The Application of International Human Rights Instruments in Outer Space Settlements: Today's Science Fiction, Tomorrow's Reality

Keywords: Commercial exploitation of outer space, outer space settlements, effective control in outer space, constitutions of outer space settlements, human rights issues in outer space, international human rights treaties in outer space

Abstract

The military and commercial exploitation of outer space has received increasing international attention since the United States of America announced its intention to establish an outer space military force to protect its interests in outer space. Simultaneously, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and private enterprises such as Blue Origin and SpaceX declared plans to colonise the Moon and/or Mars in the near future. While technology is advancing rapidly to make these objectives a reality, the international legal rules related to these developments are completely uncertain, and in some instances non-existent. It is evident that these developments may have a direct impact on the internationally protected human rights of individuals, taking into account the extremely adverse conditions in outer space and the dangers involved in creating sustainable human living conditions in outer space. International discussion of and action on these legal issues are needed urgently. As a starting point, this contribution discusses the question of whether existing international human rights instruments enjoy extra-territorial application in outer space, given the current status of outer space law. In answering the question, a broad overview is presented of some human rights issues that may be relevant to living in outer space, and the role that the doctrine of effective control may play in this regard is analysed.

 

GS3.png

Author Biographies

Anél Ferreira-Snyman, UNISA

*           Anel Ferreira-Snyman B Iuris, LLB (PUCHO), LLM (PUCHO), LLD (UJ). Professor of Law, College of Law, University  of South Africa, Pretoria, South Africa. E-mail: ferremp@unisa.ac.za

**          Gerrit Ferreira B Iuris, LLB (PUCHO), LLM (RAU), LLD (UNISA), LLD (PUCHO). Extraordinary Professor of          Law, North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa. E-mail: gerrit.ferreira@nwu.ac.za

Gerrit M Ferreira, North-West University

B Juris LLB (PU) LLD (Unisa) LLD (PU). Professor, Faculty of Law, North-West University, Potchefstroom, South Africa. Email: gerrit.ferreira@nwu.ac.za.

References

Bibliography

Literature

Abul Failat and Ferreira-Snyman "Regulation of the Space Tourism Sector"
Abul Failat Y and Ferreira-Snyman A "Regulation of the Space Tourism Sector" in Abul Failat Y and Ferreira-Snyman A (eds) Outer Space Law: Legal Practice and Policy (Globe Law and Business London 2017) 203-242

Barbree Neil Armstrong
Barbree J Neil Armstrong: A Life of Flight (St Martin's Press New York 2014)

Bhatt "Constituting Outer Space"
Bhatt M "Constituting Outer Space: The Governance of Planetary Settlements and Artificial Habitats" in Cockell CS (ed) Human Governance beyond Earth: Implications for Freedom (Springer Heidelberg 2015) 149-171

Cassese 2007 EJIL
Cassese A "The Nicaragua and Tadić Tests Revisited in Light of the ICJ Judgment on Genocide in Bosnia" 2007 EJIL 649-668

Christol "Human Rights in Outer Space"
Christol CQ "Human Rights in Outer Space" Conference paper delivered at the Impact of Aerospace Science and Technology on Law and Government Conference (1968 Washington DC)

Cockell 2008 J Br Interplanet Soc
Cockell CS "An Essay on Extraterrestrial Liberty" 2008 J Br Interplanet Soc 255-275

Cockell 2009 J Br Interplanet Soc
Cockell CS "Liberty and the Limits to the Extraterrestrial State" 2009 J Br Interplanet Soc 139-157

Cockell "Freedom in a Box"
Cockell CS "Freedom in a Box: Paradoxes in the Structure of Extraterrestrial Liberty" in Cockell CS (ed) The Meaning of Liberty beyond Earth (Springer Heidelberg 2014) 47-68

Craig 2007 ND L Rev
Craig B "Online Satellite and Aerial Images: Issues and Analysis" 2007 ND L Rev 547-578

Crawford "Interplanetary Federalism"
Crawford IA "Interplanetary Federalism: Maximising the Chances of Extraterrestrial Peace, Diversity and Liberty" in Cockell CS (ed) The Meaning of Liberty beyond Earth (Springer Heidelberg 2014) 199-218

De Man "Exploitation of Natural Resources in Outer Space"
De Man P "The Exploitation of Natural Resources in Outer Space" in Abul Failat Y and Ferreira-Snyman A (eds) Outer Space Law: Legal Practice and Policy (Globe Law and Business London 2017) 243-255

Dugard International Law
Dugard J International Law: A South African Perspective 4th ed (Juta Cape Town 2011)

