Exploring Childhood Statelessness in South Africa

Keywords: Children, Statelessness, birth registration, South Africa, doctrinal, juridical

Abstract

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees set a
10-year timeline in 2014 to prevent childhood statelessness and believes this is possible if the following four steps are taken. First, it urges all states to allow children who would otherwise be stateless to gain nationality in the country where they are born. Secondly, it urges states to reform citizenship laws that discriminate on the ground of gender, so that mothers are able to pass nationality on to their children on an equal basis as fathers. Thirdly, it calls for the elimination of laws and practices that deny children nationality because of their ethnicity, race, or religion. Lastly, and most importantly, it calls on states to ensure universal birth registration to prevent statelessness. The specific focus of this article will be to examine the risk of childhood statelessness in South Africa. It will begin by providing an explanation of statelessness, followed by the causes and consequences of statelessness. It will briefly comment on the two Statelessness Conventions and examine the extent to which the right to nationality in international human rights laws can protect the stateless child. South Africa has not ratified either of the two Conventions on statelessness, but it believes its citizenship laws are sufficient to prevent childhood statelessness. This article aims to interrogate whether South Africa's laws can protect children at risk of being born stateless and provide adequate solutions to this problem. Through this analysis, the four steps identified by the UNHCR to prevent statelessness will be tested against South African law. This article utilises a child-centred approach, viewing children as beings with rights and not merely as objects of protection, as with the State-centred approach.

scholar_logo_64dp2.png

References

Literature

Aird S, Harnett H and Shah P Stateless Children: Youth Who Are Without Citizenship (Youth Advocate Program International Washington DC 2002)

Archard DW "Children's Rights" in Zalta EN (ed) The Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy (Summer 2016 Ed) (Metaphysics Research Lab Stanford University 2016)

Bequele A "Universal Birth Registration: The Challenge in Africa" A paper prepared for the Second Eastern and Southern Conference on Universal Birth Registration (26-30 September 2005 Mombasa)

Fokala E and Chenwi L "Statelessness and Rights: Protecting the Rights of Nubian Children in Kenya through the African Children's Committee" 2013 AJLS 357-373

Foster M and Lambert H "Statelessness as a Human Rights Issue: A Concept whose Time has Come" 2016 IJRL 564-584

Goodwin-Gill GS "The Rights of Refugees and Stateless Persons" in Saksena KP (ed) Human Rights Perspective and Challenges: In 1990 and Beyond (Lancers Books New Delhi 1994) 378-401

Gyulai G Statelessness in Hungary: The Protection of Statelessness Persons and the Prevention and Reduction of Statelessness (Hungarian Helsinki Committee Budapest 2010)

Human S "The Theory of Children's Rights" in Davel CJ (ed) Introduction to Child Law in South Africa (Juta Law Cape Town 2000) 150-165

Khan F "Citizenship in South Africa" in Khan F (ed) Immigration Law in South Africa (Juta Cape Town 2018) 129-148

Klaaren J "Constitutional Citizenship in South Africa" 2010 ICON 94-110

Liefaard T and Sloth-Nielsen J The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child - Taking Stock after 25 Years and Looking Ahead (Brill Nijhoff Leiden 2016)

Manby B Citizenship Law in Africa: A Comparative Study (African Minds obo Open Society Foundations Cape Town 2016)

North West University The International Human Right to Nationality, the Prevention of Statelessness and the Protection of Stateless Individuals in the 21st Century (31 October-2 November 2017 Potchefstroom)

Sloth-Nielsen J and Mezmur BD "Surveying the Research Landscape to Promote Children's Legal Rights in an African Context" 2007 AHRLJ 330-353

Tobin J "Beyond the Supermarket Shelf: Using a Rights-based Approach to Address Children's Health Needs" 2006 Int'l J Children's Rts 275-306

Tobin J "Understanding a Human Rights Based Approach to Matters Involving Children: Conceptual Foundations and Strategic Considerations" in Invernizzi A and Williams J (eds) The Human Rights of Children: From Visions of Implementation (Routledge London 2011) 62-98

Van Bueren G The International Law on the Rights of the Child - Vol 35 (Martinus Nijhoff Dordrecht 1998)

Van Waas L "The Children of Irregular Migrants: A Stateless Generation?" 2007 NQHR 437-458

Van Waas L "The UN Statelessness Conventions" in Edwards A and Van Waas L (eds) Nationality and Statelessness under International Law (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2014) 64-87

Case law

African Committee of Experts on the Rights and Welfare of the Child, Institute for Human Rights and Development in Africa and the Open Society Justice Initiative (obo Children of Nubian Descent in Kenya) v Kenya Communication number 002/Com/002/2009 of 22 March 2011

Ali v Minister of Home Affairs 2017 JOL 38775 (WCC)

DGLR v the Minister of Home Affairs (GPJHC) (unreported) case number 38429/13 of 3 July 2014

Minister of Home Affairs v DGLR (SCA) (unreported) case number 1051/2015 of 6 September 2016

Minister of Home Affairs v Ali 2019 2 SA 396 (SCA)

Naki v Director-General: Department of Home Affairs 2018 3 All SA 802 (ECHC)

Nkosi v Minister of Home Affairs 2017 ZAGPPHC 1078 (18 December 2017)

Pham v Secretary of State for the Home Department 2015 1 WLR 1591 (SC)

