Property and "Human Flourishing": A Reassessment in the Housing Framework

Keywords: human flourishing, property regulation, housing rights, land reform, progressive property theory

Abstract

In South Africa, land/housing is a finite non-shareable type of property that must yield to stringent constitutional control to meet land reform and housing objectives, which is high on our constitutional agenda to redress injustices of the past and allow the previously dispossessed to take their rightful place in society. This article considers the normative framework that underlies the types of property that must be regulated for the purposes of section 25 of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996, since very few cases have been decided in such a way as to consider, from a normative perspective when land/housing should be subject to greater governmental control and when not. Even in the context of expropriation without compensation, certain types of land/buildings are being flagged for this purpose, but the normative reasons for such propositions remain unclear. The purpose of this article is to offer a theoretical perspective, based on work done by progressive-property scholars, on the normative foundation of some property rights, with the object of initiating a dialogue concerning whether or not such rights should be regulated. The notion of human flourishing, as developed by Alexander, should arguably be essential in determining whether land/housing rights should be subject to greater constitutional scrutiny; the more property contributes to the individual's autonomy and ability to partake in social relations, the more sceptical we should be of severe governmental interference; whereas the lesser the notion of human flourishing appears, the greater governmental interference should be. An approach of this kind adheres to the systemic purpose of section 25 of the Constitution, because the property clause is intended to regulate established rights just as much as it is intended to meet certain societal needs

 

GS11.png

References

Literature

Alexander 2009a Cornell L Rev
Alexander GS "The Social-obligation Norm in American Property Law" 2009 Cornell L Rev 745-819

Alexander 2009b Cornell L Rev
Alexander GS "The Complex Core of Property" 2009 Cornell L Rev 1063-1071

Alexander 2012 U Pa L Rev
Alexander GS "Governance Property" 2012 U Pa L Rev 1853-1888

Alexander 2013 HKLJ
Alexander GS "Ownership and Obligations: The Human Flourishing Theory of Property" 2013 HKLJ 451-462

Alexander 2014 Iowa L Rev
Alexander GS "Property's Ends: The Publicness of Private Law Values" 2014 Iowa L Rev 1257-1296

Alexander and Peñalver 2009 Theoretical Inquires in Law
Alexander GS and Peñalver EM "Properties of Community" 2009 Theoretical Inquires in Law 127-160

Barros 2009 NYU J L & Liberty
Barros BD "Property and Freedom" 2009 NYU J L & Liberty 36-69

Duguit Las Transformaciones del Derecho Publico y Privado
Duguit L Las Transformaciones del Derecho Publico y Privado (Editorial Heliastra Buenos Aires 1975)

Foster and Bonilla 2011 Fordham L Rev
Foster S and Bonilla D "The Social Function of Property: A Comparative Law Perspective" 2011 Fordham L Rev 1003-1015

Merrill and Smith 2001 Columbia L Rev
Merrill TW and Smith HE "The Property/Contract Interface" 2001 Columbia L Rev 773-852

Merrill and Smith 2001 Yale LJ
Merrill TW and Smith HE "What Happened to Property in Law and Economics?" 2001 Yale LJ 357-398

Merrill and Smith 2007 Wm & Mary L Rev
Merrill TW and Smith HE "The Morality of Property" 2007 Wm & Mary L Rev 1849-1895

Michelman 1981 Clev St L Rev
Michelman FI "Process and Property in Constitutional Theory" 1981 Clev St L Rev 577-593

Michelman 1981 Wash & Lee L Rev
Michelman FI "Property as a Constitutional Right" 1981 Wash & Lee L Rev 1097-1114

Michelman 1992 U Chi L Rev
Michelman FI "Liberties, Fair Values, and Constitutional Method" 1992 U Chi L Rev 91-114

Michelman 2016 Brigham-Kanner Prop Rts Conf J
Michelman FI "Good Government, Core Liberties, and Constitutional Property: An Essay for Joe Singer" 2016 Brigham-Kanner Prop Rts Conf J 27-43

Peñalver 2008 Cornell L Rev
Peñalver EM "Land Virtues" 2008 Cornell L Rev 821-888

Radin 1982 Stan L Rev
Radin MJ "Property and Personhood" 1982 Stan L Rev 957-1015

Rose 1995 Notre Dame L Rev
Rose CM "Property as the Keystone Right? " 1995 Notre Dame L Rev 329-370

Rosser 2013 CLR
Rosser E "The Ambition and Transformative Potential of Progressive Property" 2013 CLR 107-171

