Deciphering Dangerousness: A Critical Analysis of Section 286A and B of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977

Keywords: dangerous criminals, crime, discretion, preventative detention, indeterminate sentence, Canadian Criminal Code, Criminal Procedure Act, fair trial, constitutionality, psychiatric enquiry, community safety, under-utilised

Abstract

The violent nature of some crimes and the high crime rate in South Africa reflect the fact that some offenders constitute a real threat to the security of communities. It is understandable, therefore, that the state seeks to protect its citizens through preventive measures. Although South Africa has certain legal provisions on its statutory books, it seems that the declaration of persons as dangerous criminals is under-utilised. South African legislation dealing with the declaration of dangerous criminals can be improved by borrowing some traits of the Canadian legislation. Such features include the restriction of courts' discretion and the provision of concrete and more detailed guidelines on the nature of the offences for which the provision can be applied. The courts could also take into account the type of criminal history of the offender which would merit the declaration of a dangerous criminal. It is also important that the extent of the violence in an offence should be thoroughly defined in court. Courts need to balance their wide discretion on the matter with the provisions in the Act in order to protect the community against dangerous criminals.

Author Biographies

Windell Nortje, Dr, University of the Western Cape

Dr Windell Nortje

Associate Lecturer

Foundation Programme

Faculty of Law

University of the Western Cape

 

Abraham Hamman, Dr, Senior Lecturer, University of the Western Cape

Senior Lecturer, Law Faculty, University of the Western Cape

 

Department Criminal Justice and Procedure

Chesne Albertus, Dr, Senior Lecturer

Senior Lecturer

Department Criminal Justice and Procedure, Law Faculty, University of the Western Cape

References

Literature

Cohen "Risk Assessment"
Cohen A "Risk Assessment" in Tredoux C et al (eds) Psychology and Law (Juta Cape Town 2005) 254-286

Du Toit et al Commentary on the Criminal Procedure Act
Du Toit E et al Commentary on the Criminal Procedure Act - Volume 2 (Juta Cape Town 2015)

Elias 2009 Colum Hum Rts L Rev
Elias SB "Rethinking 'Preventive Detention' from a Comparative Perspective: Three Frameworks for Detaining Terrorist Suspects" 2009 Colum Hum Rts L Rev 99-234

Jackson 1997 FSR
Jackson M "The Sentencing of Dangerous and Habitual Offenders in Canada" 1997 FSR 256-261

Kemp et al Criminal Procedure Casebook
Kemp G et al Criminal Procedure Casebook 2nd ed (Juta Cape Town 2017)

Lafond 2005 Dalhousie J Legal Stud
Lafond M "Disorder in Court: The Use of Psychiatric Testimony in the Prediction of Dangerousness" 2005
Dalhousie J Legal Stud 1-34

Petrunik 2002 IJOTCC
Petrunik MG "Managing Unacceptable Risk: Sex Offenders, Community Response, and Social Policy in the United States and Canada" 2002 IJOTCC 483-511

Snyman Criminal Law
Snyman CR Criminal Law 6th ed (LexisNexis Butterworths Durban 2014)

Stevens 2008 De Jure
Stevens P "Where Two Oceans Meet: Reflections on the Interaction between Law and Psychiatry in the Prediction of Future Dangerousness in Dangerous Criminals" 2008 De Jure 332-351

Terblanche Guide to Sentencing
Terblanche SS A Guide to Sentencing in South Africa 3rd ed (LexisNexis Durban 2016)

Zabow and Cohen 1993 Medicine and Law
Zabow T and Cohen A "South African Psychiatrists' Criteria for Predicting Dangerousness" 1993 Medicine and Law 417-430

Case law
Moetjie v S 2009 1 SACR 95 (T)
R v Blanchard 2018 ABQB 205
R v Johnson 2003 SCC 46
R v Lyons 1987 2 SCR 309
R v Steele 2014 SCC 61
R v Swarts 1953 4 SA 461 (A)
S v Bashford 2015 ZAGPPHC 146 (13 March 2015)
S v Bull; S v Chavulla 2001 2 SACR 681 (SCA)
S v Chimboza (WCC) (unreported) case number SS61/2014 of 29 April 2015
S v Dzukuda 2000 2 SACR 443 (CC)
S v Makoula 1978 4 SA 763 (SWA)
S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)
S v Moloi 1987 1 SA 196 (A)
S v T 1997 1 SACR 496 (SCA)
Legislation
Canadian Criminal Code 16 of 1985
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Correctional Services Act 111 of 2008
Criminal Matters Amendment Act 116 of 1993
Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977
Government publication
Gen N 49 of GG 14517 of 15 January 1993

Internet sources
Crime Stats South Africa 2018 http://www.crimestatssa.com/national.php
Crime Stats South Africa 2018 Crime Stats Simplified http://www.crimestatssa.com/national.php accessed 14 January 2019
Public Safety Canada 2009 https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/2009-pcmg/2009-pcmg-eng.pdf
Public Safety Canada 2009 The Investigation, Prosecution and Correctional Management of High Risk Offenders: A National Guide https://www.publicsafety.gc.ca/cnt/rsrcs/pblctns/2009-pcmg/2009-pcmg-eng.pdf accessed 29 June 2019
NICRO 2014 http://press.nicro.org.za/images/PDF/Public-Education-Paper-The-State-of-South-African-Prisons-2014.pdf
National Institute for Crime Prevention and the Reintegration of Offenders 2014 The State of South African Prisons: Edition One, NICRO Public Education Series http://press.nicro.org.za/images/PDF/Public-Education-Paper-The-State-of-South-African-Prisons-2014.pdf accessed 31 July 2018
Ulrich 2016 https://www.uvic.ca/law/assets/docs/crimlawpapers/Ulrich,%20Lara%20-%20Dangerous%20Offender%20Proceedings%20the%20Relevance%20of%20Gladue%20and%20Possible%20Charter%20Challenges.pdf
Ulrich L 2016 Dangerous Offender Proceedings: The Relevance of Gladue and Possible Charter Challenges https://www.uvic.ca/law/assets/docs/crimlawpapers/Ulrich,%20Lara%20-%20Dangerous%20Offender%20Proceedings%20the%20Relevance%20of%20Gladue%20and%20Possible%20Charter%20Challenges.pdf accessed August 2018
Valiquet 2008 https://lop.parl.ca/content/lop/ResearchPublications/prb0613-e.htm
Valiquet D 2008 The Dangerous Offender and Long-term Offender Regime https://lop.parl.ca/content/lop/ResearchPublications/prb0613-e.htm accessed 10 August 2018

List of Abbreviations
Colum Hum Rts L Rev Columbia Human Rights Law Review
Dalhousie J Legal Stud Dalhousie Journal of Legal Studies
FSR Federal Sentencing Reporter
IJOTCC International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology
NICRO National Institute for Crime Prevention and the Reintegration of Offenders
SCA Supreme Court of Appeal
Views
  • Abstract 37
  • pdf 27
  • xml 2
  • epub 52
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-10-11
Section
Articles