The Shaping, Enactment and Interpretation of the First Hate-Crime Law in the United Kingdom - An Informative and Illustrative Lesson for South Africa

  • Kamban Naidoo University of South Africa
Keywords: hate crimes, hate crime laws, Britain, South Africa, constitutional imperatives

Abstract

Hate crimes are crimes that are motivated by personal prejudice or bias. Hate-crime laws criminalise such conduct and allow for the imposition of aggravated penalties on convicted perpetrators. This article examines the historical, social and political factors which influenced the shaping and enactment of the first British hate-crime law. The South African context is also considered since the Department of Justice has recently released the Prevention and Combatting of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill for public commentary and input.

While Britain has had a long historical record of criminal conduct that was motivated by the race and the ethnicity of victims, it was only in the twentieth century that civil society first drew attention to the problem of violent racist crimes. Nevertheless, successive British governments denied the problem of racist crimes and refused to consider the enactment of a hate-crime law. Following a high-profile racist murder and a governmental inquiry, a British Labour Party-led government eventually honoured its pre-election commitment and passed a hate-crime law in 1998.

Some parallels are apparent between the British and the South African contexts. South Africa also has a long historical record of racially motivated hate crimes. Moreover, in the post-apartheid era there have been numerous reports of racist hate crimes and hate crimes against Black lesbian women and Black foreigners. Despite several appeals from the academic and non-governmental sectors for the enactment of a hate-crime law, and the circulation for public commentary of the Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill, such a law has hitherto not been enacted in South Africa. This article posits that the enactment of a hate-crime law is a constitutional imperative in South Africa in terms of the right to equality and the right to freedom and security of the person. While the enactment of a hate-crime law in South Africa is recommended, it is conceded that enacting a hate-crime law will not eradicate criminal conduct motivated by prejudice and bias.

 

Google_Scholar_78.png  ScienceOpen_Log0316.png

Author Biography

Kamban Naidoo, University of South Africa

Department of Criminal and Procedural Law

Senior Lecturer

References

Literature

Adhikari Anatomy of a South African Genocide
Adhikari M The Anatomy of a South African Genocide: The Extermination of the Cape San Peoples (University of Cape Town Press Cape Town 2010)

Ashworth and Horder Principles of Criminal Law
Ashworth A and Horder J Principles of Criminal Law 7th ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 2013)

Athwal, Bourne and Wood Racial Violence
Athwal H, Bourne J and Wood R Racial Violence: The Buried Issue (Institute of Race Relations London 2010)

Billig 1978 Race and Class
Billig M "Patterns of Racism: Interviews with National Front Members" 1978 Race and Class 161-179

Bleich 2007 Am Behav Sci
Bleich E "Hate Crime Policy in Western Europe: Responding to Racist Violence in Britain, Germany and France" 2007 Am Behav Sci 149-165

Bowling Violent Racism
Bowling B Violent Racism, Victimization, Policing and Social Context (Oxford University Press Oxford 1998)

Bowling and Phillips "Racist Victimisation in England and Wales"
Bowling B and Phillips C "Racist Victimisation in England and Wales" in Hawkins DF (ed) Violent Crime: Assessing Race and Ethnic Differences (Cambridge University Press Cambridge 2003) 154-170

Bowling, Parmar and Phillips "Policing Ethnic Minority Communities"
Bowling B, Parmar A and Phillips C "Policing Ethnic Minority Communities" in Newburn T (ed) Handbook of Policing (Willan Devon 2003) 528-555

Brearley "Persecution of Gypsies in Europe"
Brearley M "The Persecution of Gypsies in Europe" in Gerstenfeld PB and Grant DR (eds) Crimes of Hate: Selected Readings (Sage Thousand Oaks 2004) 354-363

Breen and Nel 2011 SA Crime Quarterly
Breen D and Nel JA "South Africa – A Home for All? The Need for Hate-Crime Legislation" 2011 SA Crime Quarterly 33-43

Bridges 1999 J Law & Soc
Bridges L "The Lawrence Inquiry: Incompetence, Corruption and Institutional Racism" 1999 J Law & Soc 298-322

Campbell and Muncer 1989 Deviant Behaviour
Campbell A and Muncer S "Them and Us: A Comparison of the Cultural Context of American Gangs and British Subcultures" 1989 Deviant Behaviour 271-288

Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook
Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 6th ed (Juta Cape Town 2013)

D'Souza 1995 American Scholar
D'Souza D "Is Racism a Western Idea?" 1995 The American Scholar 517-539

Delgado 1982 Harv CR-CL L Rev
Delgado R "Words that Wound: A Tort Action for Racial Insults, Epithets and Name-Calling" 1982 Harv CR-CL L Rev 133-180

Dixon and Ray 2007 Probation Journal
Dixon L and Ray L "Current Issues and Developments in Race Hate Crime" 2007 Probation Journal 109-124

Edgar 1977 Race and Class
Edgar D "Racism, Fascism and the Politics of the National Front" 1977 Race and Class 111-128

Foot 1991 Socialist Review
Foot P "The Stephen Lawrence Case" 1991 Socialist Review 1-3

Fryer Staying Power
Fryer P Staying Power: The History of Black People in Britain 2nd ed (Pluto London 2010)

Gadd 2009 Br J Criminol
Gadd D "Aggravating Racism and Elusive Motivation" 2009 Br J Criminol 755-771

Gerstenfeld Hate Crimes
Gerstenfeld PB Hate Crimes: Causes, Controls and Controversies 3rd ed (Sage Thousand Oaks 2013)

Hall Hate Crime
Hall N Hate Crime 2nd ed (Routledge Abingdon 2013)

Herring Criminal Law
Herring J Criminal Law: Text, Cases and Materials 5th ed (Oxford University Press Oxford 2012)

Hiro Black British, White British
Hiro D Black British, White British (Eyre and Spottiswoode London 1971)

Horobin 1972 Police Journal
Horobin A "'Paki-Bashing' in Coventry" 1972 Police Journal 184-197

Iganski 1999 Crit Soc Pol
Iganski P "Legislating against Hate: Outlawing Racism and Anti-Semitism in Britain" 1999 Crit Soc Pol 129-141

Iganski Hate Debate
Iganski P The Hate Debate: Should Hate be Punished as a Crime? (Profile Books London 2002)

Jackson 1998 Geography
Jackson P "Beneath the Headlines: Racism and Reaction in Contemporary Britain" 1998 Geography 202-207

Kushner "Anti-Semitism and Austerity"
Kushner T "Anti-Semitism and Austerity: The 1947 Riots in Britain" in Panayi P (ed) Racial Violence in Britain: 1840-1950 (Leicester University Press Leicester 1993) 146-168

Lawrence 1998-2000 Nat'l Black LJ
Lawrence FM "The Case for a Federal Bias Crime Law" 1998-2000 Nat'l Black LJ 144-168

Lawrence Punishing Hate
Lawrence FM Punishing Hate: Bias Crimes under American Law (Harvard University Press Cambridge 1999)

Lawrence "Memory, Hate and the Criminalization of Bias-Motivated Violence"
Lawrence FM "Memory, Hate and the Criminalization of Bias-Motivated Violence: Lessons from Great Britain" in Minow M and Rosenblum NL (eds) Breaking the Cycles of Hatred: Memory, Law and Repair (Princeton University Press Princeton 2002) 140-153

Lawrence 2003 J Mod Hist
Lawrence J "Forging a Peaceable Kingdom: War, Violence and Fear of Brutalization in Post First World War Britain" 2003 J Mod Hist 557-589

Layton-Henry 1982 Patterns of Prejudice
Layton-Henry Z "Racial Attacks in Britain" 1982 Patterns of Prejudice 3-13

Lea 2000 Howard J Crime Justice
Lea J "The Macpherson Report and the Question of Institutional Racism" 2000 The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice 219-233

Levin 1992-1993 Stan L & Pol'y Rev
Levin B "Bias Crimes: A Theoretical and Practical Overview" 1992-1993 Stan L & Pol'y Rev 165-181

Levin 1999 J Contemp Crim Justice
Levin B "Hate Crimes: Worse by Definition" 1999 J Contemp Crim Justice 6-21

Malik 1999 MLR
Malik M "Racist Crime: Racially Aggravated Offences in the Crime and Disorder Act 1998" (Part II) 1999 MLR 409-424

