Once More uBuntu: A Reply to Radebe and Phooko

Keywords: ubuntu, constitution, legal philosophy

Abstract

This article is a critical engagement with the most recent contribution to the debate on the nature and content of ubuntu. The contribution (by Radebe and Phooko) attempts to provide the concept of ubuntu with substantive content in order for the concept to provide legal solutions for legal problems. This article shows how this attempt largely fails for three reasons. In the first place because some of the suggested rules are social/moral rules that cannot be enforced by law. In the second place because other rules are already contained in common law, legislation or case law. In the third place the remaining rules are arguably either unconstitutional or inappropriate in an open and democratic society. The conclusion is that the suggested rules are not appropriate in an open society.

scholar_logo_64dp5.png

References

Bibliography

Literature

Agbakoba and Nwauche 2006 Cambrian L RevAgbakoba JCA and Nwauche ES "African Conceptions of Justice, Responsibility and Punishment" 2006 Cambrian L Rev 73-83

Bohler-Muller N "Some Thoughts on the ubuntu Jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court" in Cornell D and Muvongua N (eds) ubuntu and the Law: African Ideals and Postapartheid Jurisprudence (Fordham University Press New York 2012) 377-387

Booth AL "We are the Land: Native American Views of Nature" in Selin H (ed) Nature across Cultures. Science across Cultures: The History of Non-Western Science Vol 4 (Springer Dordrecht 2003) 329-349

Carstens P and Pearmain D Foundational Principles of South African Medical Law (LexisNexis Durban 2007)

Cornell D and Van Marle K "Exploring Ubuntu: Tentative Reflections" 2005 AHRLJ 195-220

Dugard J "The Judicial Process, Positivism and Civil Liberty" 1971 SALJ 181-200

English R "Ubuntu: The Quest for an Indigenous Jurisprudence" 1996 SAJHR 641-648

Fagan A "In Defence of the Obvious – Ordinary Meaning and the Identification of Constitutional Rules" 1995 SAJHR 545-570

Finlayson JG "Hegel, Adorno and the Origins of Immanent Criticism" 2015 Br J Hist Philos 1142-1166

Heaton J South African Family Law (LexisNexis Durban 2010)

Idowu W "African Jurisprudence and the Reconciliation Theory of Law" 2006 Cambrian L Rev 1-16

Idowu W "'To Each a Crumb of Right, to Neither the Whole Loaf': The Metaphor of the Bread and the Jurinomics of Justice in African Thought" 2012 JJS 56-83

Keevy I "Ubuntu versus the Core Values of the Constitution" 2009 JJS 19-58

Kroeze IJ "Re-evaluating Legal Positivism – or Positivism and Fundamental Rights: A Comedy of Errors" 1993 SAPL 230-237

Kroeze IJ "Doing Things with Values II: The Case of Ubuntu" 2002 Stell LR 252-264

Kuwali D "Decoding Afrocentrism: Decolonizing Legal Theory" in Onazi O (ed) African Legal Theory and Contemporary Problems: Critical Essays (Springer Dordrecht 2014) 71-92

Manji AS The Politics of Land Reform in Africa: From Communal Tenure to Free Markets (Zed London 2006)

Metz T "Towards an African Moral Theory" 2007 J Polit Philos 321-341

Michelman F "Law's Republic" 1988 Yale LJ 1493-1537

Moosa E "Tension in Legal and Religious Values in the 1996 South African Constitution" in Mamdani M (ed) Beyond Rights Talk and Culture Talk: Comparative Essays on the Politics of Rights and Culture (St Martin's Press New York 2000) 121-135

Onyango P African Customary Law: An Introduction (LawAfrica Nairobi 2013)

Pieterse M "'Traditional' African Jurisprudence" in Roederer C and Moellendorf D (eds) Jurisprudence (Juta Lansdowne 2004) 438-462

Popper KR The Open Society and its Enemies - Vol 1: Plato (Princeton University Press Princeton MA 1966)

Radebe SB and Phooko MR "Ubuntu and the Law in South Africa: Exploring and Understanding the Substantive Content of Ubuntu" 2017 SAJP 239-251

Salmón E "Kincentric Ecology: Indigenous Perceptions of the Human-Nature Relationship" 2000 Ecological Applications 1327-1332

Schlag P "Values" in Schlag P Laying Down the Law – Mysticism, Fetishism and the American Legal Mind (New York University Press New York 1996) 42-59

Van der Walt AJ and Pienaar GJ Introduction to the Law of Property (Juta Cape Town 1999)

Case law

Azanian Peoples' Organisation (AZAPO) v Truth and Reconciliation Commission 1996 4 SA 562 (C)

Christian Education SA v Minister of Education 2000 4 SA 757 (CC)

Doctors for Life International v Speaker of the National Assembly 2006 6 SA 233 (CC)

Dulabh v Department of Land Affairs 1997 4 SA 1108 (LCC)

Faria v Road Accident Fund 2009 4 All SA 169 (GSHC)

Freedom of Religion South Africa v Minister of Justice 2020 1 SACR 113 (CC)

Inkatha Freedom Party v Truth and Reconciliation Commission 2000 3 SA 119 (C)

Joseph v City of Johannesburg 2010 4 SA 55 (CC)

Liberty Group Limited v Mall Space Management 2020 1 SA 30 (SCA)

Mohamed's Leisure Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Southern Sun Hotel Interests (Pty) Ltd 2018 2 SA 314 (SCA)

PE Municipality v Various Occupiers 2005 1 SA 217 (CC)

Ryland v Edros 1997 2 SA 690 (C)

S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)

Williamson v Schoon 1997 3 SA 1053 (T)

Legislation

Child Justice Act 75 of 2008

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 200 of 1993

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Development Facilitation Act 67 of 1995

Ingonyama Trust Act No 3KZ of 1994

Land Reform (Labour Tenants) Act 3 of 1996

Land Reform: Provision of Land and Assistance Act 126 of 1993

Security of Tenure Act 62 of 1997

Spatial Planning and Land Use Act 16 of 2013

International instruments

Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)

Internet sources

Barceló JA et al 2013 Social Interaction in Hunter-Gatherer Societies: Simulating the Consequences of Cooperation and Social Aggregation https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0894439313511943 accessed 10 March 2020

Cambridge Dictionary date unknown Shibboleth https://dictionary.cam

bridge.org/dictionary/english/shibboleth accessed 3 April 2019

Department of Public Service and Administration 2014 The Batho Pele Vision http://www.dpsa.gov.za/documents/Abridged%20BP%20programme%20July2014.pdf accessed 12 March 2020

Institute of Directors in Southern Africa 2009 King Report on Corporate Governance for South Africa 2009 https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.iodsa.co.za/resource/resmgr/king_iii/King_Report_on_Governance_fo.pdf accessed on 11 March 2020

Korff J date unknown Meaning of Land to Aboriginal People https://www.creativespirits.info/aboriginalculture/land/meaning-of-land-to-aboriginal-people accessed 4 March 2020

Lewis HM et al 2014 High Mobility Explains Demand Sharing and Enforced Cooperation in Egalitarian Hunter-Gatherers https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms6789.pdf?origin=ppub accessed on 10 March 2020

Smith D et al 2017 Cooperation and the Evolution of Hunter-Gatherer Storytelling https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-02036-8.pdf accessed 10 March 2020

Published
2020-06-02
How to Cite
Kroeze, I. (2020). Once More uBuntu: A Reply to Radebe and Phooko. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 23, 1-22. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2020/v23i0a8048
Section
Articles