Harmonising Legal Values and uBuntu: The Quest for Social Justice in the South African Common Law of Contract

Keywords: Bona fides, common law of contract, contractual fairness, good faith, legal historical comparison, legal pluralism, Roman law of contract, ubuntu

Abstract

In this article, a comparison is drawn between the role of good faith in the development of the Roman law of contract and the emerging role of ubuntu in the South African common law of contract. Firstly, it is shown how the idea of good faith as an open norm in Roman law was inspired by Greek philosophy and it is argued that ubuntu as an underlying value of the customary law can infuse good faith in the common law of contract in similar fashion. Secondly, an important distinction between the two concepts is identified. Although both concepts promote contractual justice between the contracting parties, ubuntu entails a further duty to promote the social and economic well-being of the parties as well as that of the greater community. Hence, in contrast to good faith, ubuntu is concerned with the promotion of substantive equality in private dealings.

References

Bennett TW, Munro AR and Jacobs PJ Ubuntu: An African Jurisprudence (Juta Claremont 2018)
Bennett TW "Ubuntu: An African Equity" 2011 PELJ 30-61
Berger A Encyclopedic Dictionary of Roman Law (The American Philosophical Society Philadelphia 1953)
Bhana D "Contract Law and the Constitution: Bredenkamp v Standard Bank of South Africa (SCA)" 2014 SAPL 508-521
Bhana D and Broeders N "Agreements to Agree" 2014 THRHR 164-176
Bhana D and Meerkotter A "The Impact of the Constitution on the Common Law of Contract: Botha v Rich NO (CC)" 2015 SALJ 494-509
Botha H "Human Dignity in Comparative Perspective" 2009 Stell LR 171-220
Buckland WW and McNair AD Roman Law and Common Law: A Comparison in Outline (Cambridge University Press London 1952)
Cornell D and Muvangua N "Introduction" in Cornell C and Muvangua N (eds) uBuntu and the Law: African Ideals and Postapartheid Jurisprudence (Fordham University Press New York 2012) 1-27
De Zulueta F The Institutes of Gaius Part I: Text with Critical Notes and Translation (Oxford University Press Clarendon 1946)
De Zulueta F The Institutes of Gaius Part II: Commentary (Oxford University Press Clarendon 1953)
Du Plessis HM "Legal Pluralism and the Use of Open Norms in the South African Common Law of Contract" 2019 PELJ 1-38
Du Plessis HM The Harmonisation of Good Faith and Ubuntu in the South African Common Law of Contract (LLD-thesis University of South Africa 2017)
Griffin MT and Atkins EM (eds) Cicero on Duties (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 1991)
Gruen ES "Greek Pistis and Roman Fides" 1982 Athenaeum 50-68
Hawthorne L "The 'New Learning' and Transformation of Contract Law: Reconciling the Rule of Law with the Constitutional Imperative to Social Transformation" 2008 SAPL 77-99
Hawthorne L "Contract Law: Contextualization and Unequal Bargaining Position Redux" 2010 De Jure 395-409
Hiemstra VG and Gonin HL Trilingual Legal Dictionary: Latin-Afrikaans-English 3rd ed (Juta Paarl 2008)
Himonga C, Taylor M and Pope A "Reflections on Judicial Views of Ubuntu" 2013 PELJ 369-427
Jolowicz HF Roman Foundations of Modern Law (Oxford University Press Clarendon 1957)
Kaser M Roman Private law 13th ed (Dannenbring R tr, 4th ed, University of South Africa Pretoria 1984)
Keep H and Midgley R "The Emerging Role of Ubuntu-Botho in Developing a Consensual South African Legal Culture" in Bruinsma F and Nelken D (eds) Recht der Werkelijkheid: Explorations in Legal Cultures (Reed Business BV Gravenhage 2007) 29-51
Kelly JM Roman Litigation (Oxford University Press Clarendon 1966)
Kunkel W An Introduction to Roman Legal and Constitutional History 6th ed (Kelly JM tr, 2nd ed, Oxford University Press Clarendon 1985)