Erlank "Property and Ownership in Outer Space"
Erlank W "Property and Ownership in Outer Space" in Abul Failat Y and Ferreira-Snyman A (eds) Outer Space Law: Legal Practice and Policy (Globe Law and Business London 2017) 55-94

Ferraro 2012 IRRC
Ferraro T "Determining the Beginning and End of an Occupation under International Humanitarian Law" 2012 IRRC 142-143

Ferreira-Snyman "Environmental Responsibility for Space Debris"
Ferreira-Snyman A "Environmental Responsibility for Space Debris" in Abul Failat Y and Ferreira-Snyman A (eds) Outer Space Law: Legal Practice and Policy (Globe Law and Business London 2017) 257-283

Ferreira-Snyman "Military Activities in Outer Space"
Ferreira-Snyman A "Military Activities in Outer Space" in Abul Failat Y and Ferreira-Snyman A (eds) Outer Space Law: Legal Practice and Policy (Globe Law and Business London 2017) 95-118

Finck 2016 Polish YB Int'l L
Finck F "The State Between Fact and Law: The Role of Recognition and the Conditions under which it is Granted in the Creation of New States" 2016 Polish YB Int'l L 51-81

Galea Artificial Islands in the Law of the Sea
Galea F Artificial Islands in the Law of the Sea (LLD-Dissertation University of Malta 2009)

Jacobini 1958 J Pub L
Jacobini HB "Effective Control as Related to the Extension of Sovereignty in Space" 1958 J Pub L 97-119

Masson-Zwaan "Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty"
Masson-Zwaan T "Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty and Private Human Access to Space" Proceedings of the International Institute of Space Law: 51st Colloquium on the Law of Outer Space (2008) 536-546

Mnyongani Accountability of Multinational Corporations
Mnyongani FD Accountability of Multinational Corporations for Human Rights Violations under International Law (LLD-Dissertation University of South Africa 2016)

Musk 2017 New Space
Musk E "Making Humans a Multi-Planetary Species" 2017 New Space 46-71

Pletser On to Mars!
Pletser V On to Mars! Chronicles of Martian Simulations (Springer Singapore 2018)

Presson "Citizens of Mars Ltd"
Presson E "Citizens of Mars Ltd" in Cockell CS (ed) Human Governance beyond Earth: Implications for Freedom (Springer Heidelberg 2015) 121-137

Sgrosso International Space Law
Sgrosso GC International Space Law (LoGisma Editore Italy 2011)

Tronchetti "Soft Law"
Tronchetti F "Soft Law" in Brünner C and Soucek A (eds) Outer Space in Society, Politics and Law (Springer New York 2011) 619-637

Tzevelekos 2014 Mich J Int'l L
Tzevelekos VP "Reconstructing the Effective Control Criterion in Extraterritorial Human Rights Breaches: Direct Attribution of Wrongfulness, Due Diligence, and Concurrent Responsibility" 2014 Mich J Int'l L 129-178

Wilde "Human Rights beyond Borders at the World Court"
Wilde R "Human Rights beyond Borders at the World Court" in Chinkin C and Baetens F (eds) Sovereignty, Statehood and State Responsibility: Essays in Honour of James Crawford (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2015) 51-70

Wylie "Human Space Colonies"
Wylie R "Human Space Colonies: Towards a Governance Architecture" in Cockell CS (ed) Human Governance beyond Earth: Implications for Freedom (Springer Heidelberg 2015) 251-266

Case law
Al-Skeini v The United Kingdom, Application 55721/07, ECtHR (GC), Judgement, 7 July 2011
Bankovic v Belgium, Application 52207/99, ECtHR (GC), Judgement, 12 December 2001
Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Co Ltd (Belgium v Spain) 1970 ICJ Reports 3
Case Concerning Application of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (Georgia v Russian Federation) Request for the Indication of Provisional Measures, 15 October 2008
Case Concerning Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (Democratic Republic of the Congo v Uganda), Judgement, 19 December 2005, 2005 ICJ Reports 168
Legal Consequences of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South-West Africa) notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276, Advisory Opinion, 21 June 1971, 1971 ICJ Reports 16
Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, Advisory Opinion, 9 July 2004, 2004 ICJ Reports 136

International instruments
Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (1984)
Convention on Registration of Objects Launched into Outer Space (1975)
Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989)
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966)
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (1966)
International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (1965)
International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (1979)
International Law Commission's Draft Articles on the Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (2001)
International Law Commission's Draft Articles on the Responsibility of International Organizations (2011)
Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, Including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies (1967)
United Nations Population Fund Human Rights Principles (2005)
United Nations Human Rights Committee General Comment No 31, UN Doc CCPR/C/21/Rev.1/Add.13 (2004)
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)
Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action (1993)
Vienna Declaration on the Law of Treaties (1969)

