Legal Pluralism, uBuntu and the Use of Open Norms in the South African Common Law of Contract
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2019/v22i0a6456Keywords:
Bona fides, common law of contract, contractual fairness, good faith, legal historical comparison, legal pluralism, Roman law of contract, ubuntuAbstract
In this article, a comparison is drawn between the role of good faith in the development of the Roman law of contract and the emerging role of ubuntu in the South African common law of contract. Firstly, it is shown how the Romans realised that their existing formal and rigid laws could not address the changing legal needs of the community due to the influx of foreigners (especially foreign traders) into Rome. In reaction to the changing commercial environment, they introduced flexible legal procedures and a more normative approach to these legal transactions to achieve fairness and justice between the contracting parties. This worked so well that the new flexible procedures and normative principles were transferred to the existing formalistic law. Gradually the existing ius civile became subject to a more normative interpretation in the interests of justice through the use of the open norm of good faith. It is argued that in a similar way, ubuntu can be used to address legal pluralism in the South African legal system, and its application as an underlying constitutional value could result in the better use of the open norm of good faith to address contractual unfairness.
Downloads
References
Adams J and Brownsword R Key Issues in Contract (Butterworths London 1995)
Bablitz L Actors and Audience in the Roman Courtroom (Routledge Oxon 2007)
Beinart B "Roman Law in a Modern Uncodified Romanistic System" 1971 Acta Juridica 134-142
Bekker JC, Rautenbach C and Tshivhase AE "Nature and Sphere of African Customary Law" in Rautenbach C (ed) Introduction to Legal Pluralism in South Africa 5th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2018) 17-34
Bennett TW "Ubuntu: An African Equity" 2011 PELJ 30-61
Bennett TW Customary Law in South Africa (Juta Lansdowne 2004)
Bennett TW, Munro AR and Jacobs PJ Ubuntu: An African Jurisprudence (Juta Claremont 2018)
Berger A Encyclopedic Dictionary of Roman Law (The American Philosophical Society Philadelphia 1953)
Bhana D and Broeders N "Agreements to Agree" 2014 THRHR 164-176
Bhana D and Pieterse P "Towards a Reconciliation of Contract Law and Constitutional Values: Brisley and Afrox Revisited" 2005 SALJ 865-895
Birks P "From Legis Actio to Formula" 1969 The Irish Jurist 356-367
Brennan TC The Praetorship in the Roman Republic (Oxford University Press New York 2000)
Cornell D and Muvangua N "Introduction" in Cornell C and Muvangua N (eds) uBuntu and the Law: African Ideals and Postapartheid Jurisprudence (Fordham University Press New York 2012) 1-27
Cornell D and Muvangua N (eds) uBuntu and the Law: African Ideals and Postapartheid Jurisprudence (Fordham University Press New York 2012)
Daube D "The Peregrine Praetor" 1951 The Journal of Roman studies 66-70
Davis DM and Klare K "Transformative Constitutionalism and the Common and Customary Law" 2010 SAJHR 403-509
De Zulueta F The Institutes of Gaius Part I: Text with Critical Notes and Translation (Oxford University Press Clarendon 1946)
De Zulueta F The Institutes of Gaius Part II: Commentary (Oxford University Press Clarendon 1953)
Du Plessis HM "Harmonising Legal Values and the Quest for Social Justice in the South African Common Law of
Du Plessis Good Faith and Ubuntu in South African Contract Law 2019 PELJ 1-25
Du Plessis HM The Harmonisation of Good Faith and Ubuntu in the South African Common Law of Contract (LLD-thesis University of South Africa 2017)
