critchley S "The Question of the Question: An Ethico-political Response to a Note in Derrida's De l'esprit" in Wood D (ed) Of Derrida, Heidegger, and Spirit (Northwestern University Press Evanston 1993) 93-102
Derrida "Force of Law"
Derrida J "Force of Law: The 'Mystical Foundation of Authority'" (trans Quaintance M) in Anidjar G (ed) Acts of Religion (Routledge New York 2002) 230-298
Derrida Of Spirit
Derrida J Of Spirit: Heidegger and the Question (trans Bennington G and Bowlby R) (University of Chicago Press Chicago 1989)
Derrida The Animal That Therefore I Am
Derrida J The Animal That Therefore I Am (trans Wills D, ed Mallet M) (Fordham University Press New York 2008)
Derrida "Violence and Metaphysics"
Derrida J "Violence and Metaphysics: An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas" in Writing and Difference (trans Bass A) (University of Chicago Press Chicago 1978) 79-153
Derrida and Nancy "'Eating Well'"
Derrida J and Nancy J "'Eating Well,' or the Calculation of the Subject: An Interview with Jacques Derrida" (trans Connor P and Ronell A) in Cadava E, Connor P and Nancy J (eds) Who Comes after the Subject? (Routledge New York 1991) 96-119
Descartes R "Discourse on the Method of Rightly Conducting the Reason, and Seeking Truth in the Sciences: Part Five" in Veitch J (trans) Discourse on the Method (Cosimo Classics New York 2008) 36-46
De Villiers 2012 SAJHR
De Villiers J "Towards an Ethical Relation to the Nonhuman Other: Deconstruction, Veganism and the Law" 2012 SAJHR 18-30
De Villiers 2012 SAPL
De Villiers J "Examining the Similarity Principle and Language of (Animal) Rights as a Foundation for Animal Liberation" 2012 SAPL 40-53
De Villiers 2015 SAPL
De Villiers J "Animal Rights Theory, Animal Welfarism and the 'New Welfarist' Amalgamation: A Critical Perspective" 2015 SAPL 406-433
Douzinas End of Human Rights
Douzinas C The End of Human Rights: Critical Legal Thought at the Turn of the Century (Hart Oxford 2000)
Francione Animals as Persons
Francione G Animals as Persons: Essays on the Abolition of Animal Exploitation (Columbia University Press New York 2008)
Heidegger Being and Time
Heidegger M Being and Time (trans Macquarrie J and Robinson E) (Harper Perennial New York 1962)
Heidegger "Letter on 'Humanism'"
Heidegger M "Letter on 'Humanism'" (trans Capuzzi F) in McNeill W (ed) Pathmarks (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1998) 239-276
Heidegger "Plato's Doctrine of Truth"
Heidegger M "Plato's Doctrine of Truth" (trans Sheehan T) in McNeill W (ed) Pathmarks (Cambridge Universsity Press Cambridge 1998) 155-182
Heidegger "Age of the World Picture"
Heidegger M "The Age of the World Picture" in Young J and Haynes K (trans and eds) Off the Beaten Track (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2002) 57-85
Heidegger Fundamental Concepts of Metaphysics
Heidegger M The Fundamental Concepts of Metaphysics: World, Finitude, Solitude (trans McNeill W and Walker N) (Indiana University Press Bloomington 1995)
Heidegger "Origin of the Work of Art"
Heidegger M "The Origin of the Work of Art" in Hofstadter A (trans) Poetry, Language, Thought (Harper & Row New York 1971) 15-87
Heidegger M Parmenides (trans Schuwer A and Rojcewicz R) (Indiana University Press Bloomington 1992)
Heidegger On the Way to Language
Heidegger M On the Way to Language (trans Hertz P) (Harper & Row New York 1971)
Heidegger What is Called Thinking?
Heidegger M What is Called Thinking? (trans Gray J) (Harper & Row New York 1968)
Levinas Collected Philosophical Papers
Levinas E Collected Philosophical Papers (trans Lingis A) (Martinus Nijhoff Publishers Dordrecht 1987)
Levinas Otherwise than Being
Levinas E Otherwise than Being, or, Beyond Essence (trans Lingis A) (Duquesne University Press Pittsburgh 1998)
Levinas "Paradox of Morality"
Levinas E "The Paradox of Morality: An Interview with Emmanuel Levinas" (trans Benjamin A and Wright T) in Bernasconi R and Wood D (eds) The Provocation of Levinas: Rethinking the Other (Routledge New York 1988) 168-180
Levinas Totality and Infinity
Levinas E Totality and Infinity: An Essay on Exteriority (trans Lingis A) (Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht 1991)
Lewis 2017 Cosmos and History
Lewis M "The Relation between Stranscendental Philosophy and Empirical Science in Heidegger's Fundamental Concepts of Metaphysics" 2017 Cosmos and History: The Journal of Natural and Social Philosophy 47-72
Peperzak A "Presentation" in Bernasconi R and Critchley S (eds) Re-Reading Levinas (Indiana University Press Bloomington 1991) 51-66
Plato "Statesman" (trans Rowe C) in Cooper J and Hutchinson D (eds) Plato: Complete Works (Hackett Indianapolis 1997) 294-358
Regan Defending Animal Rights
Regan T Defending Animal Rights (University of Illinois Press Urbana 2001)
Regan Case for Animal Rights
Regan T The Case for Animal Rights 2nd ed (University of California Press Berkeley 2004)
Wise Drawing the Line
Wise S Drawing the Line: Science and the Case for Animal Rights (Perseus Books Cambridge 2002)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Copyright in all material published in PER/PELJ vests in the author, provided that authors grant, by submission of their contributions, permission that their contributions may be shared and adapted without restriction. An author furthermore agrees that the same contribution may not be published elsewhere without the written permission of the editor.
Anyone gaining access, electronically or otherwise, to a contribution to PER, may quote from such contribution, use the intellectual content thereof, share and adapt it, but subject to the following conditions:
you must give appropriate credit, provide a link and indicate if changes were made; and
the copyright of the author(s) may not be infringed in any way.