Mangcu Sunday Times
Mangcu X "Ours is the Postmodern Face of a New Xenophobic Tribalism" Sunday Times (26 April 2015) 21

Matthias 1980 Paideuma
Matthias GG "From 'Brutal Savages' to 'Harmless Peoples': Notes on the Changing Western Image of the Bushmen" 1980 Paideuma 123-140

Mclaughlin and Murji 1999 Crit Soc Pol
McLaughlin E and Murji K "After the Stephen Lawrence Report" 1999 Crit Soc Pol 60-65

Mollema and Van der Bijl 2014 Obiter
Mollema N and Van der Bijl C "Hate Crimes: The Ultimate Anathematic Crimes" 2014 Obiter 672-679

Naidoo Historical and Comparative Legal Study
Naidoo K A Historical and Comparative Legal Study of Hate Crimes Motivated by Race and Ethnicity (LLD-thesis University of South Africa 2015)

Naidoo and Karels 2012a Obiter
Naidoo K and Karels M "Hate Crimes against Black Lesbian South Africans: Where Race, Sexual Orientation and Gender Collide" (Part I) 2012 Obiter 236-260

Naidoo and Karels 2012b Obiter
Naidoo K and Karels M "Hate Crimes against Black Lesbian South Africans: Where Race, Sexual Orientation and Gender Collide" (Part II) 2012 Obiter 600-624

Nosarka The Citizen
Nosarka A "Plea for Hate Crimes Legislation" The Citizen (5 July 2013) 4

Panayi 1991 Social History
Panayi P "Middlesbrough 1961: A British Race Riot of the 1960's" 1991 Social History 139-153

Panayi "Anti-Immigrant Riots in Nineteenth and Twentieth Century Britain"
Panayi P "Anti-Immigrant Riots in Nineteenth and Twentieth Century Britain" in Panayi P (ed) Racial Violence in Britain: 1840-1950 (Leicester University Press Leicester 1993) 1-25

Peterson The Star
Peterson C "Racism will be a Criminal Offence" The Star (1 December 2016) 4

Posel 2001 Afr Stud Rev
Posel D "Race as Common Sense: Racial Classification in Twentieth Century South Africa" 2001 Afr Stud Rev 87-113

Ramamurthy 2006 Race and Class
Ramamurthy A "The Politics of Britain's Asian Youth Movements" 2006 Race and Class 38-60

Scotting 2000-2001 Akron L Rev
Scotting TA "Hate Crimes and the Need for Stronger Federal Legislation" 2000-2001 Akron L Rev 853-892

Snyman Criminal Law
Snyman CR Criminal Law 6th ed (LexisNexis Durban 2014)

Vick 2002 Tex Int'l LJ
Vick DW "The Human Rights Act and the British Constitution" 2002 Tex Int'l LJ 329-372

Walters 2006 UTSLR
Walters M "Changing the Criminal Law to Combat Racially-Motivated Violence" 2006 UTSLR 66-86

Waters 1997 J Br Stud
Waters C "Dark Strangers in our Midst: Discourses of Race and Nation in Britain, 1947-1963" 1997 J Br Stud 207-238

Webster "England and Wales"
Webster C "England and Wales" in Winterdyk J and Antonopoulos G (eds) Racist Victimisation: International Reflections and Perspectives (Ashgate Aldershot 2008) 67-88

Worden 2007 Kronos
Worden N "New Approaches to VOC History in South Africa" 2007 Kronos: South African Historical Journal 3-18

Case law

Britain

Constantine v Imperial Hotels Ltd [1944] KB 693
DPP v Pal [2000] Crim LR 756
DPP v Woods (2002) EWHC 85
Johnson v DPP [2008] EWHC 509 (Admin)
R v Alderson (1989) 11 Cr App R (S) 301, CA
R v Jacobs [2001] 2 Cr App R (S) 174, CA
R v Whalley (1989) 11 Cr App R (S) 405, CA
R v White [2001] EWCA Cri 216, 1 WLR 1352, CA