Du Plessis P Borkowski's Textbook on Roman Law 5th ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 2015)
Erasmus HJ "Roman Law in South Africa Today" 1989 SALJ 666-677
Földi A "Traces of the Dualist Interpretation of Good Faith in the Ius Commune until the End of the Sixteenth Century" 2014 Fundamina 312-321
Gade CBN "The Historical Development of the Written Discourses on Ubuntu" 2011 S Afr J Philos 303-329
Gilbert RL "The Origin and History of the Peregrine Praetorship, 242-166 BC" 1939 Res Judicatae 50-58
Gordley J The Philosophical Origins of Modern Contract Doctrine (Clarendon Oxford 1991)
Hawthorne L "The Principle of Equality in the Law of Contract" 1995 THRHR 157-176
Hawthorne L "Public Policy and Micro Lending – Has the Unruly Horse Died?" 2003 THRHR 116-122
Hawthorne L "Legal Tradition and the Transformation of Orthodox Contract Theory: The Movement from Formalism to Realism" 2006 Fundamina 71-86
Hawthorne L "The 'New Learning' and Transformation of Contract Law: Reconciling the Rule of Law with the Constitutional Imperative to Social Transformation" 2008 SAPL 77-99
Hawthorne L "Public Governance: Unpacking the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008" 2012 THRHR 345-370
Hawthorne L "Public Policy: The Origin of a General Clause in the South African Law of Contract" 2013 Fundamina 300-320
Himonga C "Exploring the Concept of Ubuntu in the South African Legal System" in Kischel U and Kirchner C (eds) Ideologie und Weltanschauung im Recht (Mohr Siebeck Tübingen 2012) 1-22
Himonga C, Taylor M and Pope A "Reflections on Judicial Views of Ubuntu" 2013 PELJ 369-427
Hutchison D "The Nature and Basis of Contract" in Hutchison D and Pretorius CJ (eds) The Law of Contract in South Africa 3rd ed (Oxford University Press Cape Town 2017) 4-44
Johnson AC et al Ancient Roman Statutes: A Translation with Introduction, Commentary, Glossary, and Index (University of Texas Austin 1961)
Kaser M Roman Private Law 13th ed (Dannenbring R tr, 4th ed, University of South Africa Pretoria 1984)
Keep H and Midgley R "The Emerging Role of Ubuntu-Botho in Developing a Consensual South African Legal Culture" in Bruinsma F and Nelken D (eds) Recht der Werkelijkheid: Explorations in Legal Cultures (Reed Business BV Gravenhage 2007) 29-51
Klare KE "Legal Culture and Transformative Constitutionalism" 1998 SAJHR 146-188
Louw AM "Yet another Call for a Greater Role for Good Faith in the South African Law of Contract: Can We Banish the Law of the Jungle, while Avoiding the Elephant in the Room?" 2013 PELJ 43-120
Lubbe G "Bona Fides, Billikheid en die Openbare Belang in die Suid-Afrikaanse Kontraktereg" 1990 Stell LR 7-25
Lubbe G "Taking Fundamental Rights Seriously: The Bill of Rights and its Implications for the Development of Contract Law" 2004 SALJ 395-423
Moseneke D "Transformative Constitutionalism: Its Implications for the Law of Contract" 2009 Stell LR 3-13
Mousourakis G The Historical and Institutional Context of Roman Law (Ashgate Hampshire 2003)
Nicholas B An Introduction to Roman Law (Oxford University Press Clarendon 1962)
Pieterse M "'Traditional' African Jurisprudence" in Roederer C and Moellendorf D (eds) Jurisprudence (Juta Lansdowne 2006) 438-462
Powell R "Good Faith in Contracts" 1956 CLP 16-38
Rautenbach C "The Phenomenon of Legal Pluralism" in Rautenbach C (ed) Introduction to Legal Pluralism in South Africa 5th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2018) 3-16
Rautenbach C "Exploring the Contribution of Ubuntu in Constitutional Adjudication – Towards the Indigenization of Constitutionalism in South Africa?" in Fombad CM (ed) Constitutional Adjudication in Africa (Oxford University Press Oxford 2017) 293-312