Schnably 1993 Stan L Rev
Schnably SJ "Property and Pragmatism: A Critique of Radin's Theory of Property and Personhood" 1993 Stan L Rev 347-407

Singer Entitlement
Singer JW Entitlement: The Paradoxes of Property (Yale University Press New Haven 2000)

Singer 2006 Harv Envtl L Rev
Singer JW "The Ownership Society and Takings of Property: Castles, Investments, and Just Obligations" 2006 Harv Envtl L Rev 309-338

Singer 2009 Cornell L Rev
Singer JW "Democratic Estates: Property Law in a Free and Democratic Society" 2009 Cornell L Rev 1009-1062

Singer 2014 Duke LJ
Singer JW "Property as the Law of Democracy" 2014 Duke LJ 1287-1335

Smith 2009 Cornell L Rev
Smith HE "Response: Mind the Gap: The Indirect Relation Between Ends and Means in American Property Law" 2009 Cornell L Rev 959-989

Strydom and Viljoen 2014 PELJ
Strydom J and Viljoen S "Unlawful Occupation of Inner-city Buildings: A Constitutional Analysis of the Rights and Obligations Involved" 2014 PELJ 1207-1261

Underkuffler-Freund 1996 Notre Dame L Rev
Underkuffler-Freund LS "Property: A Special Right" 1996 Notre Dame L Rev 1033-1058

Underkuffler 2007 Cornell L Rev
Underkuffler LS "Property as Constitutional Myth: Utilities and Dangers" 2007 Cornell L Rev 1239-1254

Underkuffler 2015 Tex L Rev
Underkuffler LS "Property and Change: The Constitutional Conundrum" 2015 Tex L Rev 2015-2037

Van der Walt and Viljoen 2015 PELJ
Van der Walt AJ and Viljoen S "The Constitutional Mandate for Social Welfare – Systemic Differences and Links Between Property, Land Rights and Housing Rights" 2015 PELJ 1035-1090

Viljoen 2014 TSAR Part 1
Viljoen S "The Temporary Expropriation of a Use Right as Interim Measure in the South African Housing Context (Part 1)" 2014 TSAR 359-376
Viljoen 2014 TSAR Part 2
Viljoen S "The Temporary Expropriation of a Use Right as Interim Measure in the South African Housing Context (Part 2)" 2014 TSAR 520-535
Waldron Right to Private Property
Waldron J The Right to Private Property (Oxford University Press New York 1988)

Case law
City of Johannesburg Metropolitcan Municipality v Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd 2011 4 SA 337 (SCA)
City of Johannesburg Metropolitan Municipality v Blue Moonlight Properties 39 (Pty) Ltd 2012 2 SA 104 (CC)
Kelo v City of New London 454 US 469 (2005)
Lester v Ndlambe Municipality 2014 1 All SA 402 (SCA)
Malan v City of Cape Town 2014 6 SA 315 (CC)
Miller v Schoene 276 US 272 (1928)
Nhlabathi v Fick 2003 ZALCC 9 (8 April 2003)
Occupiers of 51 Olivia Road, Berea Township and 197 Main Street Johannesburg v City of Johannesburg 2008 3 SA 208 (CC)
Poletown Neighborhood Council v City of Detroit 304 NW 2d 455 (1981)
Port Elizabeth Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)
President of the Republic of South Africa v Modderklip Boerdery (Pty) Ltd 2005 5 SA 3 (CC)

Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Expropriation Act 63 of 1975
Extension of Security of Tenure Act 62 of 1997
Housing Act 107 of 1997
Housing Development Agency Act 23 of 2008
Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998
Government publications
GN 1409 in GG 42127 of 21 December 2018 (Draft Expropriation Bill)

Internet sources
Mahlase and Madia 2018 https://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/
gauteng-prepares-to-expropriate-privately-owned-land-without-compensation-20180615
Mahlase M and Madia T 2018 "Gauteng Prepares to Expropriate Idle Privately Owned Land without Compensation" News 24 (15 June 2018) https://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/gauteng-prepares-to-expropriate-privately-owned-land-without-compensation-20180615 accessed 3 September 2018

Schreuder 2018 https://citizen.co.za/news/opinion/1990467/which-land-is-most-likely-to-be-expropriated-first/
Schreuder N 2018 "Which Land is Most Likely to be Expropriated First?" The Citizen (6 August 2018) https://citizen.co.za/news/opinion/
1990467/which-land-is-most-likely-to-be-expropriated-first/ accessed 4 September 2018
Views
  • Abstract 36
  • pdf 33
  • xml 9
  • epub 3
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-08-26
Section
Articles