The Effectiveness of Plea and Sentence Agreements in Environmental Enforcement in South Africa

Keywords: plea and sentence agreement, South Africa, environmental compliance, criminal sanctions, environmental penalties, Environmental law, compliance and enforcement

Abstract

A recent development in South African environmental law is the use of plea and sentencing agreements. The main objective of environmental law is to promote the sustainable use of natural resources while preventing pollution and ecological degradation. Grand environmental due diligence processes could achieve sustainable development; the use of criminal sanctions with sentencing agreements could be more effective. This paper answers the question whether the plea and sentencing agreements in reality achieve the objectives of environmental regulation? This study analyses this recent development by looking at selected recent cases in South Africa. The study found that plea and sentence agreements are potentially effective, subject to the effective monitoring of compliance and enforcement against non-compliance with the undertakings made by the accused person. Without institutional strengthening and effective monitoring, the plea and sentence agreement procedure remains ineffective.

Author Biography

Tumai Murombo, University of the Witwatersrand

Professor of Law

Faculty of Law

References

Abbot C "The Regulatory Enforcement of Pollution Control Laws: The Australian Experience" 2005 JEL 161-180
Bekker PM "Plea Bargaining in the United States of America and South Africa" 1996 CILSA 168-222
Bell FG and Donnelly LJ (eds) Mining and its Impact on the Environment (Taylor & Francis London 2006)
Billiet CM, Blondiau T and Rousseau S "Punishing Environmental Crimes: An Empirical Study from Lower Courts to the Court of Appeal" 2014 Regul Gov 472-496
Bodansky D The Art and Craft of International Environmental Law (Harvard University Press Cambridge Mass 2010)
Bridge G "Contested Terrain: Mining and the Environment" 2004 29 Annu Rev Environ Resour 205-259
Bridgewater P, Kim RE and Bosselmann K "Ecological Integrity: A Relevant Concept for International Environmental Law in the Anthropocene?" 2014 Yb Int'l Env L 61-78
Clarke CT "Message in a Bottle for Unknowing Defenders: Strategic Plea Negotiations Persist in South African Criminal Courts" 1999 CILSA 141-168
Costanza R et al "The Value of the World's Ecosystem Services and Natural Capital" in Newell P and Timmons Roberts J (eds) The Globalization and Environment Reader (Wiley Blackwell Hoboken NJ 2016) 117-133
Cronje F and Chenga CS "Sustainable Social Development in the South African Mining Sector" 2009 Dev South Afr 413-427
Du Plessis W and Nel JG "Driving Compliance to and Enforcement of South African Legislation by Means of a Hybrid of 'New' Environmental Governance Instruments" in Paddock L et al (eds) Compliance and Enforcement in Environmental Law: Toward More Effective Implementation (Edward Elgar Cheltenham 2011) 259-285
Farisani DM "Corporate Criminal Liability in South Africa: What does History Tell Us about the Reverse Onus Provision?" 2017 Fundamina 1-19
Faure MG "Balancing of Interests: Some Preliminary (Economic) Remarks" in Faure MG and Du Plessis W (eds) The Balancing of Interests in Environmental Law in Africa (PULP Pretoria 2011) 1-34
Faure MG and Du Plessis W "Comparative and Concluding Remarks" in Faure MG and Du Plessis W (eds) The Balancing of Interests in Environmental Law in Africa (PULP Pretoria 2011) 591-619
Faure MG et al (eds) Criminal Enforcement of Environmental Law in the European Union (Kluwer Law International The Hague 2005)
Fisse B and Braithwaite J Corporations, Crime and Accountability (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1993)
Franks DM, Brereton D and Moran CJ "Managing the Cumulative Impacts of Coal Mining on Regional Communities and Environments in Australia" 2010 IAPA 299-312
Glazewski J Environmental Law in South Africa 3rd ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2014)