Rautenbach C "Legal Reform of Traditional Courts in South Africa: Exploring the Links between Ubuntu, Restorative Justice and Therapeutic Jurisprudence" 2015 AJICL 275-304
Roby HJ Roman Private Law in the Times of Cicero and of the Antonines Volume 1 (Lawbook Exchange Union, NJ 2000)
Schermaier MJ "Bona Fides in Roman Contract Law" in Zimmerman R and Whittaker S (eds) Good Faith in European Contract Law (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2000) 63-92
Schermaier MJ and Dedek H "Bona Fides" in Bagnall RS et al (eds) The Encyclopedia of Ancient History (Blackwell Chichester 2013) 1155
Schiller AA Roman Law: Mechanisms of Development (Mouton The Hague 1978)
Schulz F Principles of Roman Law (Wolff M tr, Clarendon Oxford 1936)
Schulz F History of Roman Legal Science (Clarendon Oxford 1953)
Thomas JAC The Institutes of Justinian: Text, Translation and Commentary (Juta Cape Town 1975)
Thomas Ph J "Harmonising the Law in a Multilingual Environment with Different Legal Systems: Lessons to be Drawn from the Legal History of South Africa" 2008 Fundamina 133-154
Tuori K Ancient Roman Lawyers and Modern Legal Ideals: Studies on the Impact of Contemporary Concerns in the Interpretation of Ancient Roman Legal History (Vittorio Klostermann 2007)
Van der Walt AJ "Legal History, Legal Culture and Transformation in a Constitutional Democracy" 2006 Fundamina 1-47
Van Warmelo P Die Oorsprong en Betekenis van die Romeinse Reg 2nd ed (JL van Schaik Pretoria 1978)
Van Warmelo P An Introduction to the Principles of Roman Civil Law (Juta Cape Town 1980)
Watson A "Consensual Societas between Romans and the Introduction of Formulae" 1962 Rev Int'le Droits Ant 431-436
Watson A "The Evolution of Law: The Roman System of Contracts" 1984 LHR 1-20
Watson A The Digest of Justinian (University of Pennsylvania Press Philadelphia 2009-2011)
Watson A Law Making in the Later Roman Republic (Clarendon Oxford 1974)
Watson A The Law of the Ancient Romans (Southern Methodist University Press Dallas 1970)
Zimmerman R "Good Faith and Equity in Modern Roman-Dutch Law" in Rabello AM (ed) Aequitas and Equity: Equity in Civil Law and Mixed Jurisdictions (Harry and Michael Sacher Institute for Legislative Research and Comparative Law, Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem 1997) 517-582
Zimmerman R The Law of Obligations: Roman Foundations of the Civilian Tradition (Juta Cape Town 1990)
African Dawn Property Finance 2 (Pty) Ltd v Dreams Travel and Tours CC 2011 3 SA 511 (SCA)
Afrox Healthcare Bpk v Strydom 2002 6 SA 21 (SCA)
Barkhuizen v Napier 2007 5 SA 323 (CC)
Botha v Rich 2014 4 SA 124 (CC)
Brisley v Drotsky 2002 4 SA 1 (SCA)
Everfresh Market Virginia (Pty) Ltd v Shoprite Checkers (Pty) Ltd 2012 1 SA 256 (CC)
Gumede v The President of the Republic of South Africa 2009 3 SA 152 (CC)
Maphango v Aengus Lifestyle Properties (Pty) Ltd 2011 5 SA 19 (SCA)
Mohamed's Leisure Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Southern Sun Hotel Interests (Pty) Ltd 2018 2 SA 314 (SCA)
Port Elizabeth Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)
Potgieter v Potgieter 2012 1 SA 637 (SCA)
Printing and Numerical Registering Company v Sampson 1875 LR 19 Eq 462
S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)
Sasfin (Pty) Ltd v Beukes 1989 1 SA 1 (A)
South African Forestry Co Ltd v York Timbers Ltd 2005 3 SA 323 (SCA)
Black Administration Act 38 of 1927
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 200 of 1993
Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008
Law of Evidence Amendment Act 45 of 1988
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2019 Hanri Magdalena Du Plessis
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
.png){kind=spacer}