SERAC v Nigeria (ACHPR) 2155/96 of 27 October 2001

Supreme Court of Cassation (Italy) Judgment number 28873/2008 of 9 December 2008

Supreme Court of Cassation (Italy) Judgment number 7614/2011 of 4 April 2011

Legislation

Births and Deaths Registration Act 51 of 1992

Children's Act 38 of 2005

Citizenship Act 88 of 1995

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Refugee Act 130 of 1998

International Instruments

African Charter on the Rights and Welfare of the Child (1990)

Committee on the Rights of the Child General Comment No 5: General Measures of Implementation of the Convention on the Rights of the Child UN Doc CRC/GC/2003/5 (2003)

Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (1979) 1249 UNTS 13

Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness (1961) 989 UNTS 175

Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989) 1577 UNTS 3

Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees (1951) 189 UNTS 150

Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless Persons (1954) 360 UNTS 117

International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families (1990) UN Doc A/RES/45/158

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (1966) 999 UNTS 171

Universal Declaration of Human Rights GA Res 217 A (III) (1948)

Internet sources

Assefa AG 2015 Realising the Right to Birth Registration to Prevent Statelessness in Africa: In the Context of the General Comment on Article 6 of the African Children's Charter https://africlaw.com/

/12/15/realising-the-right-to-birth-registration-to-prevent-statelessness-in-africa-in-the-context-of-the-general-comment-on-article-6-of-the-african-childrens-charter/ accessed 14 November 2018

European Network on Statelessness 2014 Sill Stateless, Still Suffering: Why Europe Must Act Now to Protect Stateless Persons https://www.statelessness.eu/sites/www.statelessness.eu/files/ENS_Still_Stateless_Still_Suffering_online%20veversi_2.pdf accessed 14 November 2018

Gentleman A 2014 UN Refugee Agency Launches Global Campaign to End Statelessness https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/nov/04/un-refugee-agency-global-campaign-statelessness accessed 14 November 2018

Goldston J 2004 Legal Approaches to Combating Statelessness - Executive Committee Panel Discussion on 50th Anniversary of the 1954 Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless Persons https://www.open

societyfoundations.org/sites/default/files/stateless_20041006.pdf accessed 14 November 2018

Lawyers for Human Rights 2017 States Ask South Africa to give Rights to the Stateless http://www.ngopulse.org/press-release/press-statement-states-ask-south-africa-give-rights-stateless accessed 15 November 2018

LHR 2019 https://www.lhr.org.za/news/2019/press-release-high-court-dismisses-attempt-revoke-stateless-childs-citizenship

Lawyers for Human Rights 2019 High Court Dismisses Attempt to Revoke Stateless Child's Citizenship https://www.lhr.org.za/news/2019/press-release-high-court-dismisses-attempt-revoke-stateless-childs-citizenship accessed 22 February 2020

Lawyers for Human Rights and Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion 2016 Joint Submission the the Human Rights Council at the 27th Session http://www.institutesi.org/SouthAfricaUPR2016.pdf accessed 14 November 2018

Lawyers for Human Rights and Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion 2016 Childhood Statelessness in South Africa https://www.lhr.org.za/sites/lhr.org.za/files/childhood_statelessness_in_south_africa.pdf accessed 9 February 2020

O'Malley A 2015 Statelessness: A Responsibility to Protect? https://www.e-ir.info/2015/06/14/statelessness-a-responsibility-to-protect/ accessed 9 November 2018

Open Society Justice Initiative Date Unknown Children of Nubian Descent in Kenya v Kenya https://www.justiceinitiative.org/litigation/children-nubian-descent-kenya-v-kenya accessed 20 December 2019

Stellenbosch University 2018 Ending Statelessness: The Role of Faith Based Organizations in the Southern African Region for the Protection of Stateless Persons and the Prevention of Statelessness Conference (30-31 August 2018 Stellenbosch) https://www.unhcr.org/ibelong/event/ending-statelessness-the-role-of-faith-based-organizations-in-the-southern-african-region/ accessed 24 February 2020

United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees Date Unknown Ending Statelessness http://www.unhcr.org/stateless-people.html accessed 14 November 2018

United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees 2010 Expert Meeting - The Concept of Stateless Persons under International Law ("Prato Conclusions") http://www.refworld.org/docid/4ca1ae002.html accessed 9 November 2018

UNHCR,+Handbook+and+Guidelines+on+Procedures+and+Criteria+for+Determining+Refugee+Status+under+the+1951+Convention+and+the+1967+Protocol+Relating+to+the+Status+of+Refugees/30fe78f2-5414-47ec-9439-0f2663889e58

UNHCR 2015 http://www.unhcr.org/ibelong/wp-content/uploads/2015-10-StatelessReport_ENG16.pdf

United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees 2015 I Am Here, I Belong: The Urgent Need to End Childhood Statelessness http://www.unhcr.org/ibelong/wp-content/uploads/2015-10-StatelessReport_ENG16.pdf accesed 9 November 2018

University of Cape Town 2018 Strengthening South African Academia in Preventing Statelessness and Protecting Stateless Persons in Southern Africa (8 May 2018 Cape Town) http://sihma.org.za/events/strengthening-south-african-academia-in-preventing-statelessness-and-protecting-stateless-persons-in-southern-africa/ accessed 24 February 2020

Published
2020-05-04
How to Cite
Khan, F. (2020). Exploring Childhood Statelessness in South Africa. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 23, 1-34. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2020/v23i0a6414
Section
Articles