South Africa

Carmichele v Minister of Safety and Security 2001 4 SA 938 (CC)
Harksen v Lane 1997 11 BCLR 1489 (CC)
Jordan v S 2002 6 SA 642 (CC)
Minister of Safety and Security v Van Duivenboden 2002 6 SA 431 (SCA)
Minister of Safety and Security v Hamilton 2004 2 SA 216 (SCA)
National Coalition for Gay and Lesbian Equality v Minister of Justice 1999 1 SA 6 (CC)
President of the Republic of South Africa v Hugo 1997 4 SA 1 (CC)
S v Matela 1994 1 SACR 236 (A)

Legislation

Britain

Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act, 2001
Crime and Disorder Act, 1998
Criminal Justice Act, 2003
Protection from Harassment Act, 1997
Public Order Act, 1986
Race Relations Act, 1965

France

Loi n. 2003-88 du 3 février 2003

South Africa

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996
Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Matters)
Amendment Act 32 of 2007
Criminal Law Amendment Act 105 of 1997, as amended
Promotion of Equality and Prevention of Unfair Discrimination Act 4 of 2000

United States of America

Matthew Shepherd and James Byrd Junior Hate Crimes Prevention Act, 2009 (codified as 18 USC §249)
Government publications

South Africa

Draft Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill, 2016
International instruments
International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid (1973)

Internet sources

Anon 2016 http://www.timeslive.co.za/local/2016/04/01/Law-to-criminalise-hate-speech-nearly-ready
Anon 2016 Law to Criminalise Hate Speech Nearly Ready http://www.timeslive.co.za/local/2016/04/01/Law-to-criminalise-hate-speech-nearly-ready accessed 11 July 2016
Dewan 2016 http://edition.cnn.com/2016/07/08/europe/brexit-britain-hate-crime
Dewan A 2016 Hate Crime Reports Surge in Britain in Weeks around Brexit http://edition.cnn.com/2016/07/08/europe/brexit-britain-hate-crime accessed 12 July 2016
Forde 2016 http://www.financialmail.co.za/coverstory/2016/01/21/racism-hate-law
Forde 2016 Racism: Hate Law Delay http://www.financialmail.co.za/coverstory/2016/01/21/racism-hate-law accessed 25 January 2016
Harris 2004 http://www.csvr.org.za/docs/racism/arrangingprejudic.pdf
Harris B 2004 Arranging Prejudice: Exploring Hate Crime in Post-Apartheid South Africa http://www.csvr.org.za/docs/racism/arrangingprejudic.pdf accessed 21 June 2016
Jeffrey 2015 http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2015/
2050211_HateCrimes.html
Jeffrey J 2015 Speech by the Honourable Deputy Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2015/
20150211_HateCrimes.html accessed 1 December 2015
Jeffrey 2016 http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2016/
20160330_HateCrime
Jeffrey J 2016 Speech by the Honourable Deputy Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2016/
20160330_HateCrime accessed 11 July 2016
Nair, Savides and Hosken 2015 http://www.timeslive.co.za/
thetimes/2015/04/15/flames-of-hate
Nair N, Savides M and Hosken G 2015 Flames Engulf Durban http://www.timeslive.co.za/thetimes/2015/04/15/flames-of-hate accessed 12 March 2015
Radebe 2013 http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2013/20130825-hate speech.html
Radebe J 2013 Speech by the Honourable Former Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development http://www.justice.gov.za/m_speeches/2013/
20130825-hate-speech.html accessed 1 December 2015
Runnymede Trust date unknown http://www.runnymede
trust.org/histories/index.php?mact=OralHistories,cntnt01,default,1&cntnt01qid=82&cntnt01returnid=15&page=15
Runnymede Trust date unknown An Oral History: Inquiry into Racist Groups and Attacks http://www.runnymedetrust.org/histories/index.php?mact=Oral
Histories,cntnt01,default,1&cntnt01qid=82&cntnt01returnid=15&page=15 30 September 2017
Taylor date unknown http://www.ucian.ac.uk/research/environment/
projects/assets/Racial_Aggravation_final_paper.pdf
Taylor R date unknown The Role of Aggravated Offences in Combating Hate Crime 15 Years after the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 http://www.ucian.ac.uk/research/environment/projects/assets/Racial_Aggravation_final_paper.pdf accessed 1 April 2016
Views
  • Abstract 84
  • PDF 15
  • XML 19
  • Article 9 SUmmary 0
Views and downloads are with effect from 11 January 2018
Published
2017-10-09
Section
Articles