Glazewski J "United States v Bengis: A Victory for Wildlife Law and Lessons for International Fisheries Crime" 2014 IJMCL 173-183
Hamann R "Corporate Social Responsibility, Partnerships, and Institutional Change: The Case of Mining Companies in South Africa" 2004 Nat Resour Forum 278-290
Hauck M and Kroese M "Fisheries Compliance in South Africa: A Decade of Challenges and Reform 1994-2004" 2006 Marine Policy 74-83
Helwege A "Challenges with Resolving Mining Conflicts in Latin America" 2015 The Extractive Industries and Society 73-84
Hilson G "An Overview of Land Use Conflicts in Mining Communities" 2002 Land Use Policy 65-73
Holder J and Lee M Environmental Protection, Law and Policy: Text and Materials (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2007)
Isakow D and Van Zyl Smit N "Negotiated Justice and the Legal Context" 1985 De Rebus 17
Isakow D, Van Zyl Smit N and Isakow N "The Decision on how to Plead: A Study of Plea Negotiation in Supreme Court Criminal Matters" 1986 SAJCC 3-20
Kidd M "Criminal Measures" in Paterson A and Kotzé LJ (eds) Environmental Compliance and Enforcement in South Africa: Legal Perspectives (Juta Cape Town 2009) 240-265
Kruger A Hiemstra's Criminal Procedure (LexisNexis Durban 2014)
Leggett T "The Sieve Effect: South Africa's Conviction Rates in Perspective" 2003 SACQ 11-14
Mares D "Criminalizing Ecological Harm: Crimes against Carrying Capacity and the Criminalization of Eco-sinners" 2010 Crit Criminol 279-293
Martín AM et al "The Relationship between Moral Judgments and Causal Explanations of Everyday Environmental Crimes" 2013 Soc Justice Res 320-342
McCarthy TS "The Impact of Acid Mine Drainage in South Africa" 2011 S Afr J Sci 1-7
McMurry RI and Ramsey SD "Environmental Crime: The Use of Criminal Sanctions in Enforcing Environmental Laws" 1986 Loy LA L Rev 1133-1169
Moomen AW "Strategies for Managing Large-Scale Mining Sector Land Use Conflicts in the Global South" 2017 Resources Policy 85-93
Mueller G "An Essay on Environmental Criminality" in Edwards SM, Edwards TD and Fields CB (eds) Environmental Crime and Criminality: Theoretical and Practical Issues (Routledge London 2013) ch 1
Nel JG and Wessels JA "How to Use Voluntary, Self-regulatory and Alternative Environmental Compliance Tools: Some Lessons Learnt" 2010 PELJ 48-78
Ochieng GM, Seanego ES and Nkwonta OI "Impacts of Mining on Water Resources in South Africa: A Review" 2010 Sci Res Essays 3351-3357
Oliver TH "How much Biodiversity Loss is too much?" 2016 Science 220-221
Patterson A "Incentive-based Measures" in Paterson A and Kotzé LJ (eds) Environmental Compliance and Enforcement in South Africa: Legal Perspectives (Juta Cape Town 2009) 296-335
Pelser E "How We really got it Wrong: Understanding the Failure of Crime Prevention" 2007 SACQ 1-5
Petrova S and Marinova D "Social Impacts of Mining: Changes within the Local Social Landscape" 2013 Rural Society 153-165
Pimentel D, Westra L and Noss RF "Ecological Integrity and the Aims of the Global Integrity Project" in Pimentel D, Westra L and Noss RF (eds) Ecological Integrity: Integrating Environment, Conservation, and Health (Island Press Washington DC 2000) 19-43
Preston BJ "Characteristics of Successful Environmental Courts and Tribunals" 2014 JEL 365-393
Pring GW and Pring C Greening Justice: Creating and Improving Environmental Courts and Tribunals (Access Initiative Washington DC 2009)
Pring GW and Pring C "Specialized Environmental Courts and Tribunals at the Confluence of Human Rights and the Environment" 2009 Or Rev Int'l L 301-329
Robinson A "Ensuring Access to Justice through Environmental Courts" 2012 Pace Envtl L Rev 363-395
Rousseau S and Blondiau T "Act‐based versus Harm‐based Sanctions for Environmental Offenders" 2014 Environ Policy Gov 439-454
Ruggiero V and South N "Green Criminology and Crimes of the Economy: Theory, Research and Praxis" 2013 Crit Criminol 359-373
Schröter M and Van Oudenhoven AP "Ecosystem Services Go Beyond Money and Markets: Reply to Silvertown" 2016 Trends Ecol Evol 333-334
Snyman CR Criminal Law 6th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths 2015)