Internet sources
Amos 2018 https://www,bbc.com/news/science-environment-42808180
Amos J 2018 "'Disco Ball' Put into Space from NZ" BBC News (Science and Environment) (24 January 2018) https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-42808180 accessed 20 April 2018

Asgardia Date unknown https://asgardia.space/assets/doc/constitution/
english.pdf
Asgardia Date unknown Constitution of the Space Kingdom of Asgardia https://asgardia.space/assets/doc/constitution/english.pdf accessed 2 July 2018

Asgardia 2018 https://asgardia.space/en/
Asgardia 2018 Asgardia: The Space Nation https://asgardia.space/en/ accessed 30 August 2018

Asgardia 2018 https://asgardia.space/storage/page/publication/attach/
a5/97/a597b4fdd6dc1d352c3f4a6fdbf6c4a83f93523329dd2ea8857c5528c87e7835.pdf
Asgardia 2018 Citizenship Law (Adopted at the First Session of the Parliament of Asgardia on 07 Asgard 0002 (24 June 2018), Vienna) https://asgardia.space/storage/page/publication/attach/a5/97/a597b4fdd6dc1d352c3f4a6fdbf6c4a83f93523329dd2ea8857c5528c87e7835.pdf accessed 6 May 2019

Bennett 2018 https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/moon-mars/a18345717/nasa-ntp-nuclear-engines-mars/
Bennett J 2018 "NASA's Nuclear Thermal Engine is a Blast from the Cold War Past" Popular Mechanics (21 February 2018) https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/moon-mars/a18345717/nasa-ntp-nuclear-engines-mars/ accessed 3 May 2018

Bharmal 2018 https://www.theguardian.com/science/blog/2018/aug/28/the-case-against-mars-colonisation
Bharmal Z 2018 "The Case against Mars Colonisation" The Guardian (28 August 2018) https://www.theguardian.com/science/blog/2018/aug/28/the-case-against-mars-colonisation accessed 1 October 2018

British Interplanetary Society 2019 https://www.bis-space.com
British Interplanetary Society 2019 Home Page https://www.bis-space.com accessed 2 June 2019

Brown 2019 https://www.inverse.com/article/55060-a-mars-colony-could-be-humanity-s-best-shot-at-a-purely-designed-economy
Brown M 2019 "A Mars Colony could be Humanity's First Shot at a Ground-Up, Pure Economy" https://www.inverse.com/article/55060-a-mars-colony-could-be-humanity-s-best-shot-at-a-purely-designed-economy accessed 10 May 2019

Clark 2018 https://spaceflightnow.com/2018/12/13/virgin-galactic-test-flight/
Clark S 2018 "Virgin Galactic Accomplishes Milestone Flight to the Edge of Space" SPACEFLIGHT NOW (17 December 2018) https://spaceflightnow.com/2018/12/13/virgin-galactic-test-flight/ accessed 17 December 2018

Clifford 2018 https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/02/elon-musk-defends-plans-to-build-community-on-mars-after-nasa-report.html
Clifford C 2018 "Elon Musk Defends Plans to Build a Community on Mars after Downbeat NASA Report" CNBC Make It (Entrepreneurs) (2 August 2018) https://www.cnbc.com/2018/08/02/elon-musk-defends-plans-to-build-community-on-mars-after-nasa-report.html accessed 3 August 2018

De Hoon Date unknown https://www.nomoretax.eu/living-in-international-waters-endless-adventure-without-taxes/
De Hoon I Date unknown Living in International Waters: Endless Adventure without Taxes https://www.nomoretax.eu/living-in-international-waters-endless-adventure-without-taxes/ accessed 10 May 2019

Dormehl 2018 https://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/space-champagne-zero-gravity/
Dormehl L 2018 "'Zero Gravity' Champagne Bottle Lets You Celebrate in Outer Space" Digital Trends (Emerging Tech) (12 June 2018) https://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/space-champagne-zero-gravity/ accessed 22 June 2018

Dowding 2015 https://yourrightsmatter.wixsite.com/home/single-post/2015/11/27/Extra-Terrestrial-Application-of-Human-Rights?fbclid=IwAR37Xx8CzJzrcKt2_23ZC6Ev3fPOnmyA-QY3Lon8JOxtrcm3xO3WgdqLv7E
Dowding R 2015 Extra-Terrestrial Application of Human Rights https://yourrightsmatter.wixsite.com/home/single-post/2015/11/27/Extra-Terrestrial-Application-of-Human-Rights?fbclid=IwAR37Xx8CzJzrcKt2_23ZC6Ev3fPOnmyA-QY3Lon8JOxtrcm3xO3WgdqLv7E accessed 2 May 2018