Lind LR "The Republic and Roman Morality" in Deroux C (ed) Studies in Latin Literature and Roman History Volume 5 (Latomux Brussels 1989) 5-34
Litvinoff S "Good Faith" 1997 Tul L Rev 1645-1674
Louw AM "Yet another Call for a Greater Role for Good Faith in the South African Law of Contract: Can We Banish the Law of the Jungle, while Avoiding the Elephant in the Room?" 2013 PELJ 43-120
Mokgoro JY "Ubuntu and the Law in South Africa" 1998 PELJ 1-11
Mommsen T and Krueger (eds) The Digest of Justinian (University of Pennsylvania Press Philadelphia 1985)
More MP "Philosophy in South Africa under and after Apartheid" in K Wiredu (ed) A Companion to African Philosophy (Blackwell Malden 2004) 149-160
Naudé T "The Function and Determinants of the Residual Rules of Contract Law" 2003 SALJ 820-840
Nicholas B An Introduction to Roman Law (Oxford University Press Clarendon 1962)
Rautenbach C "Exploring the Contribution of Ubuntu in Constitutional Adjudication – Towards the Indigenization of Constitutionalism in South Africa?" in Fombad CM (ed) Constitutional Adjudication in Africa (Oxford University Press Oxford 2017) 293-312
Rautenbach C "Legal Reform of Traditional Courts in South Africa: Exploring the Links between Ubuntu, Restorative Justice and Therapeutic Jurisprudence" 2015 AJICL 275-304
Roberts "Rhetorica" in Ross WD (ed) The Works of Aristotle Translated into English (Oxford University Press London 1963) vol 11
Ross WD "Ethica Nicomachea" in Ross WD (ed) The Works of Aristotle Translated into English (Oxford University Press London 1963) vol 9
Schermaier MJ "Bona Fides in Roman Contract Law" in Zimmerman R and Whittaker S (eds) Good Faith in European Contract Law (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2000) 63-92
Schulz F Principles of Roman Law (Wolff M tr, Clarendon Press Oxford 1936)
Schulz F History of Roman Legal Science (Oxford Clarendon 1953)
Sič M "Fiducia and Pignus in Sources of Post-Classical Roman Law – Synonyms or Terms Utilized for Different Kinds of Pledges?" 2008 Zbornik Radova 143-172
Thomas Ph J "The Roman Law Tradition" 2003 De Jure 101-114
Tuori K "Aequitas" in Bagnall RS et al (eds) The Encyclopedia of Ancient History (Blackwell Chichester 2013) 132
Van Warmelo P An Introduction to the Principles of Roman Civil Law (Juta Cape Town 1980)
Verboven KS "Fides" in Bagnall RS et al (eds) The Encyclopedia of Ancient History (Blackwell Chichester 2013) 2670
Wallis M "Commercial Certainty and Constitutionalism: Are they Compatible?" 2016 SALJ 545-568
Watson A The Digest of Justinian (University of Pennsylvania Press Philadelphia 2009-2011)
Watson A The Law of the Ancient Romans (Southern Methodist University Press Dallas 1970)
Winkel L "Forms of Imposed Protection in Legal History, Especially in Roman Law" 2010 Fundamina 478-587
Woolman S "Category Mistakes and the Waiver of Constitutional Rights: A Response to Deeksha Bhana on Barkhuizen" 2008 SALJ 10-24
Zimmerman R The Law of Obligations: Roman Foundations of the Civilian Tradition (Juta Cape Town 1990)
Barkhuizen v Napier 2007 5 SA 323 (CC)
Bhe v Magistrate, Khayelitsha (Commission for Gender Equality as Amicus Curiae); Shibi v Sithole; South African Human Rights Commission v President of the Republic of South Africa 2005 1 SA 580 (CC)
Botha v Rich 2014 4 SA 124 (CC)
Dikoko v Mokhatla 2006 6 SA 235 (CC)
Everfresh Market Virginia (Pty) Ltd v Shoprite Checkers (Pty) Ltd 2012 1 SA 256 (CC)
Port Elizabeth Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)
S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)
Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Prevention of Illegal Eviction from and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act 19 of 1998
Views
  • Abstract 62
  • pdf 34
  • xml 2
  • epub 57
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2019-10-23
Section
Articles