Strock JM "Environmental Criminal Enforcement Priorities for the 1990's." 1990 Geo Wash L Rev 916-937
Wang C "A Comparative Analysis of Environmental Courts in Sweden and China" 2016 FJHSS 607-626
Watney M "Judicial Scrutiny of Plea and Sentence Agreements: Regspraak" 2006 TSAR 224-230
Wellsmith M "Wildlife crime: the problems of enforcement" 2011 Eur J Crim Policy Res 125-148
White R "Environmental Crime in Global Context: Exploring the Theoretical and Empirical Complexities" 2005 Curr Issues Crim Justice 271-285
White R "NGO Engagement in Environmental Law Enforcement: Critical Reflections" 2012 Australasian Policing 7-11
White R Crimes against Nature: Environmental Criminology and Ecological Justice (Routledge London 2013)
White R "Reparative Justice, Environmental Crime and Penalties for the Powerful" 2017 Crime Law Soc Change 117-132
Woodka JL "Sentencing the CEO: Personal Liability of Corporate Executives for Environmental Crimes" 1992 Tulane Envtl LJ 635-66
Bengis v Government of South Africa; In re: Bengis v Government of South Africa 2016 2 All SA 459 (WCC)
Jansen v The State 2015 ZASCA 151 (2 October 2015)
Minister of Water Affairs and Forestry v Stilfontein Gold Mining Co Ltd 2006 5 SA 333 (W)
North Western Dense Concrete CC v DPP, Western Cape 2000 2 SA 78 (C)
S v Acker (Hermanus Regional Court) (unreported) case number ECH 100/05 (October 2005)
S v Anker Coal and Mineral Holdings SA (Pty) Ltd (Ermelo Regional Court) (unreported) case number ESH 8/11 (undated)
S v Coetzee 1997 1 SACR 379 (CC)
S v Esterhuizen 2005 1 SACR 490 (T)
S v Golfview Mining (Pty) Ltd (Ermelo Regional Court) (unreported) case Number ESH 82/11 (undated)
S v Mellvile (Kirkwood) (unreported) case number A513/09 (undated)
S v Nkomati Anthracite (Pty) Ltd (Nelspruit Regional Court) (unreported) case number SH 412/13 (undated)
S v Samancor Chrome Ltd (unreported) case number SHL72/2012 (undated)
S v Solomons 2005 2 SACR 432 (C)
S v Vunene Mining (Pty) Ltd (Ermelo Regional Court) (unreported) case number 94/11/2010 (undated)
S v UNICA Iron Steel (Pty) Ltd (Temba, Hammanskraal) (unreported) case number 386/12/2013 (undated)
US v Bengis No 13-2543 (2d Cir 2015)
Companies Act 71 of 2008
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977
Environment Conservation Act 73 of 1989
Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act 28 of 2002
National Environmental Management Act 107 of 1998
National Environmental Management: Biodiversity Act 10 of 2004
National Water Act 36 of 1998
Lacey Act, 1900 (16 USC §§ 3371-3378)
Government publications
GN 1196 in GG 15832 of 8 July 1994
DEA EMI 2010 https://www.environment.gov.za/sites/default/
files/docs/necer2009_10report.pdf
Department of Environmental Affairs, Environmental Management Inspectorate 2010 The National Environmental Compliance and Enforcement Report 2009-10 https://www.environment.gov.za/sites/default/
files/docs/necer2009_10report.pdf accessed 12 August 2019
DEA EMI 2014 2013/14https://www.environment.gov.za/other
documents/reports#compliance2013_14
Department of Environmental Affairs, Environmental Management Inspectorate 2014 The National Environmental Compliance and Enforcement Report 2013/14 https://www.environment.gov.za/other
documents/reports#compliance2013_14 accessed 12 August 2019
DEA EMI 2017 https://cer.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/NECER-2016-17.pdf
Department of Environmental Affairs, Environmental Management Inspectorate 2017 The National Environmental Compliance and Enforcement Report 2016/17 https://cer.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/NECER-2016-17.pdf accessed 12 August 2019
Kings 2017 https://mg.co.za/article/2017-05-09-environmentalists-are-winning-the-battle-for-enforcement-of-the-law
Kings S 2017 Environmentalists are winning the Battle for Enforcement of the Law https://mg.co.za/article/2017-05-09-environmentalists-are-winning-the-battle-for-enforcement-of-the-law accessed 12 August 2019
Views
  • Abstract 54
  • pdf 43
  • xml 0
  • ePub 33
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-10-25
Section
Articles