The Use of Force in Effecting Arrest in South Africa and the 2010 Bill: a Step in the Right Direction

  • Tharien van der Walt North West University(Potchefstroom Campus)
Keywords: Use of force in effecting arrest, Section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act, reasonable, proportional and necessary force, deadly force, national arrest law manual, application of the use of force in practice

Abstract

In South Africa the use of force in effecting arrest is statutorily governed by section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977.  The inception of the Constitution brought about a dramatic change in South African law in this regard.  During 2001 and 2002 the two highest courts in the country had to decide on the constitutionality of sections 49(1) and 49(2) respectively.  The Supreme Court of Appeal in Govender v Minister of Safety and Security 2001 2 SACR 197 (SCA)  did not declare section 49(1) unconstitutional but found it had to be interpreted restrictively ("read down") to survive constitutional scrutiny.  The Constitutional Court on the other hand confirmed the unconstitutionality of section 49(2) in S v Walters 2002 2 SACR 105 (CC) and the section was declared invalid.  By then (as early as 1998) the legislature had already promulgated an amendment to section 49, but the amendment came into operation only in 2003 after section 49 had undergone intensive constitutional scrutiny.  Legal scholars and others raised serious objections against the amendment – some were even of the opinion that it created a "right to flee" and that the rights of perpetrators were protected to the detriment of law-abiding citizens.  The Department of Justice and Constitutional Development in 2010 drafted an Amendment Bill which was subsequently approved in Parliament.  This paper discusses and concludes on: the developments over the last years in the South African law with regard to the use of force in effecting arrest by the South African Police Service (SAPS); international policies and guidelines of the police in this regard; and the application of the provisions of the Amendment Bill in practice and the possible pitfalls in the application of the latter. 

    ScienceOpen_Log0348.png

References

Bibliography

Bruce 2003 SAJHR

Bruce D "Killing and the Constitution – Arrest and the Use of Lethal Force" 2003 SAJHR 430-454

Bruce 2005 South African Review of Sociology

Bruce D "Interpreting the Body Count: South African Statistics on Lethal Police Violence" 2005 South African Review of Sociology 141-159

Burchell Principles of Criminal Law

Burchell J Principles of Criminal Law 3rd ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)

Currie and De Waal Bill of Rights Handbook

Currie I and De Waal J The Bill of Rights Handbook 5th ed (Juta Cape Town 2005)

De la Harpe and van der Walt 2002 Speculum Juris

De la Harpe S and van der Walt T "A note on the practical implications of the Walters decision" 2002 Speculum Juris 303-311

Leggett 2003 SA Crime Quarterly

Leggett T "Save our Cops, Preventing Police Killings" 2003(4) SA Crime Quarterly 1-4

Maepa 2002 SA Crime Quarterly

Maepa T "How much might is right? Application of Section 49 of the Criminal Procedure Act" 2002(1) SA Crime Quarterly 11-13

Snyman Criminal Law

Snyman CR Criminal Law 5th ed (Lexis Nexis Durban 2008)

Van der Walt 2007 TSAR

Van der Walt T "’n Grondwetlike Oorsig oor die Gebruik van Geweld tydens Arrestasie deur die Suid Afrikaanse Polisiediens" 2007 TSAR 96-111

Register of court cases

Govender v Minister of Safety and Security 2001 2 SACR 197 (SCA)

Macu v Du Toit 1983 4 SA 629 (A)

Matlou v Makhubedu 1978 1 SA 946 (A)

R v Britz 1949 3 SA 293 (A)

R v Labuschagne 1960 1 SA 632 (A)

S v Bhulwana 1996 1 SA 388 (CC)

S v Makwanyane 1995 3 SA 391 (CC)

S v Manamela 2000 3 SA 1 (CC)

S v Singo 2002 4 SA 858 (CC)

S v Swanepoel 1985 1 SA 576 (A)

S v Walters 2002 2 SACR 105 (CC)

Register of legislation

Cape of Good Hope Ordinance 2 of 1837

Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996

Corrections and Conditional Release Act, S.C. 1992, c. 20

Criminal Procedure Act 31 of 1917

Criminal Procedure Act 56 of 1955

Criminal Procedure Act 51 of 1977

Judicial Matters Second Amendment Act 122 of 1998

The Criminal Code of Canada (R.S.C., 1985, c. C-46)

Transvaal Criminal Procedure Ordinance 1 of 1903

Register of government publications

Criminal Procedure Amendment Bill B39-2010

GN 1636 in GG 19590 of 11 December 1998 (Judicial Matters Second Amendment Act 122 of 1998)

Proclamation 54 in GG 25206 of 11 July 2003.

Register of international instruments

International Association of Chiefs of Police Model Policy on the Use of Force

United Nations Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials

Register of internet sources

Annual Report www.icd.gov.za

Annual Report 2006-2004 http://www.icd.gov.za/documents/ report_ released/ annual_reports/2006-2004/icd03report.pdf.

Annual Report 2008/09 (http://www.icd.gov.za/ documents/ report_ released /annual_reports/2008-2009/AnnualReport2008-09.pdf)

Boyle 2010 www.timeslive.co.za

Boyle B 4 Nov 2010 'Shoot to kill bill’ more than just a movie by late next year’ http://www.timeslive.co.za/local/article746030.ece/Shoot-to-kill-bill-more-than-just-a-movie-by-late-next-year [date of use 8 Nov 2010]

IHRCJS 2001 www.icd.gov.za

IHRCJS 2001 The use of force by members of the South African Police Service: Case Studies from Seven Policing Areas in Gauteng http://www.icd.gov.za/documents/report_released/research_reports/force.pdf [date of use 7 Jul 2010]

Media Statement Independent Complaints Directorate www.icd.gov.za

Media Statement Independent Complaints Directorate ICD in its Media Release on 25 March 2010 http://www.icd.gov.za /media_statements /25032010.asp.

Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development 2010 www.pmg.org.za

Department of Justice and Constitutional Development 2010 Draft Criminal Procedure Amendment Bill and Memorandum http://www.pmg.org.za/bill/20101014-criminal-procedure-amendment-draft-bill-not-certified-version [date of use 16 Nov 2010]

SAPS 2008/2009 www.saps.gov.za

SAPS 2008/2009 National Crime Statistics released by Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa during September 2009 http://www.saps.gov.za/saps_profile/strategic_framework/annual_report/2008_2009/2_crime_situation_sa.pdf [date of use 7 Jul 2010]

SAPS 2009/2010 www.saps.gov.za

SAPS 2009/2010 National Crime Statistics released by Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa on 21 September 2010 http://www.saps.gov.za/statistics/reports/crimestats/2010/crime_stats.htm [date of use 21 Sep 2010]

Published
2017-06-06
How to Cite
van der Walt, T. (2017). The Use of Force in Effecting Arrest in South Africa and the 2010 Bill: a Step in the Right Direction. Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal, 14(1), 137-162. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2011/v14i1a2548
Section
Articles