Drake 2018 https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/we-need-to-change-way-we-talk-about-space-exploration-mars/
Drake N 2018 We Need to Change the Way We Talk about Space Exploration https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/11/we-need-to-change-way-we-talk-about-space-exploration-mars/ accessed 12 November 2018

Dunn 2018 https://phys.org/news/2018-02-space-sports-car-asteroid-belt.html
Dunn M 2018 "Space Sports Car Now Flying toward Asteroid Belt beyond Mars" Phys Org (7 February 2018) https://phys.org/news/2018-02-space-sports-car-asteroid-belt.html accessed 20 April 2018

Ecott 2018 https://www.nowscience.co.uk/single-post/2018/06/01/Jeff-Bezos-says-BlueOrigin%E2%80%99s-Moon-colony-for-human-settlers-and-heavy-industry-will be built-within-decades
Ecott K "Jeff Bezos Says Blue Origin's Moon Colony for Human Settlers and Heavy Industry will be Built within Decades" Now Science (1 June 2018) https://www.nowscience.co.uk/single-post/2018/06/01/Jeff-Bezos-says-BlueOrigin%E2%80%99s-Moon-colony-for-human-settlers-and-heavy-industry-will be built-within-decades accessed 1 October 2018

Erwin 2018 https://spacenews.com/president-trump-issues-order-to-create-u-s-space-command/
Erwin S 2018 "President Trump Issues Order to Create US Space Command" SPACENEWS (18 December 2018) https://spacenews.com/president-trump-issues-order-to-create-u-s-space-command/ accessed 19 December 2018

Foust 2018 https://spacenews.com/virgin-galactic-achieves-space-on-spaceshiptwo-test-flight/
Foust J "Virgin Galactic Achieves Space on SpaceShipTwo Test Flight" SPACENEWS (13 December 2018) https://spacenews.com/virgin-galactic-achieves-space-on-spaceshiptwo-test-flight/ accessed 15 December 2018

Garber 2012 https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/12/the-trash-weve-left-on-the-moon/266465/
Garber M 2012 "The Trash We've Left on the Moon" The Atlantic (19 December 2012) https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/
archive/2012/12/the-trash-weve-left-on-the-moon/266465/ accessed 20 April 2018

Harwood 2018 https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-space-force-pentagon-create-military-space-force-national-space-council-meeting-2018-06-18/
Harwood W 2018 "Trump Directs Pentagon to Create Military Space Force" CBS News (18 June 2018) https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-space-force-pentagon-create-military-space-force-national-space-council-meeting-2018-06-18/ accessed 22 June 2018

Hikmah 2018 http://www.unoosa.org/documents/doc/psa/activities/
2018/hsti_expert_meeting_vienna/Presentations/Session4_12_Barikatul_Hikmah.pdf
Hikmah B 2018 Multi-Planetary Human Rights Protection - Speech Delivered on 6 December 2018 at the United Nations Expert Meeting on Human Space Technology held by the United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs http://www.unoosa.org/documents/doc/psa/activities/
2018/hsti_expert_meeting_vienna/Presentations/Session4_12_Barikatul_Hikmah.pdf accessed 10 May 2019

Hollingham 2014 http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20140709-why-mars-needs-a-bill-of-rights
Hollingham R 2014 "How to Create a Bill of Rights for Mars Colonies" BBC Future (9 July 2014) http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20140709-why-mars-needs-a-bill-of-rights accessed 11 May 2018

IANS 2018 https://www.financialexpress.com/industry/nasas-portable-nuclear-reactor-could-power-missions-to-mars/1154206/
IANS 2018 "NASA's Portable Nuclear Reactor could Power Missions to Mars" Financial Express (3 May 2018) https://www.financialexpress.com/industry/nasas-portable-nuclear-reactor-could-power-missions-to-mars/1154206/ accessed 3 May 2018

Knapton 2018 https://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2018/08/30/
international-space-station-leaking-air-hit-space-debris/
Knapton S 2018 "International Space Station Astronauts Plug Leak with Finger and Tape after being Hit with Debris" The Telegraph (News Science) (31 August 2018) https://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2018/08/30/
international-space-station-leaking-air-hit-space-debris/ accessed 3 September 2018

