The Ratification of Inadequate Surrogate Motherhood Agreements and the Best Interest of the Child

Keywords: Surrogate motherhood agreement, best interest of the child, child, confirmation, ratification

Abstract

South Africa has developed domestic legislation governing all surrogacy matters within the country. These provisions are contained in Chapter 19 of the Children's Act 38 of 2005.

In Ex parte MS; In re: Confirmation of Surrogate Motherhood Agreement 2014 2 All SA 312 (GNP), the commissioning parents did not adhere to the requirement provided by Chapter 19. The parties to the (initially informal) surrogacy agreement authorised the artificial fertilisation of the surrogate mother prior to the confirmation of the surrogate motherhood agreement by the court. In considering the best interest of the resultant child, the High Court decided to ratify the inadequate surrogate motherhood agreement.

This discussion aims to establish whether the court's judgement in Ex parte MS; In re: Confirmation of Surrogate Motherhood Agreement 2014 2 All SA 312 (GNP) was in accordance with the provisions of current legislation and case law. It furthermore aims to answer two primary questions: firstly, whether adjudicators should make use of the best interest of the child when ratifying inadequate surrogate motherhood agreements; and secondly, in what manner the court should go about implementing the best interest of the child when validating inadequate surrogate motherhood agreements.

It is submitted that courts should refrain from applying the best interest of the child as a constitutional right in inadequate surrogacy matters where the child is yet to be born alive, in accordance with the Digesta Texts. Parties to the invalid agreement should rather be instructed to make use of a section 22 parental responsibilities and rights agreement, a section 28 termination agreement, or adoption as provided for by chapter 15 of the Children's Act.

 

Google_Scholar96.png

References

BIBLIOGRAPHY
Literature
Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 6th ed (Juta Cape Town 2013)

Louw 2013 THRHR
Louw A "Surrogacy in South Africa: Should we Reconsider the Current Approach?" 2013 THRHR 564-588

Louw 2014 De Jure
Louw A "Ex Parte MS 2014 JDR 0102 Case No 48856/2010 (GNP): Surrogate Motherhood Agreements, Condonation of Non-compliance with Confirmation Requirements and the Best Interest of the Child" 2014 De Jure 110-118

Skelton "Constitutional Protection of Children's Rights"
Skelton A "Constitutional Protection of Children's Rights" in Boezaart T (ed) et al Child Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2013) 265-290

Smit et al Surrogacy in the UK
Smit N et al Surrogacy in the UK: Myth Busting and Reform - Report of the Surrogacy UK Working Group on Surrogacy Law Reform (Kent Law School Canterbury 2015)

Case law
A & B (No 2 - Parental Order) 2015 EWHC 2080
AB v Minister of Social Development as Amicus Curiae: Centre for Child Law 2015 4 All SA 24 (GP)
Centre for Child Law v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development (National Institution for Crime Prevention and Reintegration of Offenders as Amicus Curiae) 2009 2 SACR 477 (CC)
D and L (Surrogacy) 2012 EWHC 2631
De Reuck v Director of Public Prosecutions (Witwatersrand Local Division) 2004 1 SA 406 (CC)
Ex parte Application WH 2011 4 SA 630 (GNP)
Ex parte: HPP; Ex parte: DME 2017 JOL 37415 (GP)
Ex parte MS; In re: Confirmation of Surrogate Motherhood Agreement 2014 2 All SA 312 (GNP)
Re X and Y (Foreign Surrogacy) 2008 EWHC 3030
Re Z (A Child: Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act: Parental Order) 2015 EWFC 73
S v M (Centre for Child Law as Amicus Curiae) 2008 3 SA 232 (CC)
X (A Child) (Surrogacy: Time Limit) 2014 EWHC 3135

Legislation
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Children's Act 38 of 2005
Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Act 92 of 1996
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act, 2008
Human Fertilisation and Embryology (Parental Order) Regulations, 2010
Human Rights Act, 1998

International instruments
United Nations Convention of the Rights of Children (1989)

Internet sources
Brunet et al 2012 http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/51063/1/__libfile_REPOSITORY_Content_Davaki%2C%20K_Comparative%20study%20regime%20surrogacy_Davaki_Comparative_study_regime_surrogacy_2013.pdf
Brunet L et al 2012 Comparative Study on the Regime of Surrogacy in the EU Member States http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/51063/1/__libfile_REPOSITORY_Content_Davaki%2C%20K_Comparative%20study%20regime%20surrogacy_Davaki_Comparative_study_regime_surrogacy_2013.pdf accessed 6 July 2016

CRC 2013 http://www2.ohchr.org/English/bodies/crc/docs/GC/CRC_C_GC_14_ENG.pdf
Committee on the Rights of Children 2013 General Comment No 14 (2013) on the Right of the Child to have his or her Best Interests Taken as a Primary Consideration (art 3, para 1) http://www2.ohchr.org/English/bodies/crc/docs/GC/CRC_C_GC_14_ENG.pdfaccessed 13 November 2015
Ratzinger and Bovone 1987 http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19870222_respect-for-human-life_en.html

Ratzinger J and Bovone A 1987 Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith: Instruction on Respect for Human Life in its Origin and on the Dignity of Procreation Replies to Certain Questions of the Day http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19870222_respect-for-human-life_en.html accessed 18 September 2016
Views
  • Abstract 149
  • pdf 189
  • xml 8
  • ePub 6
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-05-21
Section
Articles