Li 2019 https://theconversation.com/india-destroys-its-own-satellite-with-a-test-missile-still-says-space-is-for-peace-114441
Li B 2019 India Destroys its own Satellite with a Test Missile, Still Says Space is for Peace https://theconversation.com/india-destroys-its-own-satellite-with-a-test-missile-still-says-space-is-for-peace-114441 accessed 6 May 2019

Mosher 2018 https://www.businessinsider.co.za/spacex-big-falcon-rocket-spaceship-hopper-vehicle-launches-2018-12
Mosher D 2018 SpaceX is Building a 'Test Hopper' Mars Spaceship in Texas – and Elon Musk Says it Could Launch by March https://www.businessinsider.co.za/spacex-big-falcon-rocket-spaceship-hopper-vehicle-launches-2018-12 accessed 27 December 2018

Mosher 2018 https://www.businessinsider.com.au/spacex-meeting-mars-mission-planning-workshop-2018-8
Mosher D 2018 SpaceX is Quietly Planning Mars-landing Missions with the Help of NASA and other Space Flight Experts. It's About Time https://www.businessinsider.com.au/spacex-meeting-mars-mission-planning-workshop-2018-8 accessed 13 August 2018

NASA 2019 https://www.nasa.gov/topics/moon-to-mars/overview
NASA 2019 Moon to Mars Overview https://www.nasa.gov/topics/moon-to-mars/overview accessed 1 October 2018

Pultarova 2018 https://www.space.com/41897-satellite-fires-net-to-catch-space-junk.html
Pultarova T 2018 Watch a Satellite Net a Cubesat in Awesome Space Junk Cleanup Test https://www.space.com/41897-satellite-fires-net-to-catch-space-junk.html accessed 3 October 2018

Robinson 2018 https://www.businessinsider.co.za/elon-musk-colonization-of-mars-sxsw-2018-3?r=US&IR=T
Robinson M 2018 Elon Musk Wants to Colonise Mars with SpaceX – but it won't be an Escape Hatch for Rich People https://www.businessinsider.co.za/elon-musk-colonization-of-mars-sxsw-2018-3?r=US&IR=T accessed 1 October 2018

Robson 2014 http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20141002-time-to-plan-a-space-colony
Robson D 2014 "The Expert Guide to Space Colonies" BBC Future (2 October 2014) http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20141002-time-to-plan-a-space-colony accessed 11 May 2018

Sampathkumar 2018 https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/
woman-sue-nasa-neil-armstrong-moon-dust-laura-murray-tennessee-a8396176.html
Sampathkumar M 2018 "Woman Sues Nasa for Right to Own Moon Dust 'Given to Her by Neil Armstrong'" The Independent (12 June 2018) https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/woman-sue-nasa-neil-armstrong-moon-dust-laura-murray-tennessee-a8396176.html accessed 22 June 2018

Seligman 2018 https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/08/10/space-force-is-trumps-answer-to-new-russian-and-chinese-weapons/
Seligman L 2018 Space Force is Trump's Answer to New Russian and Chinese Weapons https://foreignpolicy.com/2018/08/10/space-force-is-trumps-answer-to-new-russian-and-chinese-weapons/ accessed 13 August 2018

Stubbe Gelineck 2016 https://www.ibfd.org/sites/ibfd.org/files/content/pdf/
bit_2016_04_int_3.pdf
Stubbe Gelineck M 2016 Permanent Establishments and the Offshore Oil and Gas Industry – Part I https://www.ibfd.org/
sites/ibfd.org/files/content/pdf/bit_2016_04_int_3.pdf accessed 10 May 2019

Space Settlement Institute 2019 http://www.space-settlement-institute.org/article-vi-of-the-outer-space-treaty.html
Space Settlement Institute 2019 FAQ#38: Would Article VI of the Outer Space Treaty Prohibit Lunar Land Claims Recognition? http://www.space-settlement-institute.org/article-vi-of-the-outer-space-treaty.html accessed 10 May 2019

Wall 2016 http://www.space.com/34377-private-space-stations-may-take-flight-in-2020.html
Wall M 2016 Private Space Stations May Take Flight in 2020 http://www.space.com/34377-private-space-stations-may-take-flight-in-2020.html accessed 26 May 2018

Watson 2018 https://www.forbes.com/sites/patrickwwatson/
2018/04/26/this-is-the-end-of-privacy-as-we-know-it/#362c27c76875
Watson PW 2018 This is the End of Privacy as We Know It https://www.forbes.com/sites/patrickwwatson/2018/04/26/this-is-the-end-of-privacy-as-we-know-it/#362c27c76875 accessed 11 July 2018
Views
  • Abstract 115
  • Pdf 126
  • Xml 3
  • epub 3
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-06-25